
蒹葭苍苍
- Status
- Completed
- Length
- 32k Words
- Genre
- Danmei (BL) · Ancient Era
- Era
- Ancient Era
- Released
- ~2016
- Updated
- 10y ago
- English
- Request English
Stats
13 Chapters
37 Favorites
Readers who added it to their shelf on JJWXC1.1k Avg clicks
Clicks per chapter: average reads of a chapter8.0 Score
JJWXC readers' rating12 Comments
Reader comments on JJWXCSynopsis
Where to read
I Don't Want to Work Overtime for New Year
[□□ X Li Xunhuan] Zhuang Zhou
Cold Touch
I Think I Adopted a Fake Cat
[□□ X □□] Unrestrained
[Sun Ce X Cao Ang] A Tale of Ghosts
Saint Seiya: Untitled Stories of the Specters
The Lost Fruit
The Ways of Xiliang
[Hongwan X Yagami Iori] Honey-Scented Fruit Tea
The Castle Inn
Xiuyu's Collected Notes
In booklists 1
Reader comments 9
Machine translated: Title and synopsis by GPT-6 Luna, Comments by Google Translate.





Finished watching, here's my rating! ヽ(??▽?)ノ Oh, it's not angsty at all... But if you say it's sweet, I won't listen! I won't listen! [Runs away] I'll just interpret the last part as him returning to the beginning after dying of old age. That's my interpretation, I won't accept any other interpretation!
After reading those comments, they're incredibly insightful. No wonder you initially said you wanted to discuss writing techniques with me; unfortunately, I'm really not the right person, this girl is perfect. I'll just say a few words, because I don't agree with everything she said.
The character development is decent, not too badly written, and the plot and key moments are somewhat original. The remaining issues are common mistakes in romance novels; these can be overcome gradually.
Don't just tell a flat story. Don't just tell a flat story. Don't just tell a flat story. I'll say it three times. Even if you're making a spin-off of a serious drama, don't just provide a dry, unemphasized background. Oh well, I'll forgive you; your writing style is basically that of a short essay/novel.
You know the battle scenes from official history, right? Sieges, pursuits, defenses, ambushes, and so on—the whole process. The issue is the transition of perspective. From a soldier's point of view, the battlefield is chaotic, but a general commands a large area. You're writing about a commander, a general, not just soldiers, so it's not as confusing.
You wrote those small scenes, those conversations between one or two people, very well. However, many large-scale scenes and conflicts can be described in just a few words. In terms of detail, while this approach is feasible, it inevitably feels somewhat bland.
The setting and writing style are quite good. The reason why it is not attractive enough On the one hand, it's written in a very casual, prose-like style, making it easy and convenient. However, many high-stakes, conflict-filled scenes become dull if avoided. This point, as observed in most fanfiction, is difficult to avoid. On the other hand, the emotional descriptions are somewhat drawn out and flat. Human emotions are like that, but the description and perspective still require some skill...
It's well-written and fairly close to official history, but it's too rigid and lacks liveliness. It sounds very serious, but it also makes witty remarks. To be frank, the descriptions and character portrayals are indeed somewhat superficial; it reads more like a notebook than a collection of stories.
Why can't I post a comment?