The Night Watcher of Hogwarts

Indeed, the author is truly writing about the world of Harry Potter and the England of that era; this is evident in many details. For example, the detail of going from street to street collecting secondhand goods in exchange for goldfish and small toys—I saw that in an old British movie.

This book is really to my liking! 😍 1. It has a plot: it closely follows the original work in every aspect, but it's definitely not like other Harry Potter fanfictions that always focus on the trio (I'm really tired of that). Achieving this is extremely difficult.

The text is excellent, but the protagonist still can't use magic even at this point, which isn't my cup of tea.

Another day without any news from the author...

Two Harry Potter fanfiction authors on my bookshelf have gone missing. Did they go to Hogwarts for school?

There felt like there was too much vampire content. Things that weren't mentioned much in the original work should have been introduced gradually, not all at once. It left me feeling a bit confused. Everything else was good.

It's very realistic, but not appealing. Everyone knows it's very difficult for Muggles to become extraordinary, so the idea of ​​a werewolf who can still maintain his sanity is fine; the author put a lot of thought into it. Ultimately, the main character was too weak.

I've only read a few chapters, and it seems alright. But in the Harry Potter world, is it really necessary to become a wizard? Maybe going to the Church of England would be fine? After all, the original purpose of Hogwarts was to protect persecuted young wizards. Since they were able to launch an anti-witch campaign and achieve some success, it means there must be other extraordinary forces involved.

(May contain spoilers, proceed with caution!!!) I'm really happy to see new HP fan art featuring a non-human protagonist! A note beforehand: This is very well written, take a look! (The last book I gave a long review to was Hogwarts: Chasing the Storm, but that book was somewhat off-track and heavily padded. I'm still observing whether the author plans to continue writing it.)

I've never read any fanfiction like this where the character is mute and doesn't have any special abilities. I only checked it out after passing by it three times and seeing so many recommendations, so I think there's a reason for the many recommendations. The advantages are: good writing style, reasonable plot arrangement, novel theme, meticulous details, and faithfulness to the original work.