There Are No Saviors in the Pirate World

The last article Relying on the power of the people to carry out revolution from the bottom up and using the power of the masses to carry out revolution like this book, taking our path Some readers think it is illusory, wrong and impossible. It is utopian to think that the great generals and the four emperors can only be attributed to individuals, and that relying on the people's armed forces to make a violent revolution is utopian. Personally, I think these readers are really unrealistic and have made dogmatic mistakes. If you have read the content of my three articles, it should not be difficult to find that I think from a class level The Tianlong people can be compared to the feudal emperor (actually the Manqing Emperor), and the navy has its own interests and appeals to another class (barely considered the bourgeoisie). Everyone knows that the protagonist team represents. As for the rest, for example, the rights of the participating countries of the World Government are equivalent to the governors of the states in the United States, and their status may be similar to that of the provincial officials of the Qing Dynasty, so they can basically be ignored. The Yonko are equivalent to foreign countries, and the Yonko themselves are not much different from the Celestial Dragons. Then first make it clear what the protagonist's purpose is, the most obvious and simple one is to eliminate the Celestial Dragons or even eliminate the Celestial Dragons as a class. Specifically, how to distinguish between enemies and friends, draw friends over, and beat enemies to death. To put it simply, this is it. As for who are friends and who are enemies, how to draw, and how to fight, please see the author's performance. Some book friends feel that the generals and the four emperors are of no use to the power of the people. If Akainu is in a meteor volcano, the entire country will be gone, and there is no way to fight. This involves another aspect. To put it simply, if you want revolution, you must have guns. Some people said that if you have a gun in your hand, it is useless, but Akainu still can't beat him. It can't be like the real world. But it must be understood that the gun here refers to strength, the power to resist, and the power to fight. A simple analogy is as if Akainu alone is a complete armed armored army plus logistics, etc. What he eats and sleeps is supplies. His physical strength is ammunition. When he punches someone, his gun power is covered, and when he rests, he replenishes his ammunition. It's very powerful, but why should I use the masses to fight him? Your comparison is like leading a group of children with stones, bows and arrows to attack a Japanese regiment head-on during the Anti-Japanese War. Is it funny? What should you do when you are not strong enough to fight head-on? Lurk, hide yourself, accumulate strength, and accumulate a force that can resist. Some people look down on the power of the people, so I asked Ace in this book, what class does Sauron belong to, is it considered the power of the people, and can they fight against the generals in the future? Is Fujitora, the green bull of the future, considered the power of the people? Why spread your ideas? It is necessary to pull these forces over, including some generals in the navy. Are these people all powerful? To put it bluntly, Akainu is the ace unit, and I must use the ace to deal with the ace. Besides, doesn't Akainu bleed? Will he not die? Can he survive the sea-floor, stone-Katyusha wash? As long as good conditions are created, anyone in the One Piece world can be killed. The only difference is the cost. Some people think that in a world where strong people exist, just looking at strong people is enough. How strong people come from is not something ordinary people can train themselves to do. It's just that some people have talent and some people don't have talent in this area. There is one person with the potential of a general among 10,000 people. If there is only one person with the potential of a general among 100 people with the potential of a general, does it mean that the more people we have, the more likely we will be able to produce a general? As for other people, they have their own areas of expertise and talents. Why should butchers and hunters compete in hunting, and detectives and actors compete in solving crimes. The above points are all personal thoughts and everyone is welcome to discuss them (I am relatively lazy and generally do not write comments or read discussions. I may suddenly get interested at some time and read it, so some book friends may not see it for a long time after commenting 🤭)

Regarding the fact that the protagonist is too weak, many people think that he is easily assassinated, easily affected by big moves and then dies from an unknown AoE. The protagonist uses his brain. He knows this, so he has always acted according to his sudden death. He built a system and conveyed a thought! The revolutionary army can still operate as usual even without him. The fire of revolution has spread all over the world. At this time, it is already very uneconomical to assassinate or kill the protagonist. This is why the protagonist uses his own wisdom to protect himself. The role played by the protagonist now is actually a symbol of belief and an object of belief for revolutionaries. His own wisdom is not unique, his vision and thoughts have been passed on... What's more, the protagonist's future encounters depend on the author, and the author will not write the protagonist to death.

