
Why Has Your Majesty Rebelled?
陛下因何造反
- Status
- Completed
- Length
- 1.9M Words
- Genre
- Historical
- Subgenre
- Alternate History
- Updated
- 3y ago
- Source
- Qidian
Stats
Tags
Synopsis
More by this author
In booklists 9
💗Quality General Store💗 Don't Miss These Favorites
A newbie list-maker who's been enjoying Qidian novels for seven years, and who likes fast-paced, imaginative, tightly structured stories... That's why my favorite novel is Er Mu's Let the Witch Go. I rarely finish books the way I did this one (I bought the complete edition on another account, which I use for writing novels), and I've read it three times. My current top recommendation is Starting from the Red Moon. The opening's pacing and imagination are a real pleasure. No idea when it turned
Eight Years of Reading: Recent Favorites, Just My Impressions, No Spoilers
After reading for so many years, I’d like to share the books I love. Feel free to browse. Ratings go from 1 to 5, with higher numbers being better. P.S. Some books have low fan rankings because I subscribed to them on QQ Reading using my main account. I’ve bought every chapter of every book I recommend.
My Recommendations
Novels I like or find interesting
All Worth Reading, with Something for Every Taste! Come on In!
Being able to sit quietly and read a good book, then recommend it to others, is a joy!
My Reading List
Putting together a list of books I've read that I could stick with. I'll write a summary when I feel like it. I'm going with the flow and will add more whenever I remember.
If You're Out of Books to Read, Come On In
I always feel like I've run out of books, even though there are plenty on this list I haven't finished.
【Immortal Herbs Grow Naturally, Plucked by a Skillful Hand】
What's the point of forcing things to grow before their time?
No Dynasty Had a More Legitimate Claim Than the Ming
No dynasty had a more legitimate claim to the realm than the Ming
A List of Good Reads
Worth reading
Readers also read
A Guide to Building Civilization in a Primitive Tribe
My Father Is Wen Tianxiang, and We Win the Battle of Yashan from the Start
Daming: Asking for the Throne at the Beginning, Lao Zhule Went Crazy
My Only Method: I Will Add More Points to Become Stronger at the End of Ming Dynasty
Slaughtering My Way Through the Marvel Universe: Starting with The Boys
Transmigrated to the Ming Dynasty to Become a Tyrant
Liu Xie: I Really Just Want to Abdicate!
The Road Less Traveled
The World of the Extreme Path: Tempering My Body Through Terror
The Sun and Moon Endure Forever
My Big Brother Is Called Zhu Chongba
A Plan to Revive the Northern Song
The Scholar's Comeback
Saving the Late Ming Dynasty
The Late Ming: The Transformation of Fish into Dragons
The Ideal Son-in-Law of the Late Ming
The Han Banner Will Never Fall
The Sect Leader Is So Handsome
I'm Not Chongzhen
Reader comments 29
Google Translate












































To be honest, there is no way to save the Song and Ming Dynasty. The biggest problem is not external but internal. After all, there is only one reason: the emperor has no money.
Let me talk about my humble opinion on the word ""
Many people think that "down official" is what officials call themselves when dealing with superiors. In fact, this is completely taken for granted. At that time, nobles and officials liked to use modest words when dealing with others. For example, the monarch calls himself "the widow", the princes and princes call themselves "little king" (not "my king") to officials, the queen mother and queen call themselves "old woman" or even "concubine" (not "their family"), and the princess also calls herself "concubine" (not "this palace") to her consort and courtiers. There are not many people in the world who have a higher status than them, or even none. They call themselves so just out of etiquette! The same goes for the word "". Ancient officials generally used this word whether they were talking to subordinates or superiors.
The three major poisonous points of this book for me: 1. The protagonist, as a reborn native who has seen modern cities, has no sense of the times in many decisions about development, and the logic is completely unreasonable. 2. The author's attitude towards Confucianism is disgusting🤢You only saw the good things about Confucianism and did not mention the bad things about Confucianism at all. In ancient times, Confucianism indeed strengthened ideas, but it also sealed them. Learn about Neo-Confucianism in the Song and Ming Dynasties. 3. The author repeatedly mentions the need to look at issues dialectically, but many issues are actually highly subjective. These poisonous spots avoid traps. Although they are poisonous, you can still see whether they have hit you.
Wow😯This introduction carries too much. If the author were a eunuch, send him down to accompany the Ming Dynasty!
