
Stats
1 Chapters
18 Favorites
Readers who added it to their shelf on JJWXC5k Avg clicks
Clicks per chapter: average reads of a chapter17 Comments
Reader comments on JJWXCSynopsis
Where to read
The Ultimate Encyclopedia [Quick Transmigration]
The Gentle Brat
On How Habits Affect Appearance
The Salvation of Withered Camellias
The Little Paw's Struggle
A Basketful of Beauties
[Pride and Prejudice] Dear Lydia
Dear Isis [Daughter of the Nile]
When the Louvre Meets the Forbidden City (The Deer and the Cauldron Fanfiction)
Princess Taiping
A Beauty Tempered by War (Heavenly Sword and Dragon Slaying Saber Fanfiction)
Let's Switch Places
Reader comments 17
Machine translated: Title and synopsis by GPT-6 Luna, Comments by Google Translate.
I think the author has overly romanticized the characters. First, I must say what children who truly suffer from emotional abuse are like. You can see it in Yingchun, Xichun, Tanchun, and Daiyu. Yingchun is incredibly timid, Tanchun's personality is inexplicably selfish, Xichun is cold, and Daiyu is sometimes sharp-tongued. The root cause of all this is the Jia family's neglect.
To call Xiangyun vicious is a bit of an exaggeration, but it's undeniable that she was jealous of Daiyu. Moreover, she wasn't truly without guile—who were her close maids? Ping'er, Yuanyang, Xiren, and Jinchuan—these four were all the most favored or powerful maids in the Jia family. She offended Daiyu the most, yet Daiyu never held a grudge.
Shi Xiangyun never targeted anyone except Lin Daiyu, whom she held a grudge against, so she left a very deep impression on her. She was quite shrewd to be manipulated by Xiren.
Xiangyun's actions towards Daiyu weren't limited to these few instances. She spoke ill of Daiyu to both Xiren and others; when Baoqin received the duck-down fur coat from Grandmother Jia and came to Baochai's place, she subtly implied that Daiyu would be jealous, but Daiyu didn't. I feel that Xiangyun wasn't entirely as virtuous and upright as Cao Xueqin portrayed her; her jealousy of Daiyu was quite obvious. Of course, it's also a fact that Xiangyun and Daiyu's relationship later became closer.
In ancient times, actors were basically equivalent to prostitutes, their status was so low, much lower than Aoi Sora. Actually, I've always thought it's quite malicious to say that the new girlfriend of the "Milk Tea Sister's" ex-boyfriend looks like Aoi Sora.
Too many people are misled by irresponsible online posts that only seek novelty and sensationalism, and they've read too much random fanfiction, making it impossible to distinguish what the original work actually says.
Saying Shi Xiangyun is malicious is an exaggeration, but it's true she was jealous of Lin Daiyu. Think about it: before Daiyu arrived, she was the girl the old lady and Baoyu cared about most. After Daiyu came to the Jia family, she was sidelined. Anyone would feel resentful. Xiangyun was just an ordinary girl, after all.
A true heiress still has to curry favor with several of her cousins' maids. Who would believe she's innocent and without ulterior motives? Unless you tell me Shi Xiangyun was also a time-traveler, one of those Mary Sue characters who preach equality for all? Who, then, should have the views of the ancients?
I haven't read *Dream of the Red Chamber* many times myself. Some of my reading came from other people's comments that I found very insightful. For example, some people say that *Dream of the Red Chamber* should be read in reverse. For instance, the book hardly describes anything bad about Lady Wang and Xiren, but they are almost always portrayed as kind on the outside but treacherous on the…
I like Tan Chun the most; she's brave and resourceful.