I'm Not a Magical Girl Just Because I Look Like an Idol

This is an objective evaluation, please don't criticize (personal opinion). First, the advantages: 1. The author's writing is excellent, making for a comfortable reading experience. 2. The author says this book won't be free. 3. The author says he won't abandon the story. 4. The battle descriptions are great (but so far, only the battle with Hifumi is worth mentioning). 5. It's more of a slice-of-life story; the protagonist's daily routine hasn't changed much. 6. It's rare to see stories with almost no close contact like this (but that wouldn't suit most readers' tastes). 7. The writing is coherent. Now, the disadvantages: 1. The main plot is unclear; I only found out by asking the author. 2. The plot development is too slow, starting from the first chapter...

So... It's over?

Discontinued.

Awesome!

Is the main character a boy or a girl when they transform into a magical girl? 😶

Without further ado, let's get straight to the point and summarize (out of 10 stars): 1. Luo Yuanzhen: ★★★★☆☆☆☆☆☆ 2. Mizuho Yonai: ★★★★★★☆☆☆☆ 3. Raven: ★★☆☆☆☆☆☆☆☆ 4. Sakuma Seidai: ★★★★★★★★☆☆ 5. Kazama Hifumi: ★★★★★★★☆☆☆ 6. Shinohara Sachiko: ★★★★★★☆☆☆☆ Below are the reasons for the ratings (detailed introduction): Character: Luo Yuanzhen (Male Lead & Protagonist) Gender: Male Age: 19 Height: ? Personality: Goes with the flow, gives up, stubborn, inflexible, lacks motivation (inner monologue) & filtered chapters, lazy...

First of all, this book isn't very popular right now (at least I haven't found a worse one). I apologize, author, I'm not saying the book is bad. There are some issues with the content, plot, and logic within the book. If the author addressed these points, the book's situation wouldn't be so bad. Also, if the author spent time polishing the work, its popularity would increase (promotion would also help). Below are my thoughts for the author (no offense intended). I might have gotten a little too emotional and posted so many reviews. Now that I've calmed down, I'm starting to reflect on my actions. When I wrote those reviews...

I apologize if my previous book review was too harsh or nitpicky. However, after reflecting on it these past few days, I feel I should offer some words of comfort to the author. I apologize to the author here, and I hope you won't be upset because of my review! As a reader, the plot, logic, and character development are very important. This book has many problems with its logic and plot, and I only pointed them out because I felt there were issues (I also love this book; if I had lost interest, I wouldn't have read it several times to analyze the problems. Please don't let me down!). Author...

Well, how should I put it? This book gave me a strange feeling. First of all, our protagonist is a bit too rigid, giving me the impression of a tool used to drive the plot (although the author says the protagonist will change later, but doesn't specify what that change is). His behavior is somewhat nonsensical (you could say he acts solely for the sake of the plot). For example, what was the reason for his inexplicable confidence when he first challenged the strongest new generation magical girl, Hifumi? (Didn't we say earlier that the protagonist is a nobody? Maybe it was just to gain popularity). Even after being defeated by the strongest new generation magical girl, Hifumi, he still strives to defeat her as his goal (as a nobody...).

It's Mom's cover.