Fanqie novels

Novels like Tales of Shanghai’s Underworld

Books Chinese readers most often put in the same booklists as Tales of Shanghai’s Underworld, best match first.

Genre, tags, more
Genre, tags, more
Clear all
  1. 151 Desire for Black Gold 欲黑金 Urban1.3M WordsCompleted [Underworld, Passion and Strategy, Multiple Heroines] Six years ago, Cao Zhishuang broke into the room of the campus belle, a teacher, and ended up behind bars. Now that he’s just been released, an invisible hand has already closed around him. Cao Zhishuang resolutely steps into the game, vowing to uncover the true cause of his father’s death and kill his enemies with his own hands. From then on, he sets out on a one-way road paved with desire and dirty money… 6.8kReads8.1Score73814d adds
  2. 152 Black Shark 黑鲨 Urban1.1M WordsCompleted I can’t stand you, so I’ll beat you up! You made me unhappy, so I’ll make you pay! White can be black, and black can become white, because even under the brightest lights, shadows are always there. Blunt and revealing, but not judgmental. This may not be the pinnacle of crime fiction, but it is absolutely a trailblazer in the genre! Just wait and see! 676Reads8.4Score—14d adds
  3. 153 The Forbidden City's Ultimate Playboy: Du Zhicheng 紫禁城最强纨绔:杜之城 Urban1.2M WordsOngoing A story set in a parallel world. Not real, yet real. He was born a top-tier second-generation rich kid. He united the powerful second-generation crowd across the river. He traveled far and wide, face-slapping all kinds of powerful figures. At a young age, he stood at the very top. The story of Zheng Ge and Xiao Cheng still lives on in the underworld. 10.2kReads7.6Score49914d adds
  4. 154 I'm No Little Punk: The Shorties' Hero Squad 我不是小混混之矮子英雄队 Urban371k WordsOngoing I'm determined not to become a hoodlum. Even a short person can stand tall. Not every hero is tall, but every passionate heart deserves to be seen. I won't go along with the ways of the world. I'll walk my own path through the jianghu. The road is long, so may we meet again at the summit... 115Reads—Score214d adds
  5. 155 Wang Hao, the Inverse Scale King 逆鳞王皓 Urban338k WordsOngoing A comeback, a defiance of fate. Bullied for years because of his weight, he finally reaches his breaking point and vows never to be weak again. He fights back, step by step descending into hell, and soon dominates the campus... 101Reads—Score214d adds
  6. 156 The Youth of Two Generations 两代人的青春 Urban3.1M WordsOngoing My name is Li Sunan, and I'm a complete... bastard. Please take a moment, settle in, and let me tell you the whole story. From my godfather, Li Zhen, to my second uncle, Cui Lijun, and then to my own dark life. From 1990 to 2020. Thirty tumultuous years in a small city in Northeast China. One act ends, and another begins. Two generations rise and fall, knowing both glory and disgrace. There are no all-powerful crime bosses here. Just a bunch of little people struggling at the bottom... The road 2.6kReads7.1Score14014d adds
  7. 157 Tale of the Twin Flood Dragons 双蛟记 Urban998k WordsCompleted [Brothers bound by deep affection, sharing life and death] [A flood dragon lies hidden in deep waters. After enduring bitter hardships, it can emerge transformed into a dragon.] 655Reads7.3Score10114d adds
  8. 158 The Boss of the Underworld 江湖话事人 Urban3.4M WordsCompleted [Not many readers, so the rating just won’t go up] One wrong turn brought me into the jianghu. Watch as I summon storms with one hand and calm them with the other. Starting from nothing, I’ll carve out a path through the jianghu. They say you become what you eat, so if you want to climb higher, there’s only one thing to eat... 2.6kReads7.9Score21114d adds
  9. 159 The Golden Age of the Gangland: A Blood-Red Underworld 黑帮盛世:血色江湖 Urban3.6M WordsOngoing (Not a mindless power fantasy. Underworld, urban setting, no invincible hero, first person, tight logic, humorous writing. Read with caution if that’s not your thing!) A cursed, tragic fate. A life in the underworld that cannot be escaped. A band of brothers who stand together through life and death, and a dark life longing for redemption. You’ve never endured years of hardship, so of course you can’t understand the underworld in my heart. My story begins after I get out of prison in Ice Cit 122kReads9.3Score8.7k14d adds
