From the Start, the Sky Screen Delivers a Scathing Review of the First Emperor: His Merits and Faults Spark a Huge Debate
开局天幕锐评秦始皇：功过吵翻天
- Status
- Ongoing
- Length
- 273k Words
- Genre
- Historical
- Subgenre
- Historical & Ancient
- Updated
- 12mo ago
- Source
- Fanqie
Stats
Tags
Synopsis
More by this author
Li Shimin's Soul Transformed into a Charming Girl, and When He Opened His Eyes, He Kicked Li Zhi
The Bamboo Horse Knight Finally Defeats the Prince from Heaven
Three-Body Expedition? Record of Car Overturn at the Gate of the Kingdom of Light
Time Travel Through Pig Man, Super Lollipop Is Banned!
Genshin Impact CP Collection
An English Gentleman's Guide to Living Together with a French Rose
Historical Confession
National Fate: Thank Goodness We Lost Again
In booklists 62
Explore more →
Historical Novels You Absolutely Can't Miss!!!
What? He gets to be a dad after being reborn? A soft, adorable little girl keeps chasing him and calling him Daddy? What? Qin Shi Huang, who's lived for two hundred years, keeps chasing after him, desperate to take him as his apprentice and learn the art of immortality? From the Great Xia Kingdom's top soldier to the Prince of Changyi!
Modern Historical Fiction Has Almost No Gems. Disagree? Come Debate Me
The protagonist should not be sanctimonious, and the novel should not be mindless.
Desperately Short on Historical Fiction, Please Recommend Some to Save Me From This Reading Drought
Preferably a historical novel with a realistic feel.
Historical Novels with a Sky Screen, Logical Arguments, and More Than Just Personal Opinions
I want something like *The Sky Screen: The Accidental and the Inevitable in History*.
Sky Screen Stories with Historical Rundowns That Every Dynasty Can See, Preferably Convincing
High-Quality Historical Novels
Historical Fiction: No Nonsense Allowed
It doesn’t have to be completely historically accurate, but at least don’t make it ridiculous. I want power struggles and political maneuvering that make sense. People shouldn’t just get confused all the time and believe the protagonist at first sight. The language doesn’t need to be perfectly period-appropriate, but please don’t throw in internet slang and memes at every turn.
Looking for High-Quality Historical Fiction. No Mindless Power Trips or Brain-Dead Plotting
I want high-quality historical fiction that’s engaging and doesn’t dumb things down or rely on brainless plots. It can be satisfying, but don’t treat readers like idiots. No stories like the one where the protagonist fools Cao Cao’s quartermaster about the provisions from the start, or those where a literati protagonist suddenly has the strength of a tyrant. They’re unoriginal and mindless...
Brothers, These Historical What-If Novels Are Guaranteed to Be a Blast
To help everyone get their fill of history, I'm recommending a few satisfying historical novels. My friends all say they're amazing! I picked every one of these myself, so give them a try!
Sky Screen Stories These Days All Seem to Have a Sense of Superiority
How should I put it? The plots are all the same old stuff. Please recommend a good sky screen novel with no romance and no brainless characters. Ideally, the protagonist should be male. Don’t blindly praise any particular person, criticize ancient times using modern values, or act superior.
Historical Stories (Any Dynasty, No System, and with Intelligent Characters)
Looking for books like *The Glory of the Great Wei*. Historical novels with some brains behind them. Read too many mindless wish-fulfillment stories and they’ll rot your mind.
Please Recommend Some Great Qin Dynasty Novels!!! I Can't Go a Day Without My Beloved Zheng!
I want to read books like Guys, Who Gets It? The System Got Hijacked by Qin Shi Huang. No romance, please. I want stories focused on helping Brother Zheng build his empire. Thanks, everyone!!!
I'm Obsessed with Historical Livestream Stories. Give Me the Number One Book on Your Shelves
I want to read books similar to "After Videos Connect to Ancient Times, the Emperors Secretly Compete with One Another." During the reigns of emperors from different dynasties, a light screen or ranking list appears in the sky. It displays the history of each dynasty's emperors, or someone explains that dynasty's history. Interaction would be fine too, but it is not required.
Great Historical Fiction
Make it realistic, not too over-the-top.
New Books Only! The More Underrated, the Better!
Any new book will do. I’m open to anything, especially books that haven’t gotten much attention. It’s hard being a new author, so let’s not leave them writing to an empty room, okay?
Has Everyone Noticed That Tomato Has Added So Many New Books? The Quality Is Really OK 👀
New Authors (Warning! Don't Recommend Works by Big Names.)
I want to discover authors who haven’t received much attention.
I Want Historical Stories with a Sky Screen!!
