
Sherlock Holmes at Hogwarts
福尔摩斯在霍格沃茨
- Status
- Completed
- Length
- 3.1M Words
- Genre
- Western Fantasy
- Subgenre
- Modern Magic
- Updated
- 6mo ago
- Source
- Qidian
Synopsis
More by this author
In booklists 10
Standing the Test of Time
Books I think are pretty good, so I won't forget them.
A Quiet Harbor in This Restless World
🦝 Recommending novels I enjoy and am currently following. 🦊 These are the genres I mainly enjoy: fan fiction, cultivation, historical fiction, light novels, showbiz, and mystery-solving. 🐰 I tend to favor fresh, relaxing, easygoing stories with sound values and a touch of absurd humor, as well as other kinds of traditional feel-good fiction, rather than toxic feel-good drivel. 🦭 When I have time, I'll write more detailed recommendations. When I don't, I'll just add a quick recommendation. I'l
[Book Pavilion] Books That Brighten Your Day (Mostly High-IQ Male Leads with No Romance)
This list mainly features books with interesting male leads and supporting characters. Being entertaining is what matters most, so I'll even include abandoned stories if they're interesting enough. The most important thing in a good book is its characterization. Real diamonds can never stay hidden among grains of sand, and truly great people stand apart from the very beginning!
The Wizarding World of Hogwarts (Come On In, You Won't Regret It)
A handpicked selection of more than a dozen gems, chosen after reading nearly a hundred Hogwarts-style novels. (Five stars at most ✨✨✨✨✨)
Wild Boar Studio's Reviews
After ten years of reading web novels, I’ve found some pleasant surprises and some real stinkers. I hope to sample the wild variety for fellow readers, separate the unusual gems from the rest, and share what I find. This list evaluates books I’ve actually read across five dimensions: writing, plot, setting, characters, and ideas. Each is scored out of 10. These ratings are based entirely on my personal impressions and may not reflect the views of most readers. If you disagree... Sure, sure. You’
Trial-Reading Vanguard
They might be good, or they might not be.
No Holds Barred (Xianxia, Western Fantasy, Lovecraftian Horror, Urban, Gaming, and Anime)
The first book is what I'm currently reading. Updated whenever. I add just one book per author: the first book by that author that I read. For each type of fanfiction, I only feature one title, with the rest listed below. So far I've read Harry Potter, One Piece, Naruto, Detective Conan, and more. Updated whenever I think of it. Some picks are niche, and some are just personal favorites. There are plenty of gripes and personal opinions, so take them with a grain of salt. After all, tastes differ
Reading Update Tracker
What I like
Grain Grass Sauce, Hang in There!!!
Some books I think are good. I've read them all and thought they were pretty good.
A Bit of Everything, Read Whatever Catches Your Eye
There are no specific requirements for adding a book to this list. All ratings are entirely subjective. Recommendations are scored from 0 to 10: 1–2 means I don't recommend it, 3–5 means it's readable, and 6 or higher means I recommend it. Scores with a prefix are recommendations for a specific subgenre and shouldn't be compared with books from other genres. A score of 0 means I only read the beginning because of personal preference, but thought it seemed okay. (Try reading the first 20 chapters
Readers also read
Greece: I'm Really Not a Demigod
Warhammer: Notes from the Nord Hold
My Magic Has Entries!
Offering Cards to an Unkind Otherworld
Republic of China Film and TV: Starting as the Heir Who Squanders the Family Fortune
Harry Returns from Hogwarts Legacy
From Hogwarts to Strixhaven
Reborn in Hong Kong’s Entertainment World: I Turn Movies into Myths
Hong Kong: 1979
Hogwarts: Not Even Voldemort Can Stop Me from Studying
Hogwarts: A Little Transfer Student Shocks the School
Hogwarts: What Could a Little Wizard Possibly Do Wrong?
Infinite Evolution: A Different Path
Hong Kong Crossover: Five Points of Strength from the Start
I’m Out of Money to Protect Arad
I’m the Fiercest Across All Worlds
Three Kingdoms: I’m Zhang Xiu. What Can I Do for You?
Reader comments 47
Translated by Google Translate


















































Hermione is not suitable for Sherlock
After reading another 20 chapters, I still have to say that Hermione is not suitable for Sherlock. Sherlock is not someone who can bring emotional value to a partner. Bringing Hermione and Sherlock together can only make Hermione become Sherlock's follower rather than an assistant. What Sherlock needs is an elegant woman like his senior who can have a tacit understanding with him and can tactfully defend him after he makes harsh remarks. The relationship between Sherlock and his partner should not be a sweet and greasy love atmosphere, but the slightly sweet feeling of an ordinary old married couple living their lives. Just like when I got up in the morning and sat down at the table, my lover brought me coffee and breakfast. The two of them looked at each other and smiled, sat facing each other, finished their breakfast in silence, and then went out together in the sunshine at the door. What Sherlock wants is the feeling of an English gentleman and aristocrat. Hermione is really not suitable for him. Moreover, it is all Hermione's wishful thinking towards Sherlock. Sherlock has no response at all. I really hope that this relationship can be broken off quickly, otherwise the emotional drama will be a big failure. A book with a score of 9.5 Can only give a score of 7.5.
