
Dream of the Red Chamber Characters (Essays)
红楼人物(随笔)
- Status
- Ongoing
- Length
- 3k Words
- Genre
- Unknown
- Era
- Unknown
- Updated
- 13y ago
- Source
- JJWXC
Synopsis
Tags
1Chapters
18Favorites
5kClicks per chapter
17Comments
More by this author
Invincible Encyclopedia [Quick Travel]
Gentle Evil Boy
On the Impact of Habits on Appearance
The Salvation of Withered Camellias
The Little Paw's Struggle
A Basketful of Beauties
[Pride and Prejudice] Dear Lydia
Dear Isis [Daughter of the Nile]
When the Louvre Meets the Forbidden City (The Deer and the Cauldron Fanfiction)
Princess Taiping
A Beauty Tempered by War (Heavenly Sword and Dragon Slaying Saber Fanfiction)
Let's Switch Places
Reader comments 17
Translated by Google Translate
I think the author thinks about people very well. First of all, I have to say that children who are really subjected to cold violence are like magic horses. You can actually tell it when you look at Yingchun, Xichun, Tanchun, and Daiyu. Yingchun's cowardice, Tanchun's character is also self-interested, she can cherish the coldness of spring, and Daiyu is sometimes sharp. However, the reason for these comes from the Jia family's lack of attention, and what about Xiangyun? We modern people know a lot about it. I think it should be easy to see the difference between the real and the fake, right? Assuming that Xiangyun's uncle and aunt are not good to Xiangyun, I simply can't understand, which movie is Shi Xiangyun missing or how did he grow into the character in the book? I remember hearing someone say that the way you look is half nature and half nurture. So I'm curious, how could an abused child be like Xiangyun? But what does Xiangyun say about his family to the outside world? Look at the original work. Anyway, judging from Shi Xiangyun's performance, the historian is not very friendly to Xiangyun, and being a female celebrity is really not too much. Unless the Shi family is done playing, there is no way they can let Xiangyun's own clothes come from his own needlework. This is really unrealistic. From here we can see Shi Xiangyun's character. Later, Shi Xiangyun compared Lin Daiyu to an actress, perhaps because he was really outspoken. I accepted it, but Lin Daiyu was angry and didn't say anything. Shi Xiangyun was very unhappy. This was really an example of giving someone a thumbs down. Some people still think Lin Daiyu is petty, which shows Xiangyun's generosity. I think the age of a girl of thirteen or four in ancient times can be equated with the age of eighteen or nine of modern people. Children of this age also have limits on how outspoken they can be. Let's talk about it ourselves: When we were having a high school graduation party, we passed by a KTV room and there was a "picture of Sora Aoi" who looked like your classmate (you knew that the girl was for sale, but don't go into details about it. We all knew how low the status of actors were back then). Would you say it outright? I'm pretty sure I won't. If you don't particularly hate a person and don't have bad intentions, you won't be able to say such things. These words are really annoying to you, and they can't be equated with swearing, right? Compared with Daiyu, Shi Xiangyun is really not miserable. Shi Xiangyun seems quite miserable now, but in ancient times, her situation was much better than Daiyu, and she knew this, because Shi Xiangyun could go home, but Daiyu had no home after Lin Ruhai's death. Just like that, Daiyu didn't really get angry with Shi Xiangyun. Just like that, some people still said that Daiyu was sensitive. Oh my, the more I said it, the more I hated Shi Xiangyun. No matter how we debate the matter of being an actor, Daiyu is the one who is magnanimous. As for who has bad intentions, it's a matter of opinion. To say that Xiangyun is ignorant is really to look down on Miss Shi. Miss Shi knows how to give things to the four maids, and there is a paragraph in the original text that Baochai did not do anything.
To say Xiangyun is vicious is a bit excessive, but it is inevitable that she herself is jealous of Daiyu. And she's not really careless - who is the girl she's befriended? Ping'er, Yuanyang, Xiren, and Jinchuan, these four are all the most respectable girls around the people who are really in power or favored by the Jia family. She has offended Daiyu the most, but she has never been grudged by Daiyu. Rather than showing that this is a child's lack of restraint and unintentional speaking, it is better to refute Daiyu's petty nature! Daiyu is the one who is truly magnanimous and disregards past grudges, okay? Now, compare yourself with a low-ranking lady and see if she will be angry! Think about what a ruthless person Xue Pan is. He competes with others for Xiang Ling. He dares to beat people to death. However, he teased Liu Xianglian and was beaten as a matter of shame. But are there few good-looking people around the Jia family? Didn't Wei Ziying and the others also flirt with each other, so why didn't I see him teasing anyone? Baoyu and Jia Lian were both male and female. Did he ever tease them? That is to say, he actually regarded Liu Xianglian as an actor, and Liu Xianglian beat him, so he felt ashamed. This shows how embarrassing it is to be regarded as an actor. As for why Jia's family didn't respond? Firstly, Shi Xiangyun's surname is Shi and not Jia, so he has no right to deal with Xiangyun. Secondly, how many times has Xiangyun appeared in the show since then? Very few! Of course the superficial reason was that they were going on a blind date.
Shi Xiangyun has never targeted anyone. He was only dissatisfied with Sister Lin, so he left a very deep impression. He was played by the attacker and applauded. It was quite powerful.
Xiangyun targeted Daiyu in more than just these ways, and spoke ill of Daiyu to the two attackers. When Baoqin got Jia Mu's fur coat and came to Baochai's place, he hinted that Daiyu would be jealous, but Daiyu was not. I think Xiangyun is not exactly as glorious as Cao Gong praised, and his jealousy of Daiyu is quite obvious. Of course, it is also true that the relationship between Xiang and Dai became closer later.
In ancient times, actors were basically the same as actors. Their status was so low, much lower than Sora Aoi. In fact, I always thought it was quite vicious to say that the new girlfriend of Milk Tea Sister's ex-boyfriend looked like Sora Aoi.
Nowadays, too many people are confused by irresponsible posts on the Internet that only seek novelty and novelty. Also, they have read too many messy fan stories and can no longer tell what the original work is.
It is said that Shi Xiangyun was too vicious, but it is true that she was jealous of Lin Daiyu. Think about it, before Daiyu came, she was the girl that the old lady and Baoyu cared about most. After Daiyu arrived at Jia's house, she stepped aside, which made everyone feel unbalanced. Xiangyun is just an ordinary girl.
A real rich lady still wants to fawn over a few maids from her cousins. Who would believe her if she says she has no scheming and no purpose, unless you tell me that Shi Xiangyun is also wearing one, the kind of Mary Sue who says that all living beings are equal? Who is the concept that the ancients should have?
I have not read Red Mansions many times myself, and some of them made sense based on other people's comments. For example, some people said that Red Mansions should actually be read backwards. For example, there is almost nothing wrong with Mrs. Wang and Xi Ren in the book, but the comments about these two people are almost always kind-hearted and evil-hearted. So even if Cao Gong said that Xiangyun is rich and powerful, she may not have any intention of disliking Daiyu. Besides, in ancient times, the age of marriage was reached at the age of fourteen. We cannot use the mental age of modern people as twelve or thirteen years old to confuse the ancients. Moreover, it should be common sense that the status of actors in ancient times was low. Even girls of twelve or thirteen years old should have enough understanding. To say that Xiangyun is vicious is a bit exaggerated, but I think maybe Xiangyun is not that good after all.
I like Tanchun the most, brave and resourceful