Judge Holding the Lamp

The writing is excellent and the settings are good, but the biggest problem is that the rhythm is poor Our strong ones will be defeated in actual combat, our wise generals will definitely miss the mark when approaching the battle, and our strategy will definitely make mistakes; the enemy will always have a back-up plan, and the back-up plan will still be there. There is a backhand, and there is a backhand of the backhand. If we really don't have the backhand, we will still let the enemy run away for one reason or another Any little villain can jump for hundreds of chapters, and he can't take it away every time. If he takes it away, there will be new ones. The forces jumped out to protect him The protagonist is always trying to die, and he suffers every time he tries to die, and then he will continue to do it next time, while thinking about whether he is too suicidal I read it after finishing the book, and I can't stand it. , If you were following it, you would probably have given up long ago. Such good writing has been wasted. I hope the author's new book will not be like this. It doesn't matter if you go shopping in Goulan, but in a war or crisis, you have to insert a story about Goulan. It's inexplicable.

I have been following several of Shala's books. Regardless of the fact that the first book was too jerky, from Give Me the Name of God to this book, The Lamp Judge, the biggest advantage is that the villains and supporting characters all have IQs, and the stories told are very exciting, and the settings are also very good, whether it is the setting of the previous book Goldfinger, or the grudge between this book and Qiongqi and the story behind Qiongqi. However, some supporting characters, especially female supporting characters, are too stereotyped. For example, when talking about Lin Qianniang, gentleness, Xia Hu, caressing, princess, and overbearing, but if this is the case, these characters will appear too pale, with no backstory and no growth. You can consider adding some extra stories to detail the growth story of the supporting characters. Even the protagonist has certain problems like this. His combat power is indeed improving, but his character and concepts don't seem to have grown much. Similarly, you can also write extras from the perspective of the villain. After all, most villains are not evil because of evil. If the stories behind these villains can be depicted, the characters will be more fleshed out. For example, Qiong Qi's portrayal is good. There is also the problem of the female protagonist. I feel that Shala wants to open a harem for the male protagonist, but in fact she cannot control so many female protagonists/female supporting characters. Sometimes she forgets about a certain female protagonist. You can consider the details. Two or three are enough. For example, in this book, Xia Hu is said to be the main palace, but her impression is not particularly outstanding. She is almost the same as Tao'er and the princess.

​ Emmmmm let me talk about the conclusion first. It was good to read, but I gave it up several times. Apart from reading it carefully at the beginning, I jumped a lot later. I would like to share my thoughts on why the popularity of this book does not match its content. There are actually three points. The first one is that the protagonist upgrades too slowly. Of course, it would be fun to write this, but the protagonist has not dared to confront the villain once, and it is useless even once (crying to death)! The protagonist's strength has always been limited to self-preservation. On the contrary, the villain seems to have no bottleneck in upgrading his skills one by one. Sometimes I really want to think that the protagonist should just practice the evil way or something. It is strong and fast. The judge's way is special but really good (this is because the protagonist cheats so fast, no wonder the Taoist sect has withered). This makes it difficult to control the rhythm. Of course, the author is very good, and the protagonist's strength is matched every time, but it is only a passing grade, which is really a bit uncomfortable The second is the character of the protagonist, which is actually very good, but... I feel very inconsistent. Sometimes the protagonist has wisdom, but sometimes he forgets the principle of getting rid of evil, and always gives the villain a chance inexplicably. The villain is like Xiaoqiang... Then there is the issue of the protagonist's attitude towards women. Well, how should I put it? It's so frivolous. I'm not saying it's not allowed. But there can be romantic young men in the world, but the fate of a country cannot. The simplest way to put it is that the protagonist is a national idol after all, so will everyone imitate him? (Based on the ignorance created by the author's background, is it possible for the Nufu Cult to be popular? Do you think the entire Zhiqiong Cult will be possible by then?)... Actually, I think Chu Liuxiang is a good template. There are many girls around her, and the relationship is good, but most of them are in love but not polite. This kind of girl can at least be a national idol on the surface. How are Zhiqiong and Taozi doing now? I don't think it's appropriate to accept one after another. And these are all weaknesses, not only the strength of these girls will be threatened, they will be used as hostages or something. You see, if the false news of Zhiqiong's death spreads, the world will be in chaos. Then if I am a villain, I will make good use of this news. On the one hand, I will entangle Zhiqiong, and on the other hand, if the false news slips out, the world will be full of knives. It is really... Emmm The third one is the imbalance of the forces of good and evil. Every time the villain fights against the decent, he always jumps over the wall. How can I suppress this? This is really the reason why I give up repeatedly. How can the decent be like this? The villains have all the high-ranking people, and there is no shortage of power and money. Let's look at the casualties of the decent people... The five true gods are really behind the scenes. Except for the white tiger who screamed, the remaining believers will be gone and they don't care... On the contrary, the villain is really a positive one. I always feel that this attitude should be exchanged. How come there is such a truth that even the top officials are rebelling but the world is still decent... That's all, the author is still awesome, come on!

