Five Generations of Elegance

1. The setting of the protagonist Wu Tai is good. When the Five Dynasties and Ten Kingdoms were fighting against the Han Dynasty, there were often middle and low-level generals fighting with each other, which was conducive to the transition of early meritorious service; 2. The era was well chosen. The later Han Dynasty was exhausted, as long as it can become a great It has swallowed up all the checkpoints in the north, and it is just a matter of time in the south. If you don't look for trouble, you won't be too aggrieved; 3. The title of the book is not good, the appeal is average, and the story you want to tell cannot be seen; 4. The first chapter is not well written. , It can be seen that the author wants to throw a joke, but the three consecutive questions and answers and two turns are very blunt and brainless; 5. The details in the latter part are very good and immersive, but it gives me the feeling of political struggle, but this book It's the fifth generation, and big guys like Feng Dao live cautiously... The protagonist jumps up and down like a jester; Overall rating: 3 stars Character: minus one point Plot development: minus one point

If he was still a small soldier and an officer, he would take risks every day. Since he came back to attack the capital, he has been taking risks. When he went to Chu as an envoy, he had been showing off his personal bravery. It is good to lead by example in a war, but often a brother goes on adventures without guidance. It does not look like a Machiavellian historical novel, but like a martial arts novel.

Cousin's new historical work is set against the backdrop of the Five Dynasties and Ten Kingdoms, the troubled times with the most frequent regime changes in history. It tells the story of the protagonist's rise in troubled times. The work is as solid as ever in terms of historical research. The opening chapter cuts into major events such as the historian's family extermination and Guo Wei's seizure of power, making the story full of compactness and tension. At the same time, it also touches on officialdom etiquette, market The delicate description of life in the well creates a strong sense of immersion in the era. The protagonist's growth experience from a small person to gradually affecting the course of history is also quite gripping. The plots of retreating to advance and ambushes not only demonstrate the protagonist's wisdom and strength, but also are a sideways portrayal of the cruel reality of the Five Dynasties period when human life was insignificant.

The two authors I read before have both opened new books and they are both chapter 1. I just saw it🤣

The writing is wonderful, the plot is fascinating, the character settings are reasonable, and the logic is clear. Those imagination stories are simply unreadable.

Happy New Year

The requirements are not high, just have the level of the late Song Dynasty

After reading Chapter 233, most of them have a lot of scenes with women. Do you need to keep using women to advance the plot? I feel a little tired.

Come on, come on, update well

As mentioned, I hope my cousin can make a breakthrough this time and not stay in his comfort zone. It's really good to dance with swords all the time, but it makes you tired all the time. Farming and development are also necessary~

Conspiracies can be written, but machinations are not. I can write about the small-scale battle between trapped beasts, but I can't write about the large-scale battle and farming. The sketches that highlight the character's characteristics are very strong, deeply shaping the character's heart and not changing well. Therefore, the character is superficial and has lust but no love. The most fatal thing is that the author is path-dependent on the turning point of the crisis and has no confidence in creating tension in a calm plot. Therefore, the protagonist can never settle down and is always fighting to the death. There is no condition to create conditions to drag the protagonist into a crisis... It is a pity that the starting point is not watery nowadays. The writing has the quality of a movie, but it is too deliberate and makes people feel uncomfortable.

Aren't you going to stop writing history in this life? Why are you back again? Let yourself go and let go of history. I can afford another fifty years.

