Against Water Margin: Liangshan Besieged

A rare gem in the Water Margin genre! The author insists that even niche themes are getting 160,000-170,000 words for testing now. Another factor is your book title. Keep going until you reach 200,000 words for the book test, then change to a more impactful title; it could very well take off!

I think this is a very interesting and enjoyable book. Some people might say, "They clearly captured and released him, but they just like pure, lighthearted, wish-fulfillment stories? Is it really that tiring to use your brain?" It's clearly all about psychological warfare, yet they still criticize it. Next time, I'll write a novel where everyone is killed in one chapter, and let's see how these people praise it then.

It's considered top-tier among all Water Margin fan fictions; the plot is never boring and avoids the pitfalls of other fan fictions.

Well written, but there's a major plot hole. Let's review Zhu Wu's achievements. 1. Chen Da was captured alive by Shi Jin, and Zhu Wu racked his brains to come up with a self-inflicted injury ruse (newbie protection period). 2. Shi Jin was captured in Huazhou, and Zhu Wu had no other choice but to rescue him through Wu Yong's trick of obtaining the Golden Bell. 3.

This is a fantastic Water Margin novel. The author depicts a scene from the late Northern Song Dynasty through Tian Hu's perspective. The author's writing is exquisite, and the characters are very vivid. Yu Deyuan, the subordinate general, is practically a mouth double; his mouth deserves the title of "Heavenly Mouth Star." He is also my favorite character. I hope the author continues to work hard and doesn't stop updating. Keep it up, author!

It's alright. The beginning was indeed enjoyable, both in terms of strategy and the evaluation and recruitment of characters from Water Margin. However, the overall narrative is too broad, lacking micro-level context. The author could refer to the latter half of "The Son-in-Law," especially the micro-level descriptions during large-scale battles.

I support the author; it's rare to see someone write about Tian Hu. Personally, I think the order in which the four bandits were attacked in *Water Margin* is problematic. If none of the four had surrendered, Tian Hu might have been the last to be subdued.

The princes born to the Empress from Hunchuan, who had a natural talent for green, were not princes. The princes born to Hunchuan before were princes. The rest of the writing is okay, but I really don't understand why she was so kind to the children from Tongchuan before. Ultimately, this has nothing to do with Tian Hu after your soul transmigrated.

The pacing is good, not frustrating, and the author has some clever ideas in the combat strategy. I haven't seen any major flaws so far.

Wow, this is pretty good, quite interesting. The perspective is great, well-chosen, and the story is very original.