I haven't read the book yet, but I've read a lot of reviews. I have a general understanding of what this book is about. A person traveled through the past and brought Marxism and communist ideas to the pirate world, and then carried out revolution. However, the protagonist is suitable for trash, so that's what it means. First. The author should not choose the world of Pirates, because Pirates is not over yet and no one knows what Im's abilities are. If Im has the ability to destroy the world, only people from the D family can survive. Then the protagonist's revolution is completely useless. This is not a conjecture. The original book said that the world government has something that can destroy the world. Second. I think it is ridiculous to rely on Marx's thought or the revolutionary experience we already have. I do not deny the greatness of Marx's thought, but just like the class limitations mentioned in Marx's thought, the existing Marx's thought and revolutionary theory and revolutionary experience were born in our world without extraordinary abilities. For a world like pirates where personal power is attributed to themselves, our thinking itself already has class limitations. This is just like Newton's laws of the birth of the macroscopic world are completely inapplicable in the microscopic world. Of course, this is just a guess. Whether it can be successful still requires the practice of senior time travellers. Third, let's talk about whether the protagonist will die. Many people say that the protagonist will die as soon as he touches it. Many people argue that there is someone to protect him. Many people say that it doesn't matter if the protagonist dies because the idea has been spread. First of all, the protagonist is really easy to die. Even ten generals can't stop a dead general from killing an ordinary person. Secondly, there are too many weird Devil Fruits. Some of the ones that have appeared now are very unnatural, just like the Time Fruit. Another cursed fruit is not too much. I don't think a government that has ruled the world for eight hundred years is incapable of killing an ordinary person, even if that person is surrounded by several general-level protections. You must know that it is much more difficult to protect a person than to kill a person, and most generals are not good at protecting. Let's talk about whether it's important that the protagonist dies. If it is a real world, then it really doesn't matter whether the protagonist is dead or alive, because the idea has been spread, but what we are reading is a novel, and what we are looking at is the protagonist. If the protagonist is really not important, why doesn't the author let the protagonist die, and then write a magnificent history of the pirate revolution? After all, we are still reading novels and we need a protagonist, so this is very contradictory.

I read reviews saying that the main character is a badass. . Who at the top of the pirate world is not a strong person? Why do you talk about changing the world if you don't even have the capital to stand in the same place as those top strong people? Anyone can kill you, and the aftermath of a war can destroy you. This is really meaningless

It's a very idealistic book. The previous part about convincing the empress was really held by the nose. How could you not lead a single soldier, have no strength, and go to convince a unknown Shichibukai? This is just one of them. There are countless such problems. Although you shouldn't pay too much attention to details when reading books, those who boast about their masterpieces have little education.

It's a great book. It reminds me of the novel about nuclear-powered battleships I read before. To be honest, I personally don't want this book to become popular. If it becomes popular, I'm afraid that it will cause all kinds of troubles and eventually disappear 😭. But I am happy to recommend this novel to others. Contradiction🤐

In a world where power belongs to oneself, without strength, everything is fake. If you reform, others will directly destroy you. If you can't stop it, you will die. After death, no matter how good the reform is, it will be useless.

In this book, the strength of the generals is infinitely reduced. Only three generals can defeat the Four Emperors, and only six generals can defeat a group of Four Emperors. Moreover, the Four Emperors can run away as long as they are willing. So I want to say that the setting of the author Oda has been eaten by you?

When I saw the introduction, I didn't want to read it. We all know that in troubled times, a scholar is useless, and yet he talks rhetorically and talks on paper.

After reading the novel, I always felt that something was strange and that it lacked some revolutionary flavor. After going back and looking through the review materials for the postgraduate entrance examination, I gained some insights. The author focuses on the various means and measures of revolution, but does not touch on the fundamentals of revolution, and rarely mentions revolutionary ideas. The following are some of my own opinions, from a very utilitarian perspective (I believe that the vast majority of civilians are utilitarian, and their first concern must be their own food, clothing, housing, and transportation, and their own interests. The development of a noble personality requires the support of the environment and the foundation of food and clothing.) The order established by revolutionaries is to redistribute benefits to civilians, in order to gain strong support from the people. The revolutionary party expropriated the land of big landlords and the assets of big businessmen, redistributed them to civilians, and established a relatively fair system to protect the interests of civilians. Therefore, the common people who had nothing to lose followed the Revolutionary Party wholeheartedly after receiving the land. Therefore, the common people actively accepted the various reforms and propaganda of the Revolutionary Party. Therefore, the Revolutionary Party relied on these soldiers who had just left the farmland, as well as the worst weapons and equipment and the weakest soldier quality among all parties, to build an army with the strictest military discipline and the strongest resilience. Because of sufficient publicity, the soldiers knew that they were guarding their homes and land. No other party will be as generous and just as the Revolutionary Party. Therefore, the number of troops of the Revolutionary Party is increasing as they fight, and among the forces of all parties, they are the least afraid of death. The main sources of navy and pirates are basically civilians. (After all, the number of nobles is small, and most of them are addicted to pleasure and support themselves.) The Revolutionary Party can firmly capture the hearts of the vast majority of civilians, and then there will be a steady stream of new blood and strong people to join. Aren't the three navy admirals and Fujitora both born civilians? Even among the Four Emperors, Auntie must have come from a commoner background. It can be said that most of the top fighters in the pirate world are born civilians. In terms of hard conditions such as combat methods, general quality, weapons and equipment, troop quality, funding sources, etc., The revolutionary party most of the time lags behind all parties. The author of this book always emphasizes reforms in these aspects.