Se Ruduo, my dear Se Ruduo, we miss you 🙂

Share Mr. Yan Jianfei's latest article summary In the study of Song history, the early Song Dynasty is one of the fields with the most abundant research results, and it is also the stage with the least historical materials. The limited historical data makes it easy for scholars to grasp the historical development context of this period, and also makes this stage more easily restricted by narratives, which in turn obscures the true face of history. The unification strategy of "first south, then north" is a typical example. First of all, it needs to be explained that the people of the Song Dynasty did not have a clear statement of prioritizing the south and then the north. The summary of the unification process in the early Song Dynasty by the scholars of the first south and then the north means that in the unification plan, Song Taizu and Zhao Pu gave priority to the elimination of the southern regime, and then sent troops to the Northern Han and Khitan. Regarding the strategy of unifying the north first from the south and then the north in the early Song Dynasty, there were some critics, some affirmers, and some people discussed its implementation. However, the premise that existing research has neglected is whether this strategy actually exists. If there was no unification strategy from the south to the north in the early Song Dynasty, then the existing research is undoubtedly a castle in the air. To confirm the authenticity of this strategy, one must first review the relevant documentation. 1. Document review of the unification strategy of "first south and then north" There are four relevant literature records of the unification strategy of "first south and then north" in the early Song Dynasty: Song Taizu visited Zhang Yongde to attack the Northern Han Dynasty, Song Taizu visited Zhang Hui to attack the Northern Han Dynasty, Song Taizu visited Zhao Pu on a snowy night, and Song Taizu and Taizong discussed unification. The visit of Emperor Taizu of the Song Dynasty to Zhang Yongde can be found in the "Xuzhi Tongjian Changbian" (referred to as "The Changbian") and "History of the Song Dynasty·Biography of Zhang Yongde". "Changbian" says: Zhongwu Jiedu envoy and concurrently serving Zhongyangqu Zhang Yongde moved to Wusheng Jiedushi envoy. ... At that time, the general had something to do in the Northern Han Dynasty. Due to the secret visit strategy, Yongde said: "Taiyuan's soldiers are small but strong, and they are supported by Khitan, so they cannot be taken hastily. I foolishly thought that there would be more guerrillas every year to disturb their fields, so I still sent spies to Khitan to cut off their aid first, and then take advantage of it." It said: "Good." "Song History·Zhang Yongde Biography" records are simpler, and there is no information from the "Changbian". According to "Changbian", in August of the first year of Jianlong (960), Zhang Yongde entered the court, and Song Taizu consulted him about the attack on the Northern Han Dynasty. Zhang Yongde advocated delaying the attack on the Northern Han Dynasty, reducing the strength of the Northern Han Dynasty by interfering with the farming of the Northern Han Dynasty, and alienating the relationship between the Northern Han Dynasty and the Khitan. The story of Song Taizu's visit to Huazhou regiment training envoy Zhang Hui is found in "Changbian" and "Song History". "History of the Song Dynasty·Biography of Zhang Hui" says: In the second year of Jianlong, before Taiyuan was conquered, he went to the imperial court to ask for advice. Hui said: "Ze Lu was rebelled against Li Jun, and the wounds have not recovered. The army is booming, and I am afraid of heavy manpower difficulties. It is better to fight for the army and educate the people, and to wait for the rich to make plans." He was given clothes, gold belts, saddles and horses, and ordered to return to the state. "Long Edition" has no escape information. Zhang Hui also suggested delaying the attack on the Northern Han Dynasty because Zelu's people had not recovered their strength. Both Zhang Yongde and Zhang Hui advocated delaying the attack on the Northern Han Dynasty. The difference was that what Zhang Yongde advocated was a long-term strategy, while what Zhang Hui advocated was an immediate strategy. However, none of them mentioned policies towards other regimes. Considering the possibility that the Song Dynasty had not gotten rid of the sixth generation of short-lived dynasty at that time, people at the time did not necessarily think that the Song Dynasty could be unified. Zhang Yongde and Zhang Hui do not necessarily have a unification blueprint in mind: while advocating "Back North", they should "First South" to promote the unification process. It