The Deep-Sea Island Keeper

The writing is okay, but the plot is weak, the main storyline is unclear, and the subplots are too messy. 1. The plot is terribly flawed. The protagonist's grandfather and father only encountered three support missions in their entire lives, while the protagonist, within two months of arriving, faces three attacks from foreigners who kill, seize ships, and kidnap crew members.

After reading a few chapters, there are just too many illogical points. For example, translating what animals say in a live stream, or the dolphins supposedly "evolved" on the boat right in front of his dad. Seals, dolphins, squid, seabirds—they're all brought back to the bedroom. He even mentioned keeping the squid in a bucket, while the seals and dolphins are just given a nest and a few clothes.

I feel that the author treats marine life like cats and dogs, implying that they can survive without water, especially the part about baby dolphins. It's an insult to my intelligence.

Doesn't anyone feel there's a problem with dolphins living in dry areas?

Chapter One: Persuasion to Withdraw The island, with an average elevation of 150 meters, is submerged several times a year, leaving only the mountaintops exposed. The tides from the sea are at least 100 meters high. Let's not even talk about Shanghai. It's estimated that 80 million people drown in Japan every year. Places like Tokyo and Osaka can spend a week or two underwater every year.

Actually, I quite like this type of novel, but I couldn't continue reading after the fan club left. Author, please be more meticulous when writing novels! You rescued a dolphin and then hugged it—won't the dolphin get dehydrated? And then when you woke up, the dolphin was squatting by your bed?!

I don't quite understand why, when pirates come, it's not the navy that goes, but the island's defenders.

I quite like this novel, but could the protagonist please cause less trouble? During a live stream, he pretends to understand the turtles and other small animals, even translating for everyone. He puts a dolphin in the boat and takes it out to sea, then performs a dolphin evolution act in front of his father, completely fooling him with numerous mistakes.

Keep updating and you'll get lots of tickets!

While there were some flaws in the beginning, it was generally good. It was a shame it started focusing on cultivation later on. Most novels of this type seem to lack a clear outline and are written very casually. The fact that immortals appeared in this "wilderness" novel suggests it's too niche; perhaps the later parts were just practice for future fantasy and martial arts novels.