The Chivalrous Never Retreat

The three characters, each with distinct personalities and unique traits, are already a great work even without the fourth Calamity. I hope the author maintains good pacing, especially after the player's arrival. (On a side note, the dual female leads are fantastic, and the author's emotional portrayal is excellent.

Actually, I think it's better to find a useless internal skill book and quickly raise your cultivation level. That way you can become stronger quickly and then use the points to upgrade a powerful internal skill. Every time I read a novel, the protagonist learns a bunch of awesome skills, but their cultivation level increases incredibly slowly.

Very good. Keep up the good work, author! The setting and overall direction are excellent, the plot is clear, including the twists and turns common in fast-paced novels like those on Qidian: "My wife is actually so-and-so." The romance and character development are well-done, making the characters three-dimensional.

There was a martial arts novelist before, who wrote very well, but he was later killed in a fit of rage. I heard he was pickled before being killed.

Two issues. First, the system is designed so that reaching the pinnacle of each martial art grants a bonus talent. The goal is to use this talent to exchange for lower-level martial arts skills and maximize these buffs. Secondly, despite the setting that a major boss will descend in three years, resulting in many deaths, the protagonist currently shows no sense of urgency, instead of focusing on…

The imagery is so vivid 🦶, and the writing is truly excellent!

The players were a mistake, what a pity.

This first-rank skill is truly pathetic. A half-crippled grandmaster unleashing a ninth-rank critical hit in a fit of rage is just too overpowered. Ninth-rank skills shouldn't be mixed up with first-rank skills in any form.

Chapter 5's portrayal of the protagonist's change in mindset is exceptionally well-written; it's rare to see such a realistic protagonist. Some might find this plot point abrupt, but I find it very realistic. There's a video on Bilibili of a little girl being harassed by a thug on a bus. Wasn't this an unexpected event for the girl?

In the middle of the night, I lay in bed unable to sleep. A question had been troubling me for a long time, keeping me awake no matter what I did, yet I couldn't figure it out. "Why am I still a disciple?" Yes, I really love the book "The Hero Has No Footprints," I've been following it closely, I always give it a vote, and I even tip it from time to time. "But why am I still a disciple?"