The Legendary Hogwarts Scholar

Why do some people always think that the age of the protagonist in rebirth novels is the sum of his two lives? Mental age is related to experience. If he was a primary school student in the first life and still a primary school student in the second life, then he is actually a primary school student. I think the protagonist's actual age is an uncle Are you kidding me?

This book is much better than those fans who treat readers as fools. The details are handled very well. I have read a book where the protagonist of Harry Potter made a lot of money by using the conversion of gold galleons and pounds. In this book, you fixed the bugs. I felt very comfortable reading it. One monthly pass every day, all for you. I hope I can give you the essence.

My favorite is the plot where Jon designs Umbridge and helps the Order of the Phoenix win the battle in the Department of Mysteries. I feel it is the male protagonist's crowning moment in the book. It's really rare. After writing 600,000 words, the plot is still high. What was particularly moving was Jon telling Hermione that everything was for the greater good. I was still young when I read the original book, but I still felt very sorry for Dumbledore. He seemed to have lived for others all his life. He turned against his lover and separated from his family for the sake of the wizarding world. He spent his whole life protecting Hogwarts, and in the end even gave his life. Later, I read a lot of fans, and many of them criticized Dumbledore. I felt an indescribable sadness. In Dumbledore's plan to defeat Voldemort, Snape and Harry were indeed sacrificed (Harry succeeded in the end), but wasn't he the first to sacrifice himself? He is not a god and cannot predict things in advance. What he does is his ultimate. Isn't that enough? It feels very comforting to see that someone finally understands and inherits Dumbledore's mission.

It's a very good Harper fan. The finished book definitely has the potential to be a masterpiece. I personally think it is much better than the book on the list that says HP fans despise wizards and magic, and don't even understand some basic settings. The only dissatisfaction I have is that the protagonist repeatedly emphasizes that he is in his forties, and his behavior seems childish, especially in the quarrel with Artolis, which is inexplicably bloody.

The day when the author made a steady update was when pork prices dropped across the country. Now, in addition to reading books, we have one more thing to look forward to 😏. Brother Meng, for the sake of pork and reading, go up to me...

Although this book has a mediocre monthly rating, it is undoubtedly written with great care by the author. Nothing poisonous. The writing is excellent. The protagonist is brave and resourceful, and the supporting characters are flesh and blood. It can be said that the author has a very good grasp of the original characters and objectively portrays each original character. No clues in the whole process. It is not the kind of HP fan that is invincible at the beginning (this is especially rare, many HP fans set the protagonist's magic ability to be very strong in order to reduce the difficulty of writing, so that they can write less about cleverness). The emotional lines are written very delicately and realistically. The main plot is very cleverly conceived, the logic is highly self-consistent, and the plot advances naturally and smoothly. The author has a good grasp of the plot, and there is no sign of collapse. With this level of writing and the ability to re-create the original work, if the writing is not a mixed niche like HP fan fiction, I should be able to get good monthly votes. Of course, readers who like the kind of books where the whole school is crazy about being in the first or second grade may not be able to adapt to the weak setting of the protagonist in the early stage. But I still have to say that the standard of this book is still stable among the top five HP fans in Qidian (it has to be said that many old HP fans with great achievements are too outdated. The standards of HP fans a few years ago were too low, and they did not have basic writing and plot control skills. The articles they wrote repeatedly poisoned the readers), so you might as well read it slowly and feel the charm of the author's story.

The hp fandoms that I think are in the top three so far

Why do some people write HP fanfics and call Dumbledore a faggot? It's really speechless. If you dislike this, then don't write fanfics. It stinks.

I feel that this book is very well written, the plot is logically reasonable, the characters have distinct personalities, and there is a sense of counter-convention everywhere, and it even helps the original author fill in some pitfalls! This is definitely one of the best HP fics. The only thing is that I feel that 500,000 words is only 5 or 6 years old, so it won't be finished soon 😭

For ordinary HP fans, by the time they write the fourth or fifth volume, basically both the power system and the plot have collapsed. When I saw Goblet of Fire feigning death at the end, I thought the book had collapsed. After reading it for a while, I finished reading it in a few days. To be honest, the author's series of sexy moves really impressed me. Whether it is working as an undercover agent and the boss of a group of small Death Eaters, or acting as a lackey to a toad, or pretending to be a great prophet or a magic stick. These tricks have never been seen by other HP fans, and they are really interesting and reasonable. Actually, it's quite normal. Generally, by the fifth part, the character of the protagonist has already been formed... The only thing that can be done is to follow the routine, join the Order of the Phoenix, and fight toads with the DA. There is nothing new at all. Or start a bunch of branch lines that deviate from the plot, which is boring to death. This book would have been like this originally, but after the last wave of fake death in Goblet of Fire, in Order of the Phoenix, I can completely let myself go, write new ideas, and play to my heart's content. No bragging, no slander, except for the Goblet of Fire plot, the plots of Chamber of Secrets, Azkaban and Order of the Phoenix are among the best among HP fans.