Water Margin: Starting by Beating Gao Yanei to a Pulp

Wang Ying, the rapist and murderer; Zhang Qing and Sun Erniang, who killed people and made human flesh buns; Zhang Heng, who robbed and killed while crossing the river; Li Kui, the murderous demon who brutally murdered a young magistrate's son; Dong Ping, who wiped out an entire family after failing to marry someone he wanted…

Are people like Sun Erniang, the "Mother Night Demon," and Zhang Qing, the vegetable gardener, who murdered and chopped into mincemeat, not subject to the principle of rewarding good and punishing evil? Even if we killed every other one of the 108 heroes, there were bound to be some who slipped through the net, so why did we take them all in?

Before even rebelling, you've already started building your harem and even took the "Man Jiang Hong" (a type of red wine) just to win a smile from Li Shishi. This "Instructor Lin" has probably written his story as: first a flower picker, then a mountain king, and finally an emperor! Have you got the order backwards? This kind of behavior only makes you a laughingstock.

This is a case of abusing the protagonist and portraying the character as a saint. The plot is illogical and unreasonable. The author's writing is poor, and the author should be insulted, abused, and punished. (This comment reflects all attacks permanently.)

You're kidding me, aren't you? You're just making things up.

Would Yue Fei, the Martial General, defect to a traitor like you? You're overthinking it. If he really had such intentions, would he have been recalled by thirteen imperial edicts?

If the protagonist is a eunuch, he does nothing but collect women at the beginning: Zhenniang, Jinlian, Li Shishi, Jin'er. If he's not a eunuch, he collects so many women but doesn't sleep with them, even wanting to give Jinlian to Wu Song and Li Shishi to a stranger, Yan Qing. Why didn't he give his wife to Lu Da and have him become a monk instead?

I finally found a book with a systematic approach, but the author's writing skills are really lacking!

This is a good book. First of all, the values ​​of chivalrous people in the Ming Dynasty were based on freedom, not necessarily on the principle of serving the country and its people. Even in modern times, bandits and outlaws often took lives. Since Zhang Qing and Sun Erniang were brothers, it's impossible for Zhang Qing to betray his own brother for the greater good.

What's wrong with me? I only posted one comment on the book about the Heavenly Child Granny, and I got permanently banned.