The Male Disciple in the Women's Sect

At first, it did initially impress me, after all, it's about cross-dressing. I haven't read many books, but I was drawn in and read a few hundred pages. However, I found it wasn't that great. Let's start with the strengths: ① Numerous characters, a crucial element of the book. The female characters have diverse personalities, come from different places, and are indeed well-written. ② Cross-dressing, a major factor attracting readers. If it were a masculine character, this book would definitely be unreadable. ③ Harem. ④ A hodgepodge of otherworldly elements. It includes Western and Eastern elements, fantasy and technology, so nothing seems out of place. However, it also has many weaknesses, which I'll list here...

I was already at the beginning of this book when the author started writing it, and my tolerance for the author's constant promiscuity had reached its limit. (Even Gu Ning'an was added to the harem—please, Gu Ning'an is a martial arts fanatic!) At the start, the protagonist, as a transmigrator arriving in this world, was at least sixteen or eighteen years old, and the impression was very good. But by the second volume, I really don't know what went wrong with the author. As a transmigrator who came from a monogamous world and grew up in a female-dominated sect, everyone should know that promiscuity is unacceptable, especially since you grew up in a female-dominated sect. The first volume didn't give the impression that it would become a harem, but the protagonist's behavior was completely...

I completely lost interest at this point. The plot felt cluttered and the differences between characters were diminishing. There were no foreshadowing or plot twists. The world-building was grand, but it felt like the story was ending—I just couldn't continue writing. Many important characters from the beginning became the same later on, and the crucial cross-dressing theme completely disappeared. Not only did the protagonist accept it, but the audience also gradually forgot about it. It was as if the female lead had been the only one from the start. And the protagonist's promiscuity was unbearable. Who was his real wife? There was absolutely no resolution; he was constantly having ambiguous relationships with this person and that person.

First of all, I want to thank the author for introducing me to this book. When I first started reading, I felt a strong sense of déjà vu. Back when I went to Japan to study, my school was a girls' school that had just been converted to a regular school. There were only three or five boys in a class. So reading this novel felt like those awkward times had come back. The plot flows smoothly, and the various comedic moments are particularly good. The characters are also quite well-developed. However, if the male lead had a bit more of an incongruity with women, like the male lead in "A Girl Falls in Love with Her Older Sister," there would probably be even more laughs. After all, no matter how handsome he is, he's still a male lead. Right now, he feels a bit too much like a girl hiding something cute under a skirt...

The martial arts setting is quite old, but it feels fresh here on SF. It's very good; I like the male lead's weak and submissive nature. Will the master also be taken advantage of? I just don't understand why there aren't many fans despite how good it is. Frankly, the entire sect is the male lead's harem—it's terrifying to think about; will he be drained dry? The male lead is too weak right now; I hope he gets stronger quickly and starts flirting with all sorts of girls. The author should intersperse some beautiful, regrettable, and heart-wrenching love stories; that would probably attract a huge fanbase. It's both heartbreaking and enjoyable.

I've been reading this novel for quite a while now. What initially attracted me were the cross-dressing elements and the martial arts (or perhaps fantasy?) RPG elements (and secretly, it might also be a science fiction novel). The beginning was very interesting, but later I realized this novel can't be read with a brain. Don't criticize me; to me, it felt like a nonsensical comedy. But that's okay, isn't the point of reading these kinds of novels to have fun? As long as the ideas are imaginative and you find it interesting, that's enough.

When I first started reading this novel, I really enjoyed it. The protagonist had strong moral values, was beautiful, and handled interpersonal relationships well. The author also did a good job of character development, making the characters vivid and relatable. The author used many popular internet slang terms, which made the novel more to my liking. However, the plot became abrupt when I started paying for the novel. I felt the author lost control of the pacing. The male lead went from a virtuous gentleman to a bulldozer, and the master went from pure and innocent to a jealous woman with inappropriate thoughts about her disciple. Also, the character of the Japanese princess felt out of place; I personally felt it was unnecessary...

I recommend reading it chapter by chapter, because I already regret not using my remaining 2700 Fire Scrolls after reading this novel. Simply put, as others have said, the later parts are too rambling, lacking foreshadowing, plot twists, and suspense; it's just a flat narrative. Even the initial incident of stealing the inner core was never explained, so it was likely a frame-up—yes, no foreshadowing. There are many other instances where I thought there was foreshadowing, but the author always tells me I was overthinking it. As for the characters, they are the worst of the worst. I only spent money on the novel because of the master and Meng Xuanji, but the later character development is terrible, like the author feeding us garbage. In the end, all the characters are the same: sucking up to the male lead. Regarding the ensemble cast, I also feel…

I just started reading this novel, and then I found out it was finished. I read the last chapter, and I was stunned. Isn't this book about love and hate in the martial arts world? How come the last chapter is about the Milky Way? Holy crap?

Only one epilogue? Isn't that a bit short? There are still a few plot holes to fill! Putting everything else aside, shouldn't we at least talk about Fourth Master Uncle's background?