is logically untenable to regard the above two historical materials as supporting materials for the policy of first south and then north in the early Song Dynasty. The most important historical material of the strategy of first south and then north is Song Taizu's visit to Zhao Pu on a snowy night. This incident can be found in "Shao Hearing and Seeing Records", "Changbian", "Eastern Capital History·Zhao Pu Biography", "Song History·Zhao Pu Biography", etc. The "Shao Family Hearing and Seeing Records" written by Shao Bowen in the second year of Shaoxing (1132) is the earliest and detailed record: Zhao Pu did not dare to take off his clothes every time he retired from the court. One day it snowed heavily, and towards night, Pu said that the emperor would not come out again. After a while, after hearing the knocking on the door, everyone came out, and the emperor stood in the wind and snow. Everyone was anxious to greet him, and the emperor said, "I have made an appointment with the King of Jin." Taizong had arrived, and they all sat in the general hall on the ground under heavy grass and burned meat over hot charcoal. When Pu's wife was drinking wine, the emperor called her as his sister-in-law. Pu calmly asked: "The night has been cold for a long time, why did your Majesty come out?" The emperor said: "I couldn't sleep, and there were other people's homes outside the bed, so I came to see you." Pu said: "Your Majesty, the world is small? Today is the time for the southern and northern expeditions. I hope to hear what is planned." The emperor said: "I want to go to Taiyuan." Pu said after a while. : "I don't know what I know." The emperor asked why, and Pu said: "Taiyuan is on the west and north sides. If we attack it in one fell swoop, I will be responsible for the troubles on both sides. Why not stay until we can flatten the countries, and then there will be no escape in the land of small targets." The emperor smiled and said, "That's what I want, and I will test your ears." Then he decided on the plan for Jiangnan. There are many problems with this record. Li Tao pointed out: "According to Taizu's words, 'There are other people's homes outside the bed', so Jing and Hu have not yet been leveled at this time. Taizong Yin Kaifeng in the autumn of the second year of Jianlong, and the king of Jin in the sixth year of Kaibao. Shao Bowen's "Seeing and Wedding Records" says, ' "I have made an appointment with the King of Jin", so I changed it to "my brother", which is true. It also says "the plan for the south of the Yangtze River has begun to be decided", which is particularly wrong. If it were called Jing, Hu and Xichuan, it would be correct. ""Changbian" has been rewritten accordingly. Judging from the annotations in "Changbian", although Li Tao dated the visit to Pu on a snowy night to July of the first year of Kaibao, he believed that this conversation should be before the Pingjing Lake in the first year of Qiande (963). "History of Song Dynasty·Zhao Pu Biography" was written between the second and fifth years of Qiande. "Dongdu Shilue·Zhao Pu Biography" was written five years after Qiande. The specific time is not mentioned, but it provides new information, that is, the wife of Zhao Pu, who was a wine trader, was the daughter of He Ning, the prime minister of the later Jin Dynasty. Based on the above situation and the heavy snow, Liang Wei speculated that the snowy night visit to Pu was in the third year of Qiande; Liu Zhe, based on the title of "King of Jin", believed that it should be in the sixth or seventh year of Kaibao. There are obvious problems with Liu Zhezhi's theory. On the 23rd day of the eighth month of the sixth year of Kaibao, Zhao Pu, the prime minister, was dismissed as the governor of the three cities of Heyang because of his dictatorship. On the 20th day of the ninth month, Zhao Guangyi, the Yin of Kaifeng, was granted the title of King of Jin. Therefore, Zhao Guangyi was granted the title of Queen of the Jin Dynasty and Zhao Pu should have left the capital. Even if he had not left the capital, given Song Taizu's disgusting attitude towards Zhao Pu at the time, it was impossible for the three of them to gather together in the sixth year of Kaibao to discuss the unification matter. In addition to the above problems, there is another major flaw in "Visiting Pu on a Snowy Night" that scholars have paid less attention to. That is, when Taizu asked about conquering the Northern Han Dynasty, Zhao Pu replied: "Taiyuan is on both sides of the west and north. If you move down in one fell swoop, I will be solely responsible for the troubles on both sides." This is completely inconsistent with the border defense situation of Song Taizu's dynasty. The northern frontiers of the Taizu Dynasty of