Mining

Personally, I feel that the author's plot when describing the war scenes is too simple and not realistic and intense enough. The composition of the army is also somewhat rough. I suggest the author to read the two masterpieces of the Ming Dynasty, "Back to the Ming Dynasty and Become a Thousand Households" and "A Small Soldier in the Frontier Army at the End of the Ming Dynasty" written by Lao Bainiu. I personally think that all works of the same type cannot surpass these two books. It contains a very complete description of the composition of the Ming Dynasty's army. Moreover, the military organization and related administrative and economic structures established by the protagonists in these two articles are also very consistent with that era. In particular, the military establishment model heavily refers to the military training model of the famous Ming Dynasty general Qi Jiguang, so that the army of the protagonist in the book will not deviate from that time. There are too many eras and it seems too alternative. At the same time, the combat effectiveness of the protagonist's army is the best in the world at that time. Whether it is against the early Mongolian army and the Japanese army that invaded Korea, or when encountering the Eight Banners Army and the separatist warlords in the pass in the later period, they have the strength to crush them. I hope the author can learn useful experience from these two masterpieces, especially the clear explanation of the military structure of the Qi family. In order to present readers with a wonderful war art in the late Ming Dynasty.

The finance of the Ming Dynasty was mainly based on agricultural taxes before Wanli. Emperor Wanli knew that if he continued to collect meager agricultural taxes, not only would the treasury be insufficient, but the farmers would also be intolerable. Wanli still found ways to collect taxes from Jiangnan's capitalists. Since the Ministry of Household Affairs, which manages the external treasury, does not accept industrial and commercial taxes and only collects agricultural taxes, Wanli transferred the industrial and commercial taxes to the inner treasury. This is the so-called Wanli greed for money. In fact, the money used for Wanli's three major levies was industrial and commercial taxes from the inner treasury. Through the wonderful performance of the three cases of imperial attack on Hongwan and transfer to the palace, the Donglin Party finally took control of the government for the first time after Wanli's death. They immediately forced Taichang to abolish various industrial and commercial taxes. The role of the Donglin Party as the spokesperson of the capitalists was fully exposed. At that time, the development of various regions in China was uneven. Jiangnan's industry and commerce are developed, and there is almost no tax. Farmers in the northern provinces find it difficult to bear the high taxes, and even more so when natural disasters occur. The war in Liaodong was tense and the treasury was empty. What to do! ? It was against this background that Wei Zhongxian appeared. How to do it, of course, is to ask Donglin Party members to pay taxes. After a few years, the national treasury began to become full again. Shrines to Wei Zhongxian began to appear in various places. How can the Donglin Party sit still! Apocalypse's death is a good opportunity. Chongzhen sided with the Donglin Party. The Donglin Party wanted to kill Wei Zhongxian, but Chongzhen only relieved him of his duties and ordered him to guard the mausoleum. Later, Wei Zhongxian was sentenced to death, and Chongzhen buried him generously before his death. The Donglin Party is in power again. Of course, abolishing industrial and commercial taxes is the first step. As for Liaodong, how can we spend less money to do it. The shortage of wages in Liaodong is getting worse. Coupled with the layers of exploitation by officers at all levels, the soldiers got very little, and their morale was extremely low. The generals of the Ming army wrote memorials every day asking for money, but Emperor Chongzhen was at a loss. The Donglin Party accused Liaodong officers of improper command, ineffective combat, and embezzlement of military pay. Reducing expenditures often results in moral preaching; how can we not increase revenue! Of course, the Donglin Party will not increase industrial and commercial taxes, and the burden will naturally fall on farmers. Finally, the poorest farmers in the northwest revolted. He also captured Beijing and Chongzhen committed suicide. Wu Sangui led the Qing army into the pass, and the tragedy began.

The Ming Dynasty was rotten to the core from top to bottom, and the only way to go was to overthrow it and rebuild it.

The writing is very good. I hope the author will work steadily and finish it. Don't be a eunuch 😊

I can't stand watching the protagonist after looking at the identity of the protagonist at the beginning. Really, garbage will never have the sentiment to save the world and save the country. He will only lie on other people's bodies and suck blood. Even if he has the power in the world, he is just another Ma Bufang.

If the world is righteous, no matter which dynasty it is, the world will be righteous. Mingfen is also invincible, I always talk about this

This month's four votes are all given to the author. If you don't get good grades, you should write more carefully. Build popularity for the next book.

The author is really particular about the quality of his novels, but it is a pity that not only this book, but also the history genre, is no longer available. It is really a pity.

Is it necessary to explain so much? One word was not explained for ½ chapter

Is the modern system good? Which modern training method is the best? Tactics should be determined based on the weapons and environment at the time. Have you ever heard of Dong Shi Xiaoli? ? Do you know that suppressing seedlings encourages growth?

When I wrote about Li Zicheng, it was a bit ridiculous. Everyone who started with you went to work for Li Zicheng. He was just a refugee leader. I was really speechless.

Why do we have a nondescript army establishment? It is full of modern military establishment units, which seems awkward. Although the author explains the origin of divisions and brigades, the problem is that readers will directly associate it with modern military establishments, which is really uncomfortable. In the past, many authors used modern establishments to cover ancient armies, which would affect the quality of the book!

