The Inhuman Life of a Northern Song Scholar

The introduction keeps saying, "What's so great about the Song Dynasty?" Besides the great power of scholars, what other benefits were there? Foreign tribes bullied them every day. Military generals had no dignity, land annexation was rampant, and bandits were everywhere. It was a golden age for scholars, but it had nothing to do with ordinary people.

I have reservations about the author's views on the Song Dynasty. A nation's development requires a comprehensive approach. The Song Dynasty's overemphasis on civil administration resulted in a strong economy but a weak military due to excessive restrictions on military officials. Although the Song Dynasty maintained the largest standing army in history, its combat effectiveness was lackluster.

It must be said that the author's dedication to writing a historical novel, and his efforts to maintain accuracy in detail, are truly commendable. The numerous allusions and references to classical texts demonstrate a profound understanding of Confucianism, making him a rare find in this era. However, there are still shortcomings! First of all, there's too much preaching; it's tedious!

If you're unfamiliar with the Song Dynasty or only have a superficial understanding, please refrain from commenting. I've noticed many people like to compare it to the Tang Dynasty, so I'll make a comparison. First, to understand a dynasty, you need to know its background. Let's start with the Tang Dynasty. The Tang Dynasty can be seen as a continuation of the Sui Dynasty.

Some thoughts, spoilers ahead Only after reading the entire book did I understand why the title, "The Inhuman Life of Northern Song Dynasty Scholars," was so fitting; it truly depicted the protagonist's suffering. Zheng Lang, from a young age, excelled in all the arts—music, chess, calligraphy, and painting—and achieved the highest honors in the imperial examinations, earning widespread renown…

A ten-year-old can write three chapters just by writing a few characters? This is ridiculously long-winded. These forced attempts at showing off are disgusting. And this "historical classic" status... Qidian is getting more and more tasteless.

The scholar-officials of the Song Dynasty truly lived an inhuman life; they were practically immortals. The worst they could do for a crime was exile. Even betraying the country could get them promoted to high office.

I seriously doubt if this protagonist really time-traveled. Not only is his emotional intelligence low, but he's also incredibly pedantic and trapped in the world of books.

I can't bear to read this! It's only the first scene and it's already five chapters in. How long will it take you to finish writing this?

Every time I see a story about a master and his servant being in love, I immediately drop the book.