This is the first novel that I have subscribed to until completion, and almost all the monthly tickets during the subscription period were donated to this book. I first discovered it on Daily Guide, and found that the quality was unexpectedly high. The characterization, plot, and setting are all excellent, especially this setting. I have read too many fantasy and fantasy novels, and all Chinese-style novels are generally Confucian, Taoist, Buddhist, martial arts, etc., Which are too similar. However, this novel has many interesting Taoist sects, and it has a very authentic taste. From my reading experience, this should be the first work after Mystery whose power system has won my heart. In addition, there are many characters that are well developed, such as Yu Luo. In just one or two chapters, the foreshadowing laid out in the previous chapters can be connected together while the characters are also vividly drawn. The plot is quite royal and passionate. Generally speaking, it can progress smoothly as long as the author doesn't get sick. In this regard, the book has exceeded its task. Of course, while there are many advantages, there are also flaws. Excluding minor issues such as typos and some slightly heavy-handed descriptions, there are roughly three points that make me regret the most. First, some Taoist techniques are incomplete, and many of them have not been written out. Moreover, some techniques appear too infrequently. They are more like temporary services for a certain chapter and a certain plot, and will be offline after use. Some techniques have inconsistent corresponding levels. This is a flaw that should be avoided. Second, the final plot progressed too fast, and there were too many foreshadowings that were laid in the past that were not used in the end. For example, Yuan Chengfeng, who was supposed to be a hero after the criminal was rescued with great efforts, could no longer play a role in promoting the plot. In the end, he was shamefully off-aired and was caught. He was a bit of a clown, which ruined the image created earlier. In addition, the ending chapters are a bit sloppy and end too suddenly. I was completely confused after reading this review this morning. Finally, there are shortcomings in the description of the high-ranking duel. For example, why did the angry ancestors save Liang in the first place? In the end, they couldn't figure out why the dignified true god insisted on saving a star. What is so special about Liang? Moreover, the angry ancestors also involved themselves in it. It seemed that this true god was too cheap. As for the final decisive battle with the Sinner, the Sinner was made too oppressive in the early stage, and in the end he was almost killed by Zhi Qiong alone. I think there are still many areas for improvement. Of course, this kind of description is much better than the kind of purely idealistic duel where the author can write whatever he wants and let himself go. In general, this is a novel worth reading. It is a pity that the current results cannot match this quality. Thank you Shala for your companionship over the past year or two. I hope the next book will be as appetizing.

I started reading "Xue Gang Against the Tang Dynasty" in the third grade of elementary school. I have been a bookworm for decades. I would like to briefly discuss the author's level (what is the author's name), as follows: First of all, this book has nothing to say about the plot, writing skills, and ideas. Among the few books I am currently following, this book can be ranked among the top three in comprehensive evaluation. The plot is better than "The Demon Painter", but the writing skills are much worse. The second one is "Show Me, Lord Lord". I pinched my nose and read about 400 chapters before skipping to the finale. Compared to this one, it feels like it was written by a different author. Ps: I haven't read the author's other books. Once again, I saw in the comment section that this book was not as good as "Da Feng's Watchman", so yesterday I read about forty chapters with anticipation. To be honest, it's just catering to the noob's rhetoric, and it's really not that good. Finally, there is the question of why the books are good but the grades are not good. If you don't cater to novices, how can the grades be good? Finally, I hope there will be more and more Laobai!