the Song Dynasty were the Khitan and the Northern Han Dynasty, and the western part of the Northern Han Dynasty were the vassal towns of Fuzhou, Linzhou, and Xiazhou of the Song Dynasty. There were no frontier troubles. Although these vassal towns maintained their semi-independence, they did not act domineeringly during the Taizu Dynasty. Instead, they sent troops to attack the Northern Han Dynasty many times. And judging from the wars between the Later Jin Dynasty, the Northern Song Dynasty and the Liao Dynasty, the main battlefield was always in Hebei. Due to the complex terrain, Hedong was not the route for the Khitan's southern attack. The Northern Han Dynasty and the Khitan repeatedly attacked the Later Zhou Dynasty and the Northern Song Dynasty, which shows that the existence of the Northern Han Dynasty not only failed to shield the Central Plains Dynasty, but also intensified the northern border troubles of the Central Plains Dynasty. The Song Dynasty's garrison troops on the Song-Han border also far exceeded those on the Song-Liao border (details below). Therefore, it is impossible for Zhao Pu, the prime minister of Song Taizu's dynasty, to say, "Taiyuan is on both sides of the west and north. If I move down in one fell swoop, I will be solely responsible for the troubles on both sides." The authenticity of the story of the visit to Pu on a snowy night is naturally greatly reduced. As we all know, after Song Taizong dynasty Li Jiqian rebelled against the Song Dynasty, there were border troubles to the west of Hedong; but the border troubles in the west were compared with the Khitan in the north only after the large-scale war broke out between Song Renzong and Song Xia. Therefore, judging from the content of the dialogue, the story of Xueye's visit to Pu should have occurred at least after the mid-Northern Song Dynasty. Zhou Biday, the prime minister of the Southern Song Dynasty, said: "Probably there are quite a lot of absurdities in "The Record of Shao's Hearings and Seeings", and the people and their years in the book are rarely correct." Modern people have also noticed that many of the stories contained in the book are made up by Xiangbi. Because Shao Bowen opposed Wang Anshi's new law, he recorded a large number of false stories that slandered Wang Anshi. This is another example. The fourth piece of material in the strategy of first south and then north is Song Taizu and Taizong discussing unification. This matter can be seen in Wei Tai's "Dongxuan Records", "Dongdu Shiluo·Liu Jiyuan Biography" and "Song Dynasty Facts Garden". The "Dongxuan Records" written in the 9th year of Yuanyou (1094) by Zhezong of the Song Dynasty is the earliest one: Changyu Taizong said: "Since the Five Dynasties, China has been suffering from wars and disasters, and the country's wealth has been exhausted. We must first take Xichuan, then Jing, Guang, and Jiangnan. Then the country will be rich. Today's Qing enemy only stops at Khitan. Since the beginning of luck, Yi Qingzhong The country. The east of the river is in control of the two tribes. If we take the east of the river, we will be connected to the border with the two tribes. It is better to keep Jiyuan and serve as my Pinghan. When I am ready, it is not too late to take it." Therefore, Taizu began to conquer Hedong in the last year, and Taizong succeeded to the throne and defeated the Jin Dynasty in one fell swoop. Judging from "Xichuan must be taken first, followed by Jing, Guang, and Jiangnan", this conversation should have occurred before Song Taizu sent troops to Jinghu in the first year of Qiande (963). However, like the visit to Pu on a snowy night, "Hedong is in control of the two Tibetans. If you suddenly capture the east of Hedong, you will be connected with the two Tibetans. If you can only survive to succeed the Yuan Dynasty, you can be my Pinghan." It is exposed that this passage also came from the middle of the Northern Song Dynasty and cannot be regarded as evidence that Song Taizu's dynasty moved from the south to the north. "Dongxuan Notes" was rated very low by Song people. Chao Gongwu believed that "what he was doing was unbelievable... And absurd", and Wang Zhi believed that he was "using his private joy and anger to slander his predecessors." This record can also be added as evidence. In summary, it can be seen that the above four historical materials all have problems. Based on the above historical materials, we cannot conclude that the Song Taizu Dynasty had a unification strategy of first south and then north. Of course, this does not mean that the monarchs and ministers in the early Song Dynasty did not discuss and plan for unification, but the content was not discussed in "Visiting Pu on a Snowy Night" and so on. If we focus on the actual situation of unification in the early Song Dynasty, we will find that the order of south and then north is not consistent with the practice of unification in the early Song Dynasty. 