The Great Song Dynasty's Great Detectives

In ancient times, if you wanted to be a detective, you had to be an official first. Without enough official positions, justice cannot be done at all. Comparing Di Renjie, Bao Zheng and Song Ci Di Renjie and Bao Zheng both became prime ministers and left countless legends. Song Ci was the originator of ancient forensic medicine. It was the ceiling of the bureaucrats in the ancient criminal investigation profession and was the most professional in terms of professionalism. But his official position is not high enough. Take a look at "The Punisher of the Song Dynasty" to see how aggrieved Song Ci ended up.

This kind of detective story is not very easy to write no matter what era it is in. The main reason is that it either has a thick background or it is hard on oneself. When writing about detective stories, you can't just write about detective stories, no matter what era it is.

After reading it, I can summarize the general content of this book as follows: Even if a dog dies, there is still a huge conspiracy behind it.

Looks good, looks good! The writing is smooth and the plot has ups and downs. The pace is relaxed and moderate, and the characters are well drawn. I only saw such a good book now... Qidian can you push less rubbish and more this... I am speechless.

It feels so amazing that this protagonist has become a fourth-level candidate for prime minister and is not married yet. In ancient times, it was also said that Xiu Qi Zhiping, the capital municipal party committee secretary who has not even started a family, should be his first job. Do others think this person has some physical problems?

For now, the male protagonist is not very old, so there is no need to worry about finding a girlfriend. He has status, the trust of the Queen Mother and the Emperor, and the support of allies, relatives and friends. He does not need the support of a wife family for the time being. At the same time, it is not martial arts, not romance, and the focus is not on emotional description. There is no need for a wife like a character to promote the plot. If it is just a vase, then besides The water characters have no effect on the main plot. Now even the role of the sister is slowly beginning to decrease. As the protagonist's initial "hang" guardian, the protagonist has grown up and slowly begins to fade. I mean the elder sister has faded. Suddenly a role like a wife is created. Wouldn't you feel awkward?

The atmosphere is not good

First of all, I am sure that the writing is very good, the plot is consistent and not repetitive, and the knowledge base is solid. The characters in the book have their own characteristics. Lu Yijian is sophisticated and calculating without losing the overall situation. The crime is solved with meticulous details, rigorous reasoning, and the case evidence is summarized in "The Collection of Abandoned Wrongs". It has a heavy feeling when reading. In addition, the protagonist solves the case and gets promoted smoothly along the way. In addition, the protagonist has a calm and calm personality, which seems to be very comfortable and basically has no poisonous points. However, I personally feel there are a few shortcomings. 1/It is recommended to write more daily descriptions, including the daily life of each character. 2/Some important characters felt that the descriptions were repetitive, simple, and lacked focus. For example, sister Xiang Ling basically has phrases such as "acting vigorously and resolutely", "the silhouette disappears in a flash", and "stands pretty at the window". . . Well, I personally feel that the description of such an important character is too simple. Sometimes it is even like the protagonist's intelligence tool. In fact, the emotions are not rich, and the character's personality is very single. 3/Insufficient rendering after solving the crime. After the Wu Jing Inn case, the case of poisoning the official's biological mother, and the case of the Eight Kings + Beggars Gang were solved. . . Forehead. . There was no response, the court did not award a reward, and the case involved many important people, so the reactions of all parties were not actually described. The above personal opinion is that I am also new to Qidian. It is my first time to read 400 chapters in Qidian at once. If you don't like it, don't say anything.