The protagonist is a bit indifferent to good and evil, and I couldn't stand watching the first chapter. The enemy is still an enemy when he is in trouble, and a villain is no longer a villain when he has a bad life. To a vicious old man who desperately wants to kill the protagonist and eat human flesh, the protagonist still needs a lot of pity, sympathy, and half a day! So disgusting😱😱😱😱😱😱😱😱😱😱😱😱😱😱😱😱 😱😱😱😱😱😱😱😱😱😱😱😱😱😱😱😱😱😱😱😱😱

Cavalry siege? The author couldn't come up with such a confusing trick like using mounted infantry who don't know how to ride and shoot to attack a city. I couldn't laugh or cry when I saw it.

This novel is so well written. I hope the author will work hard. By the way, I would also like to tell all my friends that the bones of the Han Dynasty that traveled through the Ming Dynasty will last forever. Friends can also take a look. The author already has a completed novel of 3 million words. Don't worry.

I read this book 2 months ago after seeing someone recommend it. The first two times I didn't appreciate the author's writing style, and there has been a serious book shortage recently. I picked it up again and endured the previous one to 200,000 words. I found that the author's writing style has improved significantly. After changing history as a giant butterfly, the historical deduction is basically reasonable. Now the more I read it, the more I like it. I specially recharged it today to reward the author. I hope the author can write this book seriously! Here are a few small suggestions, I hope the author will seriously consider them! 1: Try to avoid the appearance of a sharpshooter who shoots an enemy general in the throat from a hundred steps away. This kind of archery makes the Olympic champions holding modern compound bows embarrassed! If you have to show up, the distance should be 4 or 50 steps, so that those of us who are amateur bow players can have a clear idea. 2: A strict cavalry wall charge can certainly enhance the power of the charge, but after charging with the opponent's cavalry, they will still be intertwined like fingers, resulting in a melee, and only a few can penetrate the formation directly. 3: The protagonist's cavalry should use less lances. Looking at the major cavalry countries in modern Europe, France, Prussia, Tsarist Russia, Austria, Turkey and other countries' final mainstream cavalry weapons are cavalry epees and sabers. Apart from the popular wave of chivalry, few other countries can play lances well on a large scale. At the end of the Ming Dynasty, there were not so many military nobles in our country who had been trained since childhood who could handle lances well! Personally, I think the main reasons for the cavalry are that the hit rate is too low in cavalry clashes, the speed is not good when dropping down for melee, and the training is too difficult and takes too long. The advantage of attacking the infantry phalanx has given way to artillery as the level of infantry improves! (The Lancers can't do it either) The final reward is 5888 starting coins, I hope the author is not in jail!

Myung fans are similar to Korea. They can only brag, but in fact they don't understand history at all. It was such a dark era.

It feels like the notes at the end of each chapter are the author's hard work 😍 The author is really checking the information carefully.

This novel is so well written that I also recommend a novel to everyone. It is called Xiaopingmin in the late Ming Dynasty, and its pen name is Lao Bai Zhu. It is updated twice a day, constantly, and never ends.

It's obvious that I'm not a fan, but people misunderstood me when they saw the profile and didn't read it. Why bother? Please revise it. To be honest, I like the content of the book very much, but I really hate the introduction. Does Huang Taiji count as his hero? Author, are you Han Chinese?

Some of the emperors of the Ming Dynasty were lecherous, some were playful, and some were ridiculous, but none were weak. You see it like Emperor Chongzhen and the Son of Heaven martyred for their country; you see it as Zhengzheng being captured but never begging for mercy; you see it as Longwu dying on the battlefield; you see it as Shaowu being captured and committing suicide on a hunger strike; no reconciliation, no compensation, no cession of land, no tribute; the Emperor guarding the gate of the country; go and see if the king dies in the country.

I couldn't finish reading it several times. It's not that the author didn't write it well, it's just that it was too good. The war was too terrible and I couldn't bear to read it.

I can still read the writing, but the names of people are often mixed up, making it uncomfortable to read.

The Ming Dynasty, no matter how you say it, is the most courageous dynasty in recorded history, but it is just that you are in a feudal society and there is no way to change dynasties. Much better than Li Shimin or something like that. Do you really believe that the ancient prosperous times were not just trumped up? Even in modern society, people have starved to death since the founding of New China. I really don't believe that there was such a thing as a prosperous age in ancient times. Since he doesn't have enough to eat, he only has a little bit of backbone that deserves praise.

This book is more particular about the reasons why Chongzhen was defeated The novel is written more realistically. Like real history. It's a pity

"Looks like you still have night blindness"? May I ask how you can detect night blindness? I also experienced night blindness when I was a child, but I really don't know how to detect this problem. In addition, the cause of night blindness is generally insufficient intake of animal protein or fresh vegetables. However, although these bandits are hungry, they usually live by cannibalism. Human meat is also animal protein, so how can their vitamin A intake be insufficient? Where does night blindness come from?

I have nothing to contribute to the author, just 4 recommendation votes a day, because I am not rich either.

We are also poor, so we can do our best.

I feel tired about the chapter titles of Broken City 1, 2, and 3. I've lost most of my interest, so I can't be lazy with the chapter names.

As long as there is a big victory like the Manchu Qing Dynasty did, it is recommended to base Luoyang as the capital. As long as the Ming army is defeated in the field, and the Ming army is established in the Central Plains, farming for 2 or 3 years, and cultivating enough administrative talents, then you can go straight to Beijing like Li Zicheng did and lure most of the Manchu and Qing elite troops to enter the border for a decisive battle. However, after entering Beijing, you must concentrate the surrounding grain in advance to clear the remote areas and bring down the Manchu Qing Dynasty. . . .