Sherlock Holmes at Hogwarts

Sherlock Holmes at Hogwarts

by The Scorching Sun Blows Ice

Length:
3.0Mwords836chapters
Latest:
Ch. 836Between Victory and Defeat
Activity:
Updated 5d agoScraped 4d ago
45Comments
16KFavorites
19KFans
7.9QD Score

About This Novel

In the summer of 1991, Sherlock Holmes received an admission notice to Hogwarts. --When magic and science are intertwined, the story is about to begin.

What Readers Think

Rating

Good0%Neutral0%Bad0%

Community(0)

Official(45)Scraped 2d ago

TI
Time Darling7mo ago

A decent Harry Potter fanfic

The rhythm and plot of this article are completely driven by the protagonist, while others are marginalized and tool-humanized. The basic setting is as shown in the title. An original non-traveler protagonist, Sherlock Holmes, is created. The protagonist's template is based on the British Sherlock Holmes-related TV series (Volume Edition). The character's personality, behavior patterns, and interpersonal relationships are all the same. The plot breaks away from Sherlock Holmes and completely follows Harry Potter. After reading the whole book, I feel that the author understands the Sherlock Holmes series better than the Harry Potter series. Although the protagonist is completely copied, the move is smooth and not rigid. Therefore, the theme of this article is very clear. Sherlock Holmes uses his superhuman deduction method and observation ability to reveal the hidden secrets of the original characters in one sentence, crack the puzzles to solve various hidden dangers in advance, and gain the trust and admiration of others. On the surface, it is a fusion of magic and reasoning. In fact, the reasoning process is somewhat reversed and far-fetched. You can regard him as a spoiler time traveler, but the time traveler found a bunch of reasons to hide it. So there is no need to count on reasoning related. All the ink focuses on Holmes himself. He is elegant, intelligent, sharp and candid. He can always point out problems and propose solutions to the point. He can always point out the inner weaknesses of others and understand them. He can always stand in front of others and face them bravely in times of danger. Harry and Ron trusted him and listened to what he said, Lao Deng was optimistic that he was willing to change his stubborn logic, and Hermione Luna liked that he took the initiative to support him. He has a beautiful family, financial freedom, strong skills, and has not encountered any setbacks or failures. In short, this is a typical Long Aotian-style protagonist, and the whole world revolves around him. This results in other people's lack of subjective initiative, and some characters' personalities and behaviors deviate from the original work. Fortunately, the author has grasped this degree, so that the power system and interpersonal relationships can be advanced in an orderly manner without directly collapsing. If the reader takes the place of Sherlock Holmes, the plot will be smooth, natural and non-toxic. Therefore, the logic of this article is based on Xiaobai's text, but is higher than Xiaobai's. In terms of stance, he is kind and righteous. The protagonist does not engage in conspiracy theories or behind-the-scenes gossip. He shows his talents openly and openly fights against evil. That's nice, more human-like than most Harry Potter fanfic protagonists. The portrayal of other characters, with the exception of the absolutely evil Voldemort and a series of Death Eaters, tends to be whitewashed. Especially some controversial characters, such as Snape and Aunt Petunia, are basically whitewashed. The advantage is that it doesn't use layers of nesting dolls to smear Lao Dengtou, and it doesn't self-righteously create some specious characters. The disadvantage is that some people's behavior is divorced from the described character. The plot is based on the original work. It follows the plot and breaks where necessary. It does not deliberately follow the plot. It lacks creativity and is not too boring at the same time. It just makes do. The description of daily life is okay. The emotional line likes Shura Field and Bai Jia, but it is not too persistent. There is no conflict for the sake of conflict. The values ​​​​follow the Sherlock Holmes series and are within the scope of normal people. In short, the personality is relatively distinct. It's not a particularly good Harry Potter fanfic, but it wouldn't be fair to classify it as mediocre. I can only comment - above average, it's pretty good.