  10. 160 The Northeastern Transfer Student Conquers Tokyo! 东北插班生制霸东京! Urban465k WordsCompleted [Tokyo + hot-blooded action + System + hard-hitting fights] Li Yuan, a crime boss, died unexpectedly, and his soul transmigrated into the body of a transfer student from Northeast China at Suzuran High School. On his very first day, a delinquent gang cornered him at the entrance. When Li Yuan faced the gang, he awakened the Villain System. As long as he defeated delinquent gangs, he could keep getting stronger. [Defeat the punks who came looking for trouble. Gain +1 physique.] From then on, he t 1.1kReads6.8Score10214d adds
  11. 161 Dongguan, I Am King! 莞市,我为王! Urban690k WordsOngoing What kind of legendary path will Li Feng carve out after leaving martial arts school and arriving in Dongguan? In the bright days of youth, ride proud and true. Make the most of your time, and know where you’re headed. May you roam the world for half your life, then return still young at heart... (The original cast of strongmen who rose from vocational school reunites. A new story, a fresh start!) 2.2kReads7.3Score12214d adds
  12. 162 Dark Glory: Twenty Years in the Underworld of Northeast China 黑暗荣耀:东北江湖二十年 Urban2.9M WordsCompleted 1.2kReads8.8Score10814d adds
  13. 163 The Underworld Boss Through My Eyes 我眼中的江湖大哥 Urban1.6M WordsCompleted When Zheng Hao stood up for his ex-girlfriend, Gu Xin, he took down Chengbei Laosi, a small-time thug with a bit of a reputation, twice. His own name soon began to rise. Later, he became enemies with Jin Changxu, a Korean-Chinese gangster, and beat up Chen Jianjun, an old-time thug who had just gotten out of prison. One brutal fight after another turned Zheng Hao into the big brother everyone talked about. But the arrival of Zhou Yunkang, son of veteran boss Zhou Wandai, presents Zheng Hao and h 11Reads8.7Score514d adds
  14. 164 The King of the Underworld, Forged in the Dark District 从暗黑区走出的黑道之王 Urban439k WordsCompleted (Tough gangsters + big shots from every walk of life + rich young heirs in the capital + starts at school + ruthless + a thrill ride from start to finish) The first book, The King of the Underworld: From the Dark Zone, is complete. Read with confidence, there isn't a dull moment. The sequel, King of the Underworld: I Rule with Unrivaled Power, is currently updating. The author can post ten thousand words a day, so remember to threaten him in the comments. One day, twelve young men came from the 483Reads6.9Score—14d adds
  15. 165 I Tore Open the City's Dark Curtain 我撕开了都市黑幕 Urban123k WordsCompleted [Ensemble cast + underworld] This isn’t a power fantasy or a mindless story. Every character is fleshed out, and there are no absolute heroes or villains. People can be good and evil alike. All that matters is human nature and self-interest. If that bothers you, don’t read. A seemingly ordinary workplace dispute pushes a group of everyday people into the eye of the storm. Caught in the depths of this vast, dark whirlpool, where will they go from here? —Reads—Score—14d adds
  16. 166 Skybreaker: Born Stubborn 擎天之生来倔强 Urban1.0M WordsCompleted [Urban + action-packed + youth] From the city’s nightlife to the front lines of the war on drugs, he uses underworld tactics to serve his country and people! In the end, he burns the drug dens to the ground and etches his bloodstained underworld legend into the backbone of his people! 22Reads—Score—14d adds
  17. 167 The Underworld Heiress Makes a Fierce Bodyguard 黑道千金猛保镖 Urban518k WordsOngoing [Underworld] + [Urban] + [Multiple Female Leads] + [Power Fantasy] [Not for readers under 18] Wang Meng rose from bodyguard to godfather of the underworld, unifying both the criminal and legitimate worlds. His was a life of power and grandeur. —Reads—Score914d adds
  18. 168 Underworld Tales: One Hand Shrouds the Heavens 黑道往事之只手遮天 Urban1.4M WordsOngoing [Realistic, not overpowered, no harem, no System, not reborn] A novel about the southern underworld, telling the story of several young men who avenge their brother and gradually rise to become crime bosses. Whether it is the underworld or organized crime, it is all just a game of chess, a set of rules, fraught with danger and human cunning, and driven by power and desire. Behind the bustling city lies a shadowy underworld filled with darkness and desire, where power and money intertwine, and te 356Reads8.6Score—14d adds
