Steal the Immortal!

She's someone the original owner hadn't seen in a hundred years, and has absolutely no connection to the transmigrator, yet the protagonist thinks about saving her and licking her boots every day. He wants to find a magic elixir to save her even before he's cultivated Qi.

The protagonist has so many powerful abilities, yet he still can't defeat opponents even if they're just one level below him. It seems pointless to learn so many; why not just learn the easiest one to improve and directly suppress the opponent's cultivation level?

The author has some talent; the setting is reasonably coherent so far, and the writing style is quite good and consistent. The author has unique insights into men and women, and into human nature, making for a engaging and smooth reading experience. This is a rare good book these days, so its lack of popularity is understandable.

It's said that you get points for obstructing the path to immortality, but that really means you get points by killing people. And the higher the cultivation level of the person you kill, the more points you get. So why not just invest all those points into upgrading your cultivation techniques? Why keep adding points to those random skills? Do they even have any use in combat?

Instead of wasting time learning about those immortal pills every day, why not spend more time improving your cultivation first? Besides, I think the person upstairs is right. The male protagonist reincarnated and hadn't even seen Li Qianxue once before he started thinking about saving her. Why don't you use this energy to win over your senior sister?

Author, could you please stop suppressing the combat power? You've set the protagonist as a sword cultivator with a cheat code. I don't expect the protagonist to be able to cross a major realm to kill enemies, but you can't expect him to be unable to even cross a minor realm. He struggles to fight enemies of the same realm and can only defeat those stronger than him.

Let's talk about the novel *Stealing Immortals*: It's undeniably exhilarating, but the characters are just two-dimensional. I recently finished reading *Stealing Immortals* on Qidian, and my overall impression can be summed up in two words: readable and enjoyable.

Can the author please explain? Why doesn't the protagonist go to the outer sect to become an apprentice? Is there any benefit to staying in the servants' quarters? A bunch of useless people, they can't even contribute much to the cultivation of immortal seedlings. Is the outer sect small? There are only two masters available for apprenticeship.

When I first thought about stealing the immortal seedling, I assumed the author had chosen elixirs instead of using talismans or formations, indicating a hidden agenda. Given that the early and middle stages of the story repeatedly depicted cultivators mostly residing in Taixu and Yuxiao, why not create a elixir similar to cigarette smoke?

It's very well written; it's been a long time since I've seen a Xianxia novel of this quality. An engaging subplot involves the currently comatose prodigy and his childhood sweetheart, while the main plot revolves around the protagonist's leveling up and monster-hunting journey. Any seemingly illogical progress by the protagonist is automatically explained by his relationship with his childhood sweetheart. The subplots intersect and constantly influence each other, driving the story forward.