8
WH
Why Does a Childhood Sweetheart Need a Bamboo Horse?4mo ago

More like a mystery novel than a Harry Potter fanfic

I have subscribed to Chapter 460 and have seen Chapter 388. The beginning is quite interesting. It can be seen as a lucky version of Sherlock Holmes entering the Harry Potter world. Reasoning and magic collide with each other. While he has a vicious tongue, he criticizes some characters in the original book, such as Dumbledore. Starting from the prisoner chapter, the writing method changed to plot advancement → Sherlock began to collect clues → there were still some questions confirmed and then explained → the end of the chapter began to force reasoning and backtracking... The problem is that this is a fan novel. When the audience already knows that Scabbers is Peter Pettigrew, a lot of space is spent on reasoning and laying out clues to prove why this matter can be seen through, and a lot of descriptive metaphors are interspersed to highlight Sherlock's insight and reasoning ability. The rhythm seems very strange. After third grade, apart from being powerful in melee combat for solving crimes, Sherlock's abilities basically had nothing to do with magic. As for the heroine, Gemma Farley's description is brilliant, and it feels very consistent. Apart from saying that she is the real Slytherin every time, she says it every time she meets her. Hermione looked like she had a crush on him. Luna suddenly appeared, and without much description, she began to become one of the candidates for the harem. It's not as good as the description of Zhang Qiu Jinni's harem opened by Harry. Generally speaking, the author is more suitable for writing mystery novels with realistic backgrounds, so that this situation will not occur. One or two chapters are used to construct some evidence for solving the case, and what is proved is exactly some basic settings of the fan fiction. The process is exciting and the conclusion is speechless.

7
BO
Book Friends 20240302196_eb13mo ago

It's quite interesting. The height of a wise man in a book depends on the height of the author's wisdom. As a character with high IQ, Sherlock Holmes is a high-IQ character. If the deduction method is not written well, the book will be nothing more than an empty shell. Although this book has only over 200,000 words, judging from the chapters I have read, at least the author has worked hard on the creation of Sherlock Holmes.

7
LU
Lucian D1mo ago

There are too many. I will ask who Sherlock is with in the comment area. If there are kind people who can tell me, I will decide accordingly.

31
BO
Book Friends 20250925612_cb8mo ago

A subtle collision of magic and reasoning

The description of Sherlock Holmes is like the original work, cleverly combining Harry Potter and Sherlock Holmes. Although I don't like the ambiguous part, this is undoubtedly a good work. Continuing to catch up.

3
HO
Hongchenke14mo ago

nice

It looks great. I'm so excited about Double Chef. I love watching it. Ten Chinese characters

31
WH
Whale Falling into the Rain_cb13mo ago

Can there be fewer emojis after it is put on the shelves? I won't say anything about the free ones. You like to use emojis too much. If you want to see the ups and downs of the plot, you are not here to be cute.

3
JI
Jiang Ciluoli14mo ago

Woc, the writing is so NB! It feels like Sherlock himself!

3
SH
Shadow in Dream14mo ago

It can be seen that the author has a deep understanding of both works. When applying the original works, it does not feel like copying them mechanically, and there are even some adaptations.

3
MO
Momo10mo ago

The character's personality is extremely close to each other, and there is no deviation. It fully restores Sherlock's calm analysis and venomous tongue. On this basis, it also involves a friendship line. The plot is also very different from the original work. Looking forward to the third grade! ! !

2

Featured in 7 Booklists

Official(7)

[Book Collection] An Eye-catching Book (Mainly Recommending Male Protagonists with High Iq and no Cp)
9054935

Well, it's the Hogwarts version of Sherlock Holmes, and our wizarding world is saved!

This Time I Choose Paladin
After the Player is Reborn
The Teacher is a Multi-game Speedrun Player
I Play the Role of a Player in the Folklore Dungeon
Reviews of Yezhu Zhai
8016623