  19. 169 The Man Who Reached the Top of the Underworld 黑道触顶之徒 Urban1.1M WordsCompleted The underworld is shallow waters teeming with big shots. Thousands shout my name: Brother Tian. Xia Tian, a young man from the bottom of society in Northeast China, gets caught up by chance in the feud between two underworld bosses. From then on, he sets out to climb to the top of the criminal world. Benefactors, moles, bandits, desperados… all sorts of characters take the stage, and the action is heart-pounding. Watch as he leads his brothers from small-time nobodies to become the biggest kin 3.7kReads8.8Score25514d adds
  20. 170 The Women I Met in Dongguan Back in the Day 那些年,我在东莞遇到的女人们 Urban2.9M WordsOngoing [Urban underworld + no System + nostalgia + beauties + power struggles + ruthless action + pure wish fulfillment, no self-torture] Back in Dongguan in 2004, he rises from bodyguard to nightclub beauties to the godfather of Dongguan's underworld. Li Zhan moves to Dongguan for work and meets A-Zhen, who works at a nightclub. After an unexpected incident, Li Zhan drives away a customer harassing A-Zhen, only to find himself at odds with the local underworld. To survive, he's forced into the crimina 22.4kReads8.6Score1.7k14d adds
  21. 171 The Underworld: A Life in the Jianghu 黑道:人在江湖 Urban1.2M WordsCompleted What is the underworld? No one can really say. To me, the underworld is the jianghu. The jianghu has its own rules and its own stories. It’s not all fighting and killing. More than anything, it’s about human relationships and navigating the ways of the world. In 1996, a film about young gangsters influenced countless young people, leading them down a path of no return... That same year, after four years in prison, I walked out through those heavy doors and regained my freedom. My name is Fang We 197Reads6.7Score—14d adds
  22. 172 Eight-Year-Old Bandit: I Made Forbes Through Extortion 八岁悍匪:靠敲诈勒索进入福布斯 Urban152k WordsOngoing [School gangsters + How a ruthless bandit is made, coming-of-age story] [Reborn + Passionate + Arrogant + Bandit of the century + Blackmail and extortion + Robbery + Building a criminal organization + Satisfying read + No System, just pure badassery!] [Five chapters a day, plenty to keep you fed!] [In the style of Gao Qiqiang, the story of a bandit's rise. Don't read if you don't like it.] Zhang Shiqiang, the bandit of the century, was taken to the police station at age twelve after getting into 2Reads—Score—14d adds
  23. 173 The Pawn Who Crosses the River: Beyond Forgiveness 过河卒:罪无可恕 Urban2.0M WordsCompleted People who make money through shady dealings need to learn to burn incense and pray to Buddha. Those who move in the underworld have to believe that good things come to those who wait. After the turn of the millennium, Jiang Xinze was kicked off the police force for saving someone. He led his brothers into a world of guns and blades, with blood on their military daggers, riding the winds of a turbulent era to forge a dazzling legacy. If you’ve got a score to settle, settle it. If you won’t back 10kReads8.5Score77614d adds
  24. 174 Tales of Dragon City: Stories of a Small Town 龙城往事之小城故事 Urban156k WordsCompleted A realistic portrayal of northeastern China from the late 1980s to the present, full of grudges, grievances, and social change. Follow a group of impressionable young people as they face a host of challenges and opportunities and discover what it means to grow up. Realistic fiction, not a wish-fulfillment story, with a slow build. 87Reads—Score514d adds
  25. 175 Tales from the Lower Streets (Complete in Three Volumes) 下街往事(全三册) Urban583k WordsCompleted An unforgettable memory of raw courage, a brutally honest chronicle of human nature: sharp, wild, and burning hot. The shock forged from love, hate, and passion swells through every line, leaving you breathless. The novel’s protagonist spends his entire childhood surrounded by frenzied violence and bloodshed. The decade of disaster leaves an indelible mark on him, leading him to believe that violence is the best way to protect himself and that he can make something of his life through force. Ins 132Reads9.0Score2314d adds