This is an excellent work, an epic portrayal of human nature, vivid and vivid, mainly aimed at punishing evil and promoting good. Volume 1 of White Tiger Killing Road mainly focuses on the portrayal of human nature, including scoundrels in the market and greedy parents. What is even more impressive is the chapter of Sheng Nian, about saving another person after punishing evil, which is one of the highlights of the book. Volume 2 of Zhuque Shengdao mainly focuses on the political struggle in officialdom. Some book friends have been saying why not kill the official family directly. Compared to the protagonist, he has an unshakable position and is one of the biggest villains in the book. It takes a long time to bring him down. Many book friends say that the judge is the second person to watch, but there is still a big difference. Although from the outside, they all have an upgrade system and are protected by a boss in the early stage. But this book has fewer cheats and is more realistic, so the second volume didn't feel so satisfying. Moreover, this book pays more attention to punishing evil and promoting good. The various aspects of the world and the portrayal of human nature are really well done.

It's a very nice novel, every foreshadowing is recycled, and the story is very complete. I feel that they are some of the best novels in recent years. Compared with the later chapters of Da Feng Da Gong Ren, they are more readable and have a more complete story.

I've been watching it for a month and I finished it in one go. It's so heartbreaking and exciting! Give away all the tickets! I hope Shala will do more chapters😭😭😭

Great book, absolutely great book! This is the best book I have read in all my years at Qidian. The characters, plot, writing, and depth are all impeccable! After reading the first volume, remember it is the first volume. If you feel bad, just come to the comment area to criticize me! I don't believe you didn't say yes!

I think it's quite interesting. I've read some books.

After reading novels for so many years, there are very few novels that I can really read into. There are only a few novels that I can read into and read again and again. This is the only novel where every plot is vividly remembered after reading it again and again. The judge said, "The Lantern Man, he stands between life and death, defending heaven and justice. I don't deny his cunning and cruelty, but because of him, I believe in heaven, and I believe there are heroes in this world!" I still remember the moment when Xu Zhiqiong held a lantern and fought to the death with Liang Yuming. I still remember the scene when Xu Zhiqiong held a lantern and killed Liang Xianhong angrily. I remember the lights of the Hanako Festival illuminated the stars in the sky. I remember Xu Zhiqiong. Dressing up as a mouse made Miaoying give up her evil thoughts. I remember him killing Prince Tunu in anger and supporting Daxuan's backbone. I remember him fighting to the death for the people of Yunzhou. I remember Xu Zhiqiong raised the lantern again and again and shouted, "Lantern Holder Holds the Lantern!" It would be great if there were more works like this! If there were more works like this, I would stay at the starting point every day and never leave!

Encourage people to do good? To be poor: No one knows better than me! !

To be honest, I was very worried. Xu Zhiqiong's temperament was a bit insidious. I thought he would continue to take advantage of Lao Chen, but I didn't expect that he would ask for a bowl of drink. Chen Shuncai, straighten your waist!

Haha, who has made history in the past three thousand years, Hengdao is the first one

It's really weird. You can't tell the taste of Qidian readers. This book is not bad at first glance. It's not even a high-quality book. I've read half of it and it's well written. However, I feel that my relationship with women is too weak. I always feel like I just passed it by talking and laughing. The emotional scenes are just you kissing me and driving by, but it doesn't leave any deep impact. Anyway, as I continued reading, I saw that the author was writing well. I continued to read and caught up with the progress immediately.

Pu Luo is really a divine book, this book is hard to describe in one sentence

After reading novels for so many years, there are very few novels that I can really read into, and there are only a few novels that I can read deeply and be willing to read again and again. When I read it repeatedly, every plot is vividly remembered. This is the only novel. Judge Dao, the lantern man, he stands in the realm of life and death, defending heaven and justice, because of him, I believe in heaven, and I believe there are heroes! I still remember the moment when Xu Zhiqiong held a lantern and fought to the death with Liang Yuming, I still remember the scene when Xu Zhiqiong held a lantern and killed Liang Xianhong angrily, I remember the lanterns at the Hanako Festival The light illuminated the stars in the sky, I remember Xu Zhiqiong dressed as a mouse and made Miaoying give up her evil thoughts. I remember him killing Prince Tunu in anger and supporting Daxuan's backbone. I remember him fighting to the death for the people of Yunzhou. I remember Xu Zhiqiong raising the lantern again and again and shouting, "Lantern Holder Holds the Lantern!" It would be great if there were more works like this!

I don't know what evaluation to give at the moment. To say good things about him, he has a unique combat system, novel narrative logic, and the jokes are not obtrusive. To say he is bad, the villain often loses his wits, logic is often disconnected, and the ending is child's play. Perhaps it should be said that it is stronger than the average, and it is average than the strong.