2. Emphasis on both the north and the south, focusing on the north: the practice of unification in the early Song Dynasty Before discussing the practice of unification in the early Song Dynasty, there are two issues that need to be explained. First, the "early Song Dynasty" here only refers to the Song Taizu Dynasty. After Song Taizong came to the throne, the south has been basically pacified, and there is no choice between the south and the north. Secondly, in addition to the Northern Han Dynasty, scholars are divided on whether "North" includes the Khitan. In view of Song Taizong's two northern expeditions to Youzhou, this difference only makes sense in the Song Taizu Dynasty. As far as existing research is concerned, the vast majority of scholars believe that "North" includes Khitan. However, judging from the border defense situation in the Song Taizu Dynasty, there was no large-scale war on the Song-Liao border, and Song Taizu did not station heavy troops on the border. After the Xiongzhou Peace Conference in the seventh year of Kaibao, the two sides reconciled. Therefore, although we can find many records of Song Taizu's obsession with the Youji area (of course, many of them visited Pu on a snowy night, and were attached to later generations, such as Song Taizu and Zhao Pu discussing the map of Youzhou presented by Cao Han, and Song Taizu's setting up a sealing warehouse to redeem Youji, etc.), These are inconsistent with the historical events of the early Song Dynasty. However, we cannot conclude that Song Taizu had a plan to use troops to capture Youji. In other words, Youzhou was not in Song Taizu's case. Wang Yuji and Li Huarui have both analyzed it, and Li Wen is more convincing. As we all know, the order of unification in the early Song Dynasty is Jinghu, Houshu, Southern Han, Southern Tang, Zhangquan, Wuyue, and Northern Han. However, this is only based on the results. This order is not completely consistent with the order of military use in the early Song Dynasty. In the first year of the Qiande Dynasty (963), Zhou Baoquan asked for help from the Song Dynasty. Li Chuyun, the deputy envoy to the Privy Council, was the governor of the capital and sent eleven envoys to send soldiers from An, Fu, Ying, Chen, Chan, Meng, Song, Bo, Ying, Guang and other prefectures to gather in Xiangyang to attack Zhang Wenbiao. "I knew that this time the Jinghu Uprising was put down. The troops mainly used soldiers from various states. Li Chuyun was ordered to lead thousands of cavalry to Jiangling. He forced Gao Jichong to land in Jingnan and continued to send troops to Hunan to pacify Jinghu in one fell swoop. In the second year of Qiande. (964) In the first month of the year, Song Zhaoyi's military governor Li Jixun and others led more than 10,000 infantry and cavalry troops to attack Liaozhou of the Northern Han Dynasty. Liaozhou governor Du Yantao and 3,000 men surrendered to the Song Dynasty, and the Northern Han Dynasty recruited a Khitan army of 60,000 troops to attack. , Jixun, Zhangde Jiedu envoy Luo Yanhuan, Xishan inspection envoy Guo Jin, Neigu Province envoy Cao Bin and others also led 60,000 troops to the battle and defeated the Khitan and Northern Han armies at the foot of Liaozhou City. On the 10th of the second year of Qiande. In January, the Song Dynasty sent troops to Shu in two directions: Fengzhou Road and Guizhou Road. Wang Quanbin, the commander of the Zhongwu Army on the Fengzhou Road, Cui Yanjin, the commander of the infantry commander, and Wang Renfan, the deputy envoy of the Privy Council, and Long Jie Youxiang all commanded. The envoys Shi Yande, Hu Jie Youxiang envoy Zhang Wanyou, etc. Commanded 20,000 infantry and cavalry troops, and 10,000 soldiers from various states. On the way back to the state, the guards and infantry envoys Liu Tingrang, and the Neihu envoys Cao Bin and Long Jie were sent. Zhang Tinghan, the commander of Zuoxiang, and Li Jinqing, the commander of Hujie, commanded 10,000 infantry and cavalry troops and 10,000 soldiers from various states. Long Jie and Hu Jie were the main bodyguards of the Sima Army and the Infantry Army respectively. They were later renamed Longwei and Shenwei and belonged to the upper four armies of the Forbidden Army. Judging from the commanders, the 30,000 imperial troops dispatched by the Song Dynasty were mainly the infantry of the Guards Sima, rather than the more elite front division troops. Taizu was quite confident in destroying Shu. It only took sixty-six days for the Song army to send troops from the capital to Mengchang. In the first year of Kaibao (968), there was civil strife in the Northern Han Dynasty. In August, Song Taizu "Yi Zhaoyi". Jiedushi and Tongping Zhangshi Li Jixun deployed for the army capital before marching to Hedong. The guard infantry commander made Dang Jin his deputy. Xuanhui Nanyuan envoy Cao Bin served as the capital supervisor. Dizhou defense envoy He Jiyun deployed for the vanguard. , Huaizhou defense envoy Kang Yanmao was the capital supervisor; Jianxiong Jiedushi envoy Zhao Zan was in charge of Fenzhou Road deployment, Jiangzhou defense envoy Si Chao was his deputy, and Xizhou governor Li Qianpu was the capital supervisor." It can be seen that the Song army came from Luzhou and Fenzhou Two routes attacked the Northern Han Dynasty, and the troops dispatched included both the Northern Han border troops and the central imperial army. In November, the Khitan army came to help, and the Song army was forced to withdraw. In the second year of Kaibao (969), the Song Dynasty. Taizu of the Song Dynasty made various preparations for this personal expedition. He sent 18 people including Li Ying, the imperial censor, to various states, and sent 49 envoys to send troops to Taiyuan. He stationed himself in Lu, Jin, Ci and other prefectures, and ordered Cao Bin, the envoy of Xuanhui Nanyuan, and Dang Jin, the commander of the infantry guards, to lead the troops to Taiyuan first. He also sent Li Jixun, the envoy of Zhaoyi Jiedu, to deploy the army in front of the Hedong camp. Jianxiong Jiedu envoy Zhao Zan served as the capital of the Ma Bu Army and went to Taiyuan. Later, Zhangde Jiedu envoy Han Chongyun was deployed as the northern capital, and Yiwu Jiedu envoy Qi Tingyi was his deputy to attack Khitan reinforcements in the Dingzhou area. After Song Taizu arrived at Taiyuan City, he attacked the city from all sides and deployed Dizhou Defense Envoy He Jiyun at Shiling Pass to block the Khitan reinforcements. After Taiyuan could not be attacked for a long time, the Khitan again sent tens of thousands of cavalry. Taizu of the Song Dynasty was forced to retreat. Judging from the "tens of thousands of horses" of the Khitan reinforcements, they should be tens of thousands of cavalry. In addition to the Central Forbidden Army and the troops stationed in the northern Han Dynasty, Taizu also mobilized the army of the Forty-Nine Prefectures. It was said that the whole country was unable to capture Taiyuan. In September of the third year of Kaibao, Song Taizu deployed the troops and horses of the Hezhou Daoxing camp with Pan Mei, the defense envoy of Tanzhou, and Yin Chong, the training envoy of the Langzhou regiment. Ke said, "He still sent envoys to send soldiers from various states to the city of Hezhou." Unfortunately, the number of soldiers mobilized this time was unknown, and the Southern Han Dynasty was destroyed in September of the seventh year of Kaibao. Taizu of the Song Dynasty took Cao Bin, the envoy of Xuanhui Nanyuan, as the commander, and ordered Pan Mei, the envoy of Shannan East Road, Li Hanqiong, the Marquis of Yu of the Horse and Horse Guards, Liu Yu, the Marquis of Yu of the Infantry Guards, and Cao Han, the envoy of the Yingzhou regiment, to attack the south of the Yangtze River. Considering that the Southern Tang Dynasty was the strongest among the ten countries, the Song Dynasty's attack on the Southern Tang Dynasty lasted for more than a year. The Song army successively defeated the Jiangnan army of 200,000 to 300,000 soldiers in Jinling, Wankou, Runzhou, Ezhou, Hukou and other battlefields. Pan Mei, the envoy of the Beiyuan, was appointed as the governor of the capital, and Yang Guangyi, the commander of the right wing of Hujie, was appointed as the governor of the capital, and they attacked the Northern Han Dynasty. They also ordered Zhenzhou Xishan inspection and Mingzhou defense envoy Guo Jin to conduct horse-based operations for Hedong Daoxin, Dai and other prefectures. The imperial edict sent troops to the Northern Han Dynasty. Hao Chongxin, the general envoy to the west, and Wang Zhengzhong, the governor of Jiezhou, left Fenzhou. Yan Yanjin, the deputy envoy of the Underwear Storehouse, and Sun Yanxuan, the deputy envoy of the Underwear Storehouse, went out to Qinzhou together with the governor of Zezhou. An Shouzhong, the governor of Puzhou, left Liaozhou, and Qi Yanchen, the deputy envoy, inspected Jinxizhou. Mu Yanzhang, the governor of Ruzhou, left Shizhou. Hou Mei, the deputy envoy of Luoyuan, and Guo entered and exited Xin and Dai. However, after the death of Song Taizu in October, Song Taizong issued an order to withdraw his troops. Judging from the appointment of military generals, the Song court dispatched the central imperial army and the imperial army stationed around Hedong, but their number is unknown.