I was scrolling through Douyin and suddenly wondered: are there any stories where people from ancient times watch Journey to the West in a livestream? I really want to know!
Sky Screen Stories That Don’t Just Talk About History. Who Can Keep Watching History Videos All Day?
Looking for Historical Reaction Stories with a Historically Rigorous Perspective, Thank You
For example, Starting with Emperor Jing’s Reaction Watch. I’d prefer no romance, or a historical figure as the protagonist.
Looking for Sky Screen Stories Featuring Historical Viewing, with Smart Characters
Please recommend stories where people from ancient times see the modern world. They must be logical, sensible, and well-supported!!!!!!!!!!!! I've read a few and they were so bad they made me sick!!!!!
Looking for Historical Fiction with a Wild Premise, Set in Another World
Editing Is Dead, Long Live Watch-Party Fics!
Any Historical Sky Screen Novels That Don't Grovel to Any Emperor?
Looking for books similar to *The History Lecture Hall: Do You Want to Be Emperor?*.
Reader comments 23
Google Translate
Finally, there is someone who is not mindlessly bragging about the First Emperor and Zhu Yuanzhang.
Clear stream! The emperor is no longer called "ancestor", but is truly affirmed and criticized. It is neither one-sided flattery nor one-sided smear. It is rare. It pays great attention to the true historical scene. It is neither one-sided smear nor flattery for the emperor of the Qing Dynasty. North Korea, compared to others I have met, said that Alexander's Eastern Expedition did not exist, that America belonged to the Chinese, and that the Yin Shang were the first to discover the American continent. It is much better, but if you want to mention the West later, don't fall into the trap of nationalism. Of course, I believe the author will not.
It's okay, but the evaluation of Qin Shihuang is still too kind. If we really evaluate his car, track, book and post road in detail, they were all pioneered by Zhou Gong. It took the Eastern Han Dynasty to complete. Ying Zheng played more of a transitional role and it was Zhou Gongdan's Zhou Li who laid the foundation for China.
Let's take a look. This is a girl who played Qin that I met in the Douyin comment area a few days ago. This girl was very arrogant. She thought I had nothing to offer and posted that piece of information to kill the game. As a result, I took out some historical materials and papers and was dumbfounded for a while, and then started to change the topic boringly. To open up a new track, the discussion is obviously about whether the people's livelihood in the Qin Dynasty was good or not, and whether Qin Shihuang himself was cruel or not. This guy didn't answer directly. She didn't care what I said. She just proved that the Qin Dynasty was good by publishing some historical materials about the poor life of the people in the Han Dynasty [face covering]. I thought that the Qin Dynasty was only a few years old, and natural disasters were not taken into account. She also frequently publishes irrelevant newspapers to prove her claim that the people's livelihood of the Qin Dynasty was good. For example, a piece of a People's Liberation Army newspaper said that the military of the Qin Dynasty was good. She also used it to prove that in terms of people's livelihood, it was wrong [face covering] I couldn't get around it later, so I asked her to answer directly. She said that the laws of the Qin Dynasty were actually very good and could reflect a high level of moral standards [laughing awkwardly] [crying with laughter] I won't tell you how many there are. If you look at the screenshots in the comment area, you don't know how many can be sent.
People who like the emperors of the Ming and Qing Dynasties are also weird.
The writing is relatively objective and does not overly praise or belittle any historical figure.
The author writes very objectively. Although there are still many things worthy of discussion, it is a rare masterpiece in the current environment where most people talking about history on the Internet are extreme fans or nationalists. It can be seen that the author has really researched a lot of information in order to write this book. The author's own historical accumulation is also sufficient, and his attitude towards history is also very rational. It is a masterpiece that is rare in a century.
As for you, you are not like most of Tianmuwen. I only know how to praise you, and that is enough.
I feel like you can write more advanced questions to inspire the ancients. The merits and demerits of many wise kings and saints are sometimes also caused by luck, geographical problems, natural disasters and ice ages. It is necessary to broaden the horizons of the ancients. There are many mistakes at the same time, and it is easy to get worse without a strong enemy to help you make them. For example, the hidden dangers of the Tang Dynasty began when Li Yuan killed the rebels in Hebei. Li Yuan stole the military merits of his relatives and killed Liu Wenjing, which was a king with the talent to subjugate the country. Many people did not criticize the love between children, but because the Tang Dynasty was always prosperous, they ignored local issues. The bombing is a little better than that of the Western Jin Dynasty. After attracting foreign soldiers to help and allow looting, they passed by.
A good book. The only bad thing is that the author is too civilized and friendly, and can negotiate peacefully with some non-human comments...