  26. 176 Dirty Cop 黑警 Urban1.4M WordsCompleted “I gave my heart to the moon, but the moon shines on the ditch.” As a people's police officer, it is my duty to defend the country, maintain social order, and protect the lives and property of the people. But there are always people who operate in the gray areas, acting with abandon and flouting the law. I have no choice but to step in and wipe them all out... 10.6kReads7.9Score57914d adds
  27. 177 Selfish Desires: Tales of the Underworld 私欲:江湖往事 Urban1.3M WordsCompleted [This book is based on a true story] Three years ago, I was convicted of intentional assault and sent to prison. After getting out, I wanted to live an ordinary life. But then my younger sister went down a path of no return. For her sake, I had no choice but to return to the underworld! This book is packed with thrilling action and satisfying moments! 1kReads7.5Score11614d adds
  28. 178 A Gangster's Son Enters the Police Academy and Goes on a Rampage! 黑二代上警校,杀疯了! Urban152k WordsOngoing Human nature is neither good nor evil; one thought is all it takes for others to pass judgment. [Savagery] [Greed] [Desire] [Power] [A refined and elegant heiress] [A proud and spoiled noblewoman] [A sexy, scheming green tea] [A teacher who stirs up trouble] [A mature, perceptive bathhouse owner] [A sweet, innocent, insecure girl] Violence can't solve everything! But for extreme situations, it's a splendid way to handle things! [Su Hu]: “I want both my brothers and the gold!” (The story begins a 316Reads—Score—14d adds
  29. 179 The Underworld’s Final Ballad 黑道绝响 Urban1.0M WordsCompleted (Original title: Black Road, Final Echo) What is the underworld? Is it really not about fighting and killing, but about the ways of human relationships? Wrong. Only those who can still stand after all the fighting and killing have the right to talk about human relationships. My name is Luo Ping. I witnessed the so-called underworld in a corner of the southwest go from its golden age to its decline, until at last its echoes faded away. This is my story, and a glimpse into one corner of the underw 50.4kReads9.4Score5.4k14d adds
  30. 180 Blood Prison's Mad Overlord 血狱狂枭 Urban2.6M WordsOngoing The down-and-out youth Zhao Tian suffered the slaughter of his entire family as a boy. After vanishing for many years, he returned to exact revenge, rise to power, establish the Blood Prison, and dominate the world. With a band of brothers who would lay down their lives for him, he embarked on one journey after another, stirring up waves of bloodshed across the martial world… 16kReads8.5Score1.2k14d adds
  31. 181 The Bad Guy: I Transmigrated into Xie Wendong, but I Won’t Join the Underworld 坏蛋:穿越谢文东,我不混黑道了 Urban1.9M WordsOngoing Xie Wendong opened his eyes and discovered that he had become the younger version of the future underworld kingpin. Looking at his youthful yet ruthless face in the mirror, he smiled. “Run with the underworld? That’s way too low-tech.” Armed with modern business thinking, he founded the Dongsheng Group. San Yan became chairman of the security group, Li Shuang took charge of logistics, and Jiang Sen switched careers to become 1kReads—Score6814d adds
  32. 182 Making a Living on the Side in Australia 我在澳洲捞偏门 Urban537k WordsCompleted This story is based on real events. I came to Australia with a dream of studying abroad, only to be driven to the brink by reality. From a lowly street-level smuggler to a force to be reckoned with, commanding the underworld and crossing the world, I paved my way to power with cunning and bloodshed. Only when I stood at the summit and looked back did I realize that the most dangerous gamble of all is the one you make with human nature. This is a road with no turning back, but who knows which cor 25Reads—Score414d adds
  33. 183 The Day I Went to Prison: She Blazed a Trail Alone and Smashed My Shackles 入狱当天:她单枪铺路,为我砸镣 Urban160k WordsOngoing [Not Reborn]+ [No System]+ [One Female Lead] The last big sister of the underworld! The day I went to prison, she broke into the jail and smashed my shackles, clearing a path for me with a gun in hand! If the rest of my life is destined to be without light, at least in this moment, she is by my side! Some even call her the last big sister of Southeast Asia! Truth is, she was just forced to take charge in a crisis, with no other choice! Since we're already fugitives, then let's take our dark love 451Reads8.1Score—14d adds
