A Proper Man in the Dream of the Red Chamber
红楼正经人
- Status
- Completed
- Length
- 1.4M Words
- Genre
- Historical
- Subgenre
- Alternate History
- Updated
- 2y ago
- English
- Request a translation
Synopsis
Stats
More by this author
In booklists 5
#No Fake Reviews# Recommending Veteran Readers, With Anti-Trope Plots and Wild Ideas #
No Fake-Review Dogs Series
Red Chamber Novels I’ve Enjoyed
2026.6.1 1. Most Dream of the Red Chamber fan fiction falls under alternate history, but it's fundamentally different from conventional historical fiction. The unique charm of these stories lies in the lives of the women in the garden. If a book uses the title Dream of the Red Chamber but ignores the fates of the women throughout, then the words "Red Chamber" in the title are meaningless. If it's just a historical novel wearing a Red Chamber disguise, it would be better to write straight-up hist
Top-Rated Red Chamber Novels on Qidian
I love Dream of the Red Chamber and enjoy reading stories inspired by it. The books I choose are ones I've read carefully. They may not all be great, but each has something distinctive and is worth recommending or warning others away from.
A Collection of Dream of the Red Chamber Stories
⭐ Qidian has so many Dream of the Red Chamber stories that this list mainly features completed works I consider excellent or at least readable, though I'll also include a few outstanding ongoing fanfics. ⭐ Both male-targeted and female-targeted completed works may be included. ⭐ Dropped books won't be added. ⭐ Completed books have an overall rating at the end, ranging from dependable reads to masterpieces. Feel free to recommend new Dream of the Red Chamber stories in the comments! I really w
(O>_<o) Great Book Recommendations 1 (O>_<o)
Collecting some entertaining reads. Based on my personal tastes, I'm recommending good books with no System and a single love interest, mostly historical stories and light novels. Most are new books. Hope you enjoy them!
More like this
After the Rebellion Succeeded, I Learned This Was the Story of the Red Chamber
Dream of the Red Chamber: Power Over All, Joining Daiyu to Save the Empire
Dream of the Red Chamber: From Foot Soldier to Ruler of All
Dream of the Red Chamber: I Found a Lin Daiyu
The Scholar of the Dream of the Red Chamber
The Jia Family of the Dream of the Red Chamber
Rising Above the Rivers and Mountains
Dream of the Red Chamber: Daiyu and I Swapped Bodies
Spring in the Red Chamber
The Charismatic Concubine’s Son of the Red Chamber
Drunk and Enchanted by the Dream of the Red Chamber
Striving in Dream of the Red Chamber
Aren't You the South American Tyrant? Why Are You Fighting the Empire?
Emperor of Longevity: Emperor Xian of Han
Do We Not All Have the Same Blood?
Great Han: I Kicked Liu Bang Out of the Car from the Start
In the Americas, From Security Guard to Call of Duty
Rising Above the Rivers and Mountains
Story of Minglan: I'm a Son of the Xu Family
A Literary Master in Ancient Greece
League of Legends: Being an Honest Support Is Boring, Isn't It?
A Minister of the Jia Clan
The Dream of the Red Chamber's Military Governor
Dream of the Red Chamber: I Truly Had No Plans to Rebel at First
Reader comments 26
Google Translate
Are there any other Dream of the Red Chamber novels with a single female lead? There are too many harem elements in Dream of the Red Chamber.
This book is above average among many adaptations of *Dream of the Red Chamber*, without any major flaws. The beginning was decent, raising expectations, but the later parts lacked truly exciting moments, making it just passable. Even if Daiyu and the protagonist were engaged, their intimacy couldn't be as pronounced as in modern times; the time travel aspect has a foundation from a previous life…
It's well-written, but it's lacking. I still don't know what the protagonist wants to do, what their goals are, or what they're striving for. They're constantly passively reacting to events, lacking a central theme and initiative.
Regarding the age setting: based on the first year of Jianwu. Main characters: 16, Daiyu: 11, Baoyu: 12, Baochai: 13, Yingchun: 13, Tanchun: 11, Xichun: 8, Xiangyun: 10, Jia Huan: 8, Jia Lan: 5 years old.
I once envisioned using the framework of *Dream of the Red Chamber* to write a fictional historical novel, rather than a harem-style play that abandons ethics. This book is like something that stepped out of my mind, fulfilling my previous imagination.
In ancient times, one needed a harem to succeed. In ancient times, the imperial harem was a symbol of power and also a means of winning people's hearts. First, to succeed, you need the help of others. How can you gain their trust? Political marriage is the simplest way. There are also more complex methods, such as binding interests together.
This book has one excellent point: it clearly distinguishes between wives and concubines. Many books, however, try to fool readers by presenting a harmonious facade without any distinction between seniority and juniority.
Start a thread If you have something to say about Wu Sangui, just say it directly. There's no need to use so-called internet slang. I'm not ignorant. Besides, anything I don't understand will be deleted and I'll ban you!
Is it really appropriate to keep provoking the nobles under such internal and external troubles? Is the emperor stupid and the retired emperor stupid? Isn't this digging their own grave? The nobles generally control most of the country's military power. Just considering the fact that the earl's line has ended, if the royal family had any sense, they should have reacted immediately and given the nobles an explanation.
Author, this book is definitely to my liking. It's a dilemma. I've read too many harem novels and want something lighter, but writing about Dream of the Red Chamber inevitably involves the women of the Jia family. I also dislike original female protagonists. I'm a Daiyu fan and just want to find a book with a single female protagonist, but I haven't found one. It's so frustrating. Can you tell me about the female protagonist in this book?