I remember that in the back of the room, Piao Longji burst into tears and said that he didn't like writing historical texts, time travel, or farming. He wanted to write fantasy and human hearts. Why did he take up history again? No way, right? ?

At first I was recommending the end of the Song Dynasty and the Tang Dynasty everywhere, but because a certain chapter said that the heroine's IQ fluctuated, I deleted the post and banned it. Until now, I have been cryptic in my response to the ban. Haha, I want to try again and see if I can be happy for 50 years.

The Five Dynasties had the glory of chicken feathers, and no history books were willing to write more about it. You killed me and I killed you. Order was chaotic and people cannibalized people.

The beginning is messy and has no logic at all.

As proof, this book will collapse later!!!! My cousin can only write about conspiracies and conspiracies, such as thousands of people guarding the city of Chang'an. This nonsensical operation sounds very flammable, but in fact it has zero operability and cannot write the right path at all, and build a base area. He doesn't have the ability to rely on strength to eat up the hard work step by step . In the early stage of historical novels, you can rely on your nonsensical operations to accumulate strength. In the later stage, it basically depends on internal strength. Who in history has achieved political power not by strength, but by your conspiracy and trickery? It doesn't make sense, so we can see that the author's book will collapse in the later period. It stands to reason that his style is suitable for writing about cultivating immortals. Didn't my cousin say that he won't write history in the future, but I don't know why he came to write history again. According to his style, only It may be that he keeps losing his character in the middle and later period , and the old readers have almost run away . I don't know how long I can deceive new readers. I advise my cousin to do it and cherish it, or to study further, and don't engage in history Nihilism is just the flow!!!!!!!