Oh my gosh, this book is so beautiful. The combination of solving crimes and the court does not involve any fancy tricks on the case, but also gradually affects the political situation of the court through the imperial examination. He is really just like the protagonist Di Renjie, his ancestor, a master of solving crimes and a sophisticated political master in the way he handles cases. He is not as rigid as Song Ci and Bao Zheng. Just like Mr. Di in "Detective Di Renjie", he has both legal principles and human feelings; and after becoming an official through the imperial examination, he gradually changed the court situation and improved the system with the help of modern research on the Song Dynasty. Whether it is the protagonist's behavior or the depth of the plot (of course, there is no rebellion in every case), he is really like Mr. Di Liang, Lord Di. He is flexible in handling cases, has legal principles and humane feelings, takes the overall situation into consideration, is mature and stable, and is never a fool. The goal is clear, the case analysis is very methodical, there is no personal heroism, and the division of labor is reasonable if we can cooperate in investigating the case. Facing power is not just about being tough, but about using all available resources, cleverly setting up situations, using various psychological tactics, leveraging strength, and ultimately achieving justice. Moreover, the protagonist himself is mature and steady, and he is far-sighted in doing things. He is appreciated by the emperor and several important ministers. He also has classmates and friends who share the same goals. He will go far in the officialdom and change more shortcomings of the Song Dynasty. There are no extra love scenes, it is clean and tidy. The male protagonist's sister is the rare female lead. The siblings work together and have a deep relationship. So far, the protagonist has no love scenes, which is really great. The plot focuses on the case and the court situation, with a combination of solving the case and political struggle. Interspersed with introductions to various related knowledge about the Song Dynasty, it is refreshing and not boring. It is really interesting. In response to the various questions raised in the book review area, I will answer from a personal perspective: 1. Some people say that the case design in this book is too showy and complicated. If the case in this book is too complicated, really, "Detective Conan" is a complete showdown. The case is too complicated and pretentious. It is much more serious than this book. It is so complicated and showy that there is no way to watch it. Not to mention that Kindaichi and part of the case copied it from "Young Bao Qingtian" 😊 In fact, the case in this book is not particularly complicated. The difficulty lies in the involvement behind the case. As a young man who is just starting out, how does the protagonist cleverly deal with the huge pressure, leverage on strength, and use various conditions at his disposal to finally find out the truth and deliver justice. 2. Some people say that people who traveled through the Song Dynasty and did not rebel were really spineless. However, the protagonist travels back to a time when Song Renzong was not yet in power, and the chaos of the Five Dynasties ended less than a hundred years ago. In the early days of the dynasty, it was difficult to stabilize, and the people wanted to live a good life and stop fighting. Rebellion at this time 🤔 is not the time when people rebelled in order to survive in the last years of the dynasty. And why, regardless of the specific circumstances, does the protagonist who travels through the Song Dynasty have to rebel? The protagonist traveled to the late Song Dynasty, and rebellion was quite normal. Traveling back to the peaceful era of the early Song Dynasty, what kind of country should we build after the rebellion? If it were capitalism or our current system, not only would the productivity not be achieved, but it would also be difficult to change the people's thinking for thousands of years. Especially since they are still living in a stage where feudal society has been doing well for thousands of years, it will be even harder to change. If a feudal dynasty is still established, how different will it be from the early Song Dynasty? In the early days of the establishment of a feudal dynasty that ended the war, the protagonist rebelled and suffered numerous casualties, just to establish a feudal dynasty similar to the original dynasty? The protagonists in time-travel novels may not all have the ability to lead armies in rebellion and create new worlds. If only protagonists with this ability can time-travel, it would be more convenient to directly search for imperial novels. And the protagonist doesn't do nothing. The protagonist is Di Renjie of the Song Dynasty. He became an official through the imperial examination and tried his best to improve the system and policies of the Song Dynasty bit by bit. He belongs to the reformist among the time travellers. (Moreover, the protagonist is the same age as Song Renzong. He won the favor of the emperor through crime-solving novels and incorporated court struggles into the detective novels. The immature Renzong learned the methods of political fighting on his own.) In the early days of the dynasty, he entered the official position through the imperial examination and won the emperor's favor. His official career was relatively smooth. At the same time, he used modern people's research on the Song Dynasty to learn the handling methods of "Detective Di Renjie", mature and sophisticated, and improved this relatively young dynasty in a good direction to avoid serious shortcomings in the future. 3. Some people say, "Take the deed of the land that the original owner wants to burn as your own." This is purely because I didn't understand the plot. In order to avoid excessive spoilers, I will only say one sentence: the title deed belonged to the original owner. After the protagonist's brother and sister avenged it, they burned it to pay tribute to the original owner. If you have different views, please open a new page to state your views 😳😳 This is my opinion.

Hmm... When I saw it on the shelves, there was nothing wrong with it except that it didn't look very good 1. The old problem of detective stories is that the crime techniques are overly polished and complicated for the sake of complexity, but they are basically doing more and making more mistakes 2. The character design is quite satisfactory, and the protagonist, supporting roles and villains are all standard templates, with nothing outstanding 3. The motive for solving the case is unknown. If the protagonist likes to solve crimes, it is strange that he is determined to take the imperial examination and refuses to accept the recommendation; if it is just to gain fame, then why bother with such trouble? If solving crimes is just about pursuing high-ranking officials and good salaries... Wouldn't it be strange to choose a detective as the theme? It's better to write about officialdom interspersed with solving crimes Basically, if you are a fan of mystery writing, you should find it good. If you are just looking for a casual book to read, I think you can skip it.