The title of the book is a bit awkward, The Emperor Revolts? If there is no one who rebels against oneself, then it is called reform~_~
It's really embarrassing to see Chapter 77 killing corrupt officials, gentry and landlords! Many people agreed in the comments! Incredible! I can only see one ending! Just be countered by the landlords and gentry first! 1. Combined with the background of that era, it was so rotten that few butts were clean to the core. The only way to survive would be to make everyone feel insecure and unite against you, "Qingjun side" and "uprising". There are so many refugees who are just giving food to you and fooling around! The next day I'm sure there will be a governor who will cause the vassal king to revolt! It is Yuan Shikai who ranks second. 2. How many days have you been on the throne? You have to know that you have just created a vassal king, and now everyone in the vassal king is in danger! Do you think you are Lao Zhu? Does he have as many military exploits as Lao Zhu? There are so many life and death brothers like Lao Zhu? Is he as courageous as Lao Zhu? You have to know that Lao Zhu has ruthless people under his command! The next day there will only be a second Zhu Di who will rise up to "Qingjun's side"! 3. You have no money and no one. The feudal kings, landlords and gentry were all so rich that they could rival the country. All I can say is that it's really embarrassing! Don't take it for granted if you're bookish!
1. "The Ming Dynasty was destroyed by Li Zicheng, not the Qing army" I don't know how Li Zicheng managed to destroy the Ming Dynasty even after seventeen years of death. 2. "As long as the Ming Dynasty is not destroyed, it is impossible for the Qing army to enter the Shanhaiguan Pass." In 1644, if Li Zicheng did not march eastward, who would Chongzhen intend to send to prevent the Qing army from attacking Shanhaiguan from both inside and outside the Jimen entrance? Ginger? Tang Tong? Liu Zeqing? Gao Jie? 3. "Even if the Qin Wang army from all over the country arrived at the Ming Dynasty the day before Chongzhen was hanged, the Ming Dynasty would not be destroyed." Which Qin Wang army do you plan to count on to defeat Li Zicheng? Wu Sangui who persisted for only one day in Shanhaiguan and was beaten by Li Zicheng until he knelt down and begged Dorgon for help? Gao Jie who was chased by Li Guo from Tongguan to northern Shaanxi and then all the way to Yangzhou? Or Liu Zeqing, who was beaten by the rebel army during the Battle of Kaifeng? 4. "If the eunuchs were still in Chongzhen, they would not be unable to defeat the civil servant group and collect taxes from the landlords." Chongzhen did not need eunuchs, then Cao Huachun, Wang Chengen, Gao Qiqian, Wang Zhixin, Yang Jinchao, Who are Lu Jiude, Zhang Yixian, Li Guofu, Xu Jinzhong, Zhang Yuanheng, Cui Liangyong, Deng Xizhao, Du Xun, Chen Gui, Ma Yuncheng, Lu Weining, Bian Yongqing, Xie Wenju, Wei Bangdian, Niu Wenbing, Wu Jin, Chen Zhenyi, Cui Jin, and Yang Xianming? A palace maid? As for the idea that using eunuchs to collect taxes from landlords will make the country rich, I can only say that your imagination is really rich. 5. "The Ming Dynasty was not weak against the nomadic cavalry." This is true, but what's the use? What else could the nomadic cavalry do in the late Ming Dynasty besides reconnaissance and robbery? 6. "If Chongzhen did not suppress the eunuchs, plunder the rich's money, and prevent uprisings" That's really interesting. Maybe the country can be saved. After all, if the poor and the rich rebel together, maybe a new dynasty can be established and consolidated before the Qing army enters the customs.
I found that all time-travel novels have ignored one thing, and that is the reaction of the people in ancient China when they encountered foreign invasions. Most of the time, most of the people were numb, very similar to the late Qing Dynasty. The people had no national concept, and the national concept was extremely weak. When they encountered an invasion, they often looked at the war as a bystander. If you fight with the emperor, what does it have to do with me?
What the author writes is completely illogical. If a ruler wants to achieve his goal, he must find the right direction. He must first find a target, draw one faction to fight against another, and when you are ready, first make everyone equal. Can the emperor call for equality? For target practice, first set yourself up as a target? When you want to become a gentry, you don't have to look for so many names. You first find the one that is most unfavorable to you. Kill one thousand enemies and lose three thousand. Everyone is equal. First, you deny yourself as the emperor from the root. Then why should others listen to you and equalize land?
The best defense is offense! The reason why Zhu Yuanzhang and Zhu Di were able to kill tens of thousands of corrupt officials without any successful rebellion was because they had military power and the support of the people. (Historical research shows that Zhu Yuanzhang killed all the tens of thousands of officials in the Ming Dynasty three times during his reign)