I like the characters and stories created by my cousin so much. They are persevering and courageous, facing the abyss but never being assimilated by the abyss. Although the abuse has been constant since the beginning of the Tang Dynasty, I hope my cousin can stabilize his mentality. I believe that the person who can write Li Xia is also a stubborn and determined paranoid monster. This writing style and technique are very appealing to me, and I believe they are also very appealing to many people. Therefore, I believe that there are many readers supporting my cousin, but only a few people choose to speak out. In fact, sometimes I don't understand why a group of people who don't read books (or are they reading my cousin's books?) Come to the comment area to slander a work that has not yet begun. The last book was actually the same, and they started criticizing it before writing a few chapters... I believe the author himself will be full of grievances and indignation, but the Internet This is the factual principle of the Internet. It is an amplification of human nature. If you do something wrong inadvertently, it will be infinitely amplified. Keyboard warriors will not put themselves in my shoes and consider whether it is necessary for me to rant in the comment area of a new book or to mismanage the review area of a previous book. They will only resort to emotions: taunting. New readers, please don't be alarmed, my cousin's writing skills are always online. If my cousin can see it, I wish you another nirvana and rebirth in this book.

Two posts have been blocked in three days. I am also very curious about how many years the operation team will sentence me after they come to power. If the sentence is lower, it is because I am not stylish enough!

The last few pictures have really disgusted me. Just write Xiao Yi as invincible. Use a Wushuang to defeat everything. When there is a problem, the Wushuang will solve the opponent's coach. Is this what the historical article says? There is no need to go to such trouble, just write about Xiao Yi Wushuang who unified the five generations and that's it. What's the point of writing about Machiavellian plots? Anyway, in the end, Wushuang solves the problem. You can highlight the one I am invincible and you can do whatever you want!

This author actually has more than 2,000 monthly votes

This book is not like a historical novel, but more like martial arts that is overly dramatic. The protagonist is more like a knight, without any political literacy, and does not reflect the talents of his subordinates. The political content in the book is like child's play.

This subject happens to be my favorite. To be honest, I really like the first half of Man Tang Hua Cai written by my cousin. I really like to read it. My cousin writes absolutely top-notch plots and stories. This is really what my cousin is good at. I hope my cousin can bring out the momentum of writing the final song of the Song Dynasty while retaining the advantages of Man Tang Hua Cai. He must have a good attitude towards readers and stand upright when he is beaten. Writing this book well is the greatest compensation for readers.

This is the first time I read a novel with good writing and such a speechless plot.

Conspiracy, hegemony, politics, and court. I haven't quite figured out the politics and court part yet. There is too little written about it, but I really enjoyed what my cousin wrote about the other two. There are three twists and turns in the early stage, and it does not deviate from the main goal. However, I skipped it at the end. There were too many twists. In the later period, especially the part where the protagonist kills Chen, I got a lot closer to the protagonist. I was afraid of the consequences. I should do it for myself in this troubled world. I changed my mind based on my thoughts, and the training during the hegemony period did not make me feel the irritability of continuous marching and fighting during the hegemony period. It was quite interesting to watch. The most important point is also the advantage of Cousin, that is, the characters are very interesting, and the various characteristics of the characters are novel and interesting to everyone. I don't know if my idea of ​​reading the article is different from other people's. Anyway, I enjoyed reading it, so please don't criticize me.

I have never seen the protagonist become an emperor by being an assassin. Yuan Shu even knew how to ask his subordinates to do it.

If you really want to seize power and do things for the world, marrying Wu Niang is the best way. If you insist on talking about things in such an awkward manner, this is not a matter of tension. You like to increase the difficulty too much. You like to find strange paths too much. You like to create conflicts too much.

It doesn't matter if the author has a harem, but the old-fashioned way of writing is still the same as before. As long as she is a beautiful woman, no matter whether it is reasonable or not, she must try every means and beat around the bush to accept it. Can such writing really increase the attention of the novel? I am skeptical. Now it is appropriate to open a harem. It's no longer popular anymore. Even Ji Cha, a harem master, has stopped writing books. Look at the Lord of Mysteries who didn't deliberately open a harem. It's just as popular. There is also a historical article about Shao Song Dynasty, but he didn't deliberately open a harem. It also became the first historical article to have 100,000 orders.