  34. 184 Sichuan Gangsters 四川黑帮 Urban395k WordsOngoing What is the jianghu? Everyone has their own answer. But in my more than twenty years of experience, the jianghu is a game of chess, one in which everyone is both a piece and a player. Once you enter the game as a piece, there’s no way out. Once you enter the jianghu, there’s no turning back! My name is Liang Yu. I’ve been a piece, and I’ve also been a player! Note: I’m not Er Ge. I’m a huge fan of Er Ge. If you don’t know who Er Ge is, just search for Healing-Style Dou on Tomato Novel! 86Reads—Score314d adds
  35. 185 The Tiger Roars Across the Central Plains 虎啸中州 Urban158k WordsCompleted Three cups of wine for the mortal world, one pot of tea for a legacy that lasts a thousand years. What does it mean to truly live? Let me tell you what it means to unleash a ferocious tiger. Some ride horses, some sit in sedan chairs, while others push carts and shoulder their loads. I’ve never admitted defeat. You can beat me a thousand times, but I still won’t cry!!! 252Reads—Score1614d adds
  36. 186 King of the Underworld: I Rule with Unmatched Power 黑道之王:权势滔天我为王 Urban687k WordsCompleted [Urban + underworld + feel-good power fantasy + big shot + no System + two heroines + mildly risqué] This novel is also known as "After Storming the Prison, I Became the Underworld Emperor" and "The Underworld King Who Rose from the Dark Zone", the first part. This is the second part and can be read on its own. Two chapters are all it takes to get your fix. Qin Shiyi came from the Dark Zone. He brought his brothers to Pearl City in District Two, hoping to make something of themselves. By fightin 868Reads7.0Score—14d adds
  37. 187 Tiger Husband 虎夫 Urban7.0M WordsOngoing [Born to be somebody, just going through a rough patch for now!!!] 4.4kReads8.8Score43314d adds
  38. 188 The Young Marquis of the Borderlands: This Assassin Isn’t That Cold 边关小侯爷:这个杀手不太冷 Historical219k WordsOngoing [A killer transmigrates + martial world battles + court intrigue + countless beauties] Tang Mou, a young marquis on the border, has a reputation as a good-for-nothing playboy, but in reality, he's a top assassin who transmigrated into this body! Eight hundred battered soldiers against a hundred thousand Northern Slaves? No problem. To me, these barbarians are just easy pickings! Corrupt court officials scheming against me? No problem. Your tricks are nothing but amateur work! Martial world facti —Reads—Score114d adds
  39. 189 The Path of an Ordinary Person 小人物的路 Urban286k WordsOngoing A person has to make many choices in life. Everyone has choices of their own. Everyone has their own path. As for whether a path is right or wrong, no one has a definitive answer. (The story spans quite a lot.) 1Reads—Score—14d adds
  40. 190 The Stubborn Song of the Condor Heroes 射雕里的宋之倔强 Martial Arts505k WordsCompleted This book has no System. The soul of a martial arts heir from a later era merges with Han Xicheng, the grandson of Han Tuozhou in the Song dynasty. After Han Tuozhou's ambition leads to the failure of the Kaixi Northern Expedition, he is purged in a coup by Shi Miyuan and Empress Yang. Han Xicheng escapes the flames and goes into hiding with his guards, concealing his identity. As he grows, he steadily hones his martial arts, encounters the jianghu sects from The Legend of the Condor Heroes, and 2Reads—Score—14d adds
  41. 191 Be the Fiercest One 做最凶的那个 Urban476k WordsCompleted Lin Yu had always been troubled by a question: Why must good people endure eighty-one trials to become Buddhas, while bad people only need to lay down their butcher's knives? Fairness has never been something the poor get to talk about. If you want fairness, there's only one way: make yourself strong enough to create it. This world has both light and darkness. It won't treat you well just because you're kind. His father was unable to repay his debts and eventually took his own life. The creditor 594Reads6.3Score—14d adds
  42. 192 1980: A New Order in the Underworld 一九八零:江湖新秩序 Urban1.6M WordsCompleted What is the martial world? Wherever there are people, there will be conflict! The strong survive, and the weak perish. That is the martial world! Relive the 1980s and pay tribute to a youth long gone! This is the story of Han Yue, and how he rose from the bottom to the top of the provincial capital, only to fall again! The road through the martial world is treacherous. Everyone survives by their own wits! Hold on, and you can make something of yourself. Give up, and you're out... (This book is p 3.8kReads8.7Score22814d adds