The biggest problem with this book is that it feels uncomfortable to read.

The story is a good story. The main script is very good. It is rare to see the author of Qidian write such an excellent plot. But the writing style is quite obscene. The whole book revolves around playing with women, dancing and visiting brothels, including basically all the gods and demigods in it. They are all carved out of the same mold. The atmosphere of the city is very strong. The flavor of the common people is very strong. There is no sense of spirituality or seriousness. It feels that there is no style. It is very annoying after watching it for a long time. It feels like a history of the capital city romance of young ruffians and old scumbags, with some folklore and ghosts added.

Comments from old bookworms: I can read it, the first volume is excellent, and the second volume is very good. It can be seen that it is generally an imitation of the plot of Da Feng's watchman, but the description of the judge fits the underworld, making people feel more immersed in it, which is excellent. The protagonist in the first volume meets a confidante, enters the main entrance of spiritual practice, and has a good boss to lead the case. I have to say that it is better written than Wei Yuan of Dafeng. In the end, he desperately kills the prince and summons the white tiger, which brings a perfect ending to the first volume of the article. But at the beginning of the second volume, it was very strange. It was too strange. Let me emphasize that it was too strange. What did the protagonist do when he watched two thousand people die? He went to the palace with the prince and princess and entered a famous family without any worries; even though he knew clearly that Gongsun Wen's third-grade assassin came to assassinate him three times, he still managed to avoid it once without any worries; even though he knew clearly that it was the Dog Emperor who did it, what on earth are you waiting for? Are you waiting for the Dog Emperor to reach the third level to kill people? I can understand and accept this kind of plot. It is well written and the killing of the emperor is the climax, but you wrote it too long. Just before you see the plot of the emperor conceiving the king is all played out, the protagonist is still playing with the prince. Where is the protagonist in the first volume who kills decisively and knows everything? Without the protection of the boss, your IQ will drop completely, right? Really, I think this book is quite a masterpiece, and it was almost the second one. However, the image of the protagonist in the second volume was half ruined. I haven't read the rest yet, and I can't help but feel unhappy.

Let me talk about my rough impression of this work (written casually) First, the Angry Ancestor, the Sinner, and the Four Evils are the ultimate support of the villains. They are still mysterious at present, and the information can only be told over and over again; Second, the true gods, the ones mentioned in the first article should be able to compete with the true gods in terms of strength (that is, the residual, anonymous) (hidden), and then Suzaku is sleeping and has no time to control, the current situation of Xuanwu is unknown, the white tiger roared once and then stopped moving, Canglong doesn't know what he is doing, and finally, the hozen is also the first to appear. As the true god of the criminal judge, his own Xingxu (the master's command should be a first-grade one) and Qiongqi's remnant soul were seriously injured in the fight, and there has been no expression for so many years? Seeing that I could only explain that the true god was in trouble before, and he came out to grab a handful. There is no reason why the true god can be resurrected and the souls of the scattered people cannot be saved. So it can only be explained that he has already taken action, so the master fell asleep to heal his wounds (he even thoughtfully hung up the lock), so why didn't he kill Long Xiulian? Or is it the experience package left for the protagonist? It doesn't make sense; Thirdly, I feel that the four evil ways are a bit ridiculously strong. The bad guys are almost seeping through the sieve, and the various skill effects are one after another. The righteous way can't be twisted into a rope. The difference in strength is a bit big. The capable good people are losing points one by one, and what's going on with the Confucianism and Mohism? Forget about this Mo who only entered Taoism through mechanisms. After all, it is people who use tools to do bad things, not tools. Confucianism and Taoism with great righteousness almost have the word "stooge" written on their faces. It is recommended to strictly investigate Confucian stars;