Reading progress: 134 Dear Hermione, do you have any misunderstanding about me? Reading score: 27 points, not recommended. Summary of review: The entire content is basically just the title, The Adventures of Jack Su in the Sub-Era. The writing is more to my liking. In terms of plot, there is nothing innovative, not interesting, and a bit toxic. Readers who like Jack Su's set may be familiar with Dianbo. Writing style (7 points): While the writing style is smooth, it also incorporates a large number of translation accents from the Sherlock Holmes collected translations, and incorporates a large number of complex popular memes. It is a type that will be quite interesting when it hits the airwaves. Of course, if it doesn't match up, it will feel stiff and abrupt. There are not many detailed descriptions of scenes and actions, and the sense of the picture relies more on understanding the original work. There are some passages copied from the original text, but fortunately not many. Characters (6 points): The shot version of Detective Sherlock Holmes is a more classic Jack Sue. The psychological behavior is very close to the middle-aged detective in the original work. It's very reductive at best, but from a physical and psychological point of view, I don't want to be an 11 or 12-year-old child. The performance of HP's original characters is relatively restored. Except for Principal Dumbledore who seems to be too weak, the rest of the characters are restored well. Plot (4 points): Basically, Jack Su leads the protagonist group of the original work to complete the plot in the original work. Basically, no innovative reconstruction is seen, and it is just a simple manifestation of the saint in front of people. The original detective plots do not seem to have much meaning at present. They neither deepen the interpretation of the original work nor form new foreshadowing, or are in vain. So far, there are three poisonous points in my personal understanding. One of them masturbated the cat that McGonagall transformed into in the first Transfiguration class. This was completely inexplicable and the protagonist already knew that it was Professor McGonagall. I didn't know the necessity of this behavior. The other one is that the protagonist dissected his classmate's pet toad. This is no longer a simple prank or school bullying, this is a perversion that requires psychological intervention! The third and most troublesome one is that in the plot of the Sorcerer's Stone, in the potion puzzle, the operation of using the elixir of blessing to exchange the potion appears inexplicably. There is no foreshadowing at all! Forcibly embedded in an important main plot, just to show off in order to bring Jack Su into the final battle, it is simply an insult to the IQ. In short, the almost straightforward plot of the original work is mixed with inexplicable detective stories and weird poisonous points, which makes people feel a little stomachache. Setting (5 points): The protagonist's character is basically that of Sherlock Holmes and a magic genius. Well, it's a typical Jack Su character. The rest of the HP part has not changed much, it is basically the same as the original work. It also does not reflect any exploration or interpretation of the magical field by Holmes using deductive methods. Among them, the private setting of the Fuling Elixir seriously affects the rationality of the plot. All I can say is, just be happy. Thoughts (5 points): It's nice to have a protagonist who insists on justice, but the practice of privately executing a classmate's innocent pet is very disgusting. Basically, he is just a wanton Jack Su, leading his younger brothers on a rampage.

The Demon King is Unfathomable
There Are Mushrooms Growing in This Dungeon
Warhammer: My Biological Father, the Emperor, and His Demigod Brother
Doomsday America
No Taboos (Xianxia Western Fantasy Cthulhu, Urban Game Two-dimensional)
149444

The content is as per the title. Same as Harry. There doesn't seem to be anything wrong so far. Because it is Sherlock Holmes, a lot of reasoning elements are added to it. You can take a look.

Lord of Puro
I Am a Literary Giant in Tokyo
Naruto: the Legend of Cishen
Sherlock Holmes at Hogwarts
Grain and Grass Sauce, Hold On! ! !
13642

Rating: [Xiancao] Introduction: ●The collision of deduction and magic. ●"Your divination can know the future, but my deduction can know your past." Advantages: ●The protagonist is [Sherlock Holmes] (started at the age of 11). Personally, I feel that there is no problem in writing this book. It does not blindly boast about Shylock's wisdom, but describes the process and experience of Shylock, although he is young and smart, but also needs time to grow. The description is in place and the development is smooth and reasonable. ●Interesting, Sherlock's way of speaking and intonation are unique, and there is no cookie-cutter pretense for the sake of pretense. ●Truthfulness does not rely on contrast or deceiving others to set off Shylock, but the process of actually writing out the details and inferring the results. At the same time, Sherlock Holmes in the novel also has some strengths and weaknesses. Disadvantages: No obvious shortcomings found yet

Sherlock Holmes at Hogwarts
Comprehensive Manga: the Master is Not Here Today
What Should I Do If I Marry My Enemy?
Only Come to the Love Strategy System after Getting Engaged

You Might Also Like