Taking a step back, why can't the heroine be Professor Moriarty
Hermione has a lot of plot, so she won't be the heroine. To be honest, I can't imagine Holmes getting along harmoniously with a woman. At most, he would be fighting wits and courage with a high-IQ woman like Irene Adler. If I write about Hermione as the heroine, I might as well write about Irene Adler Of course, this is purely a personal opinion.
I have read Chapter 140, and the writing is pretty good, but I have to say that Hermione is not suitable for Sherlock. Shylock's behavior is a bit gentlemanly, and his super intelligence gives him a temper that is beyond ordinary people, which can be said to be arrogant. In this case, a competitive girl like Hermione is not suitable to be paired with Sherlock. Now Hermione likes Sherlock as a girl's ignorant feelings, but I think it is not suitable for development. Sherlock's most suitable partner should be Slytherin's prefect. She has an elegant temperament and good intelligence that match Sherlock's ideals. She has been in Slytherin for many years and has not been assimilated, which shows that she has a world view that can be said to be correct. Slytherin's senior sisters are very good at dealing with people, which just makes up for Sherlock's sharpness in dealing with people. She can also try to tolerate Sherlock as much as possible. If these two people get together, it will be like an old couple getting along like an old couple who knows what to do without having to say anything to Sherlock. If Hermione and Sherlock were together, I don't think a sweet and boring love would be suitable for a rational person like Sherlock.
If a time traveler comes to this world
I want to laugh just thinking about the look on his face when he heard that the first Sherlock Holmes volume was "Sherlock Holmes and the Philosopher's Stone"
Regarding everyone's discussion about single-multiple-nothing
The reason why everyone has so much discussion about the odd-many-nothing here is simply that the plot of the protagonist and the supporting characters in the emotional drama is too blunt. 'Sherlock Holmes' is a protagonist with a high IQ. He is also a human being. Everyone knows his original story. It is normal to have emotional scenes. Hermione in this book is a bit too 'enthusiastic', which no one expected, so she may feel a little uncomfortable. And I think if there is to be an emotional drama, does 'Wooden Sherlock ། – _ – །' need some emotional changes now? The 'Three Years' in the novel has already well described the calm and straightforward Charlotte that everyone knows. Now should there be a 'Sherlock who is affected by emotions in the magical world' 🤔? I would like to make a digression here. I think the character expression of the heroine Hermione in the book "Chainsaw Man" is quite suitable. Ben Benfen is silently caring and accompanies the protagonist as a good friend. As a protagonist with a high IQ, the emotional scene should be 'you know I'm here, and I know you are here'. Obviously, the 'enthusiastic' Hermione here is not very popular with everyone. And I also found some interesting 'hidden settings' to share with you ૮ ºﻌºა The Sherlock Holmes here is a boy, not the Sherlock Holmes you see in film and television works or literary works. Those Sherlock Holmes are adults and have a very complete set of 'self-concepts'. When you are a teenager, you will be easily affected by the things around you. Whether 'Sherlock of Hogwarts' will become 'Sherlock the Detective' will be different from the moment you enter the magical world. ᐅAbout who the heroine is? Is there any? This kind of problem. My personal opinion is 'okay'. I just think the setting of Sherlock Holmes in Hogwarts is very interesting, and I really, really want to watch the Sherlock Holmes "Detective Night" event 😏. The above is my personal opinion. Oh, let me say one more thing. Many female protagonists in "Starting Point" have always been the audience of traffic. The author also knows that after all, traffic is definitely a good thing... Finally, I think the fusion of "Holmes in Hogwarts" is really great, very good, I like it very much ٩(๑^o^๑)۶
I don't care about the female protagonist, as long as the main plot is written, it's Sherlock Holmes after all, so I can accept a male female protagonist.
Writers who write about Sherlock Holmes, whether intentionally or unintentionally, tend to ignore one thing. His brother's power. In the book, Mycroft is the "most powerful man" in the British Empire during the Empire on which the sun never sets in the 19th century, and "the person who can directly represent the British Empire." If the riddle excludes political factors, in human terms, Holmes is the biological brother of the supreme leader of the Empire. In the original book, Lao Fu is happy to play there. Who dares to treat him as an ordinary person? His status is such that he can really say "I don't eat beef" and "You really do"
It's still about the female protagonist. Normally, it has nothing to do with humanities and multiple female protagonists. But he is Sherlock Holmes. I feel that multiple female protagonists are inconsistent with the setting. I feel that it is better to have only one female protagonist or no female protagonist. And about Harry. Harry seems to have clearly liked Zhang Qiu now, but it feels a bit strange that the author wants to write Harry with multiple female protagonists.
Curly Holmes is the most handsome
No rebuttal accepted