I hope to give Zhi Qiong a suitable ending. It doesn't necessarily have to be good, but it must be worthy of his original intention and mission, as well as the hardships and ups and downs along the way. Even if it is a knife in the end, I will accept it. From the initial curiosity to the daily reading, Judge Holding the Lamp has accompanied me through my last year of high school. It is indeed a good book, at least I think so. It has been almost three years since I came to Qidian. This is the only novel that a poor student like me is willing to spend money to read. Whenever I think of Xu Zhiqiong's sentence about the judge, I feel a sense of excitement in my heart. If there were more people like the protagonist in life, then the world would definitely become a better place. This is my first time to write a long review. I am not good at words and I really don't know what to say. I originally planned to wait until the end to say it, but because I was so bad at the college entrance examination, I plan to repeat it and school is about to start, so I will say a few words in advance. When Judge Holding the Lamp talks about this, I estimate that 2/3 of the plot is gone, from watching pirated copies for free to spending money to support the genuine ones. If possible, I hope I am the judge who has finished reading and finished the book, instead of sending congratulations after more than ten days. After the college entrance examination next year, if The Lamp Judge is finished, I will make up for the full subscription. If it is not finished (that is the best), I will first make up the full subscription, and then subscribe until it is finished. Finally, I wish the Lamp Judge becomes more and more popular, I wish Shala will become a great god soon, and I wish everyone's wishes will come true!

The Judgment Dao system is too fragile. If there is a conflict with the Underworld Dao, it will immediately burp.

The first 500 chapters of this book seem to be okay, but after the 500th chapter, it doesn't work. The protagonist has a bit of a holy mother's heart. Looking at it...

The plot design is one after another, the story develops in waves, there is almost no idle writing, and there are foreshadowings everywhere. It is indeed a very good book. The problem is that the reading pace is really too tight, one thing follows one thing, one crisis follows another, and there is basically no chance to breathe while reading this book. I am still nervous after reading the whole book. If this was a book of hundreds of thousands and one million words, then I would have nothing to say, and I would have to praise it for being perfect, but this book is nearly four million words long, which is four million words. Tired, although this book is good, reading it is so tiring. I feel like I am trapped in a quagmire of conspiracy that is entangled with the whole world, with no way to escape and no place to exert force. This kind of reading experience is extremely cold and suffocating. Although the author has also used the protagonist to flirt with women, or created several angry comedians to dispel this experience, the protagonist is still a virgin for more than one million words, making this kind of dissolution seem ridiculous. Another thing that makes me dissatisfied is that in the author's writing, it is not important whether he is hostile to the protagonist, whether he has really harmed the core interests of the protagonist, or even tried to kill the protagonist, or it cannot be used as a "decisive factor" in whether the author wants this character to be killed by the protagonist. The author does not intend to satisfy us in this regard, but is obsessed with describing the important characters' own positions and the legitimacy of their actions, so as to make these supporting characters more three-dimensional and fuller in image. For this reason, several characters who have been in trouble with the protagonist several times, and even wanted to kill the protagonist, have been forgiven by the author's arrangement of the protagonist. To be honest, I am very resistant to this arrangement in my heart, even if it is reasonable in the plot. This is a good book and definitely worth subscribing to. However, because of so many disappointments and so much discomfort in the reading experience, I am extremely unwilling to spend money to subscribe to it in full. This is also the reason why after I finished reading outside, I didn't subscribe to the full subscription here, but only replenished a part of the subscription. I'm willing to spend money on it, but I'm only willing to spend so much on it.

Xu Zhiqiong

There are many books that won't make the monthly list, but that doesn't mean it's a good book.

I really don't like the plot of the six princesses cleaning up their innocence. Does our male protagonist have to be with a princess? I used to have a good impression of princesses because old books described princesses with beautiful words such as beauty and kindness. The more I understand history, the more I realize that marrying a princess is really not a good thing. Even people with integrity in ancient times did not want to marry a princess (most of them). You retort that the background of the story is different, and I don't like the current setting of the princess either. At the beginning, the male protagonist annoyed the princess, so the princess sent someone to kill the male protagonist. Such a person who decides the life and death of others according to his own preferences is later cleared up and develops an emotional line with the male protagonist. It is really a poisonous point. Moreover, this princess's cultivation level is not low, and she is not as stupid as Princess Da Feng Lin'an. When describing the killing of the emperor later, it is also said that the imperial power is deeply rooted in the hearts of the people. If you marry such a princess to serve, wouldn't the other wives of the hero become the role of maids. If you want me to clear it up, just clear it up. Don't mess with the emotional line, or the princess just likes the male protagonist unilaterally. The male protagonist can't tolerate such a princess to think about his wife, isn't it? I have finished reading the second volume, and I don't know the plot behind it. I really don't want the relationship between the sixth princess and the male protagonist to develop later.

Coming from the Lord of Puro, it is not easy to find a good author