  43. 193 The Delinquent Who Changed the Rules of the Jianghu 不良之江湖换天 Urban107k WordsOngoing Pan Bo, a member of the Black Tiger Gang, had the woman he worshipped stolen from him. In a fit of rage, he castrated a man in broad daylight. After serving 12 years in prison, he is released and tries to reintegrate into modern society. With help from an old friend, he enrolls in a vocational college to turn his life around. How will the story of the Black Tiger Gang continue with Big Brother Wang Hao and Yu Chengfei back on the scene? After his release, Pan Bo will get his revenge and win back 3Reads7.4Score114d adds
  44. 194 The Dragon Rises in the Martial World: A Father's Promise 龙起江湖·父诺 22k WordsCompleted 13Reads—Score—14d adds
  45. 195 The King of Hardened Criminals from Prison 监狱出来的悍匪之王 Urban2.2M WordsOngoing In 2001, Hanjiang City was named the safest city in the country. Chu Tianhong made an indelible contribution to that distinction, because two of his underlings were arrested. 21.5kReads8.8Score1.2k14d adds
  46. 196 Destined for a Life in the Underworld from Birth 从出生开始就注定混黑道 Urban882k WordsOngoing No System! No brainless antics! Packed with thrilling, iconic moments from beginning to end! My big brother told me to go to school and protect the campus belle, but I ended up reading her a love letter in front of the whole school? The son of the boss of a rival gang wants to be my underling? A gorgeous, wealthy woman wants me to marry her? It's gotten to the point where I don't even want to run with the gang anymore. I'm surrounded by gorgeous, wealthy women. I really don't want to work hard a 3.3kReads7.2Score23614d adds
  47. 197 Tales of the Northeast: The Turbulent Nineties 东北往事之九零风云 Urban1.7M WordsCompleted (Hot-blooded) (Brotherhood) (Youth) (Fast-paced, no dragging things out) The law-abiding worry all day, while the mighty sing all night. Those who harm others for their own gain ride in comfort, while the honest and fair go hungry. Those who build bridges and mend roads go blind, while those who kill and set fires have plenty of sons. I went to the Western Heaven to ask Buddha. Buddha said, “There's nothing I can do either.” This novel tells the blood-and-tears story of Shen Congwen, a great und 6.9kReads8.9Score43114d adds
  48. 198 Heading South in 1996: I Take My Young Aunt and Conquer the Underworld 九六南下:我带小姑奶闯江湖 Urban206k WordsCompleted [Period] [Fleeing an arranged marriage] [Heading south for work] [Passionate underworld] [Multiple heroines] New Year’s Day, 1996. Chen Yaozu, a poor lad from southeastern Henan, flees south overnight with his young grandaunt, who is being forced into marriage. As soon as they arrive in the Pearl River Delta, his classmate’s cousin kicks him out of her rental, leaving him homeless. He steps in to help someone, only to be hunted by gangsters. At the factory, he’s bullied, and people even set thei 640Reads—Score10114d adds
  49. 199 Underworld Chronicles: Rising from Selling Leather Shoes 黑道往事:从卖皮鞋开始崛起 Urban1.7M WordsOngoing [Period Jianghu] [The Rise of an Ordinary Man] [Brotherhood] "Everyone else pays fifty. You pay two hundred! If you don't want to pay, get lost!" Zhou Zheng couldn't understand why it was so hard to do something as simple as sell shoes from a street stall. After three years of reeducation through labor, he couldn't find a job when he got out. He and his parents scraped together what they could, and he swallowed his pride and borrowed another three thousand yuan before he could set up a shoe stal 15.4kReads8.1Score87314d adds
  50. 200 Schoolyard Storms, Northeast Underworld 校园风云,东北江湖路 Urban680k WordsOngoing [Wherever there are people, there will be a world of the underworld] [A Northeast underworld story] [Decisive and ruthless] [A road of no return] [First person] [Recollections] [This story is entirely fictional. Any resemblance to real people or events is purely coincidental.] My name is Han Tian. I was kidnapped by human traffickers as a child and forced to beg on the streets. It wasn't until Uncle Han rescued me from them that I was given a name. He showed me that a person could live like a re 10Reads—Score214d adds

Save search

Name these filters to come back to them later.