Stormy Song Dynasty

From the author's last book to the present, the author has a good foundation in the history of the Song Dynasty, and his writing style is also very good. The systems and technology trees in the book can withstand scrutiny. It can be said to be a guide to traveling through the Song Dynasty. There are many exciting points, but the performance of this book is confusing. It should be ranked in the top 10 in the history category, which is where you are.

The author's writing is quite good, and I followed up from the previous book Stormy Song Dynasty. I feel that the author's problem has never changed, that is, he loves to talk theory, and he has a sense of loss that everyone is drunk and I am sober, which invisibly makes people uninspired. To be honest, there must be theory, otherwise the novel will have no depth, but it cannot be too much, otherwise it will become preaching. I hope that the author's lectures will be concise and comprehensive, and his writing style will be positive and passionate.

Peeping-proof😂😂😂😂 The biggest drawback of these two books is that there are no heroes, and the stories must be based on people. The story I saw was that the author arranged for a middle-aged time traveler to do his best and use his forward-looking vision to help a "dynasty that seems backward now" to achieve its glory beyond the times. The story is solid, but! Really, it's painful to watch. Speaking of "smart" lines, (the plots of these two books rely on "lines rather than character plots"), is socialism smart enough? Marx was a theoretical discoverer and theorist, and Engels was a social activist. I regard the protagonists of the two books as a combination of the two. From the perspective of social practice, the two big brothers Marx and En are "just" the convening of the World Proletarian Congress and several subsequent ones. But the development of socialism as a whole, familiar countries, the Soviet Union, Cuba, Vietnam, Czechoslovakia, North Korea. . Countries have different development and different problems. The heroes who promoted the development of socialism are Lenin and Stalin. . . The development of capitalism is even more exciting. The protagonist came up with some idea of ​​​​solving the problem, not to mention that there were actual successful examples! Just not! Even if there is a little bit of hope, there will be countless people with lofty ideals who will continue to work hard. To arrange such a plot would be to underestimate the ancients! In terms of the servility of the people, the ignorance of their thinking, the strength of foreign enemies, and the rise of domestic thieves, there is no one who can compare with me, the Qing Dynasty, right? How about now? !

I couldn't stand it any longer. I read more than twenty chapters and saw that I was successfully persuaded to quit when I was thinking about buying wine grains. This is the legendary moral kidnapping. People who don't save themselves are not worth saving.

Magister Liu Xiu 🤪

Great book, why are so few people reading it?

I wrote a book and I don't know how it goes. Is there anyone who has time to come and read it and leave a review by the way?

I have read this book several times and listened to it several times. Although not comprehensive, it still reflects the development of a process. There are also details. Still can't learn anything from this article though.

Poison This start is silly and sweet.

The textile industry is very particular. Goat hair is not suitable for weaving into fine cloth and can only be used for tents and felts. The first thing the wool textile industry must solve is the breed of sheep. Only sheep that are specialized in producing wool can do it. There is only one breed of sheep in the world that is suitable for wool textiles, the Spanish Merino sheep. In addition, the cotton textile industry has similar problems. Cotton is an original species in India and is a tropical plant. It basically cannot survive in temperate zones. Therefore, it is impossible to provide a large amount of cotton before cultivating cold-resistant varieties. Moreover, cotton is divided into long-staple cotton and short-staple cotton. . . In fact, the foundation of the development of human society is agriculture and animal husbandry. Different varieties of agricultural and animal husbandry products directly determine the production structure and life structure. There is nothing wrong with the author's golden finger, but I think it is better to round it out.

Today I read a book "History of Chinese Clique", which mentioned the struggle between the Northern and Southern Clique in the Northern Song Dynasty. I don't know if this new angle of interpretation of party strife can hold up, but the bits of information mentioned in it are indeed eye-opening. From the previous book "A Life of Wealth", I feel that the protagonists subconsciously want to stay away from party strife. In the previous book, the protagonist made his fortune quickly and early, forming his own faction. Later, he was inevitably dragged into the banner by others; in this book, the protagonist seems to be unable to avoid party strife, right? The question is not whether we can avoid party strife, but how to avoid duplication with the previous book. My opinion is that party struggle is a fact and a current situation. To avoid repetition, why not write a little bit about it? Otherwise, the original amazingness has cooled down, and now it is very dull and difficult to attract people. A bit off topic, I would like to share with you some interesting examples from the summary book: 1. Wang Anshi wrote in "The Book of Statements" that the world "suffered from the failure of Jinling (Wang Anshi) to govern". Northerners rumored that the sound of cuckoos was heard on the Tianjin Bridge in Luoyang, which foreshadowed that "when the southerners are prime ministers and special tasks are changed, the world will be in chaos" 2. Han Qi: "Anshi will be in power for a long time." A Hanlin scholar is more than enough, but he cannot be in the position of assisting Bi." 3. When Lu Huiqing discussed the new law with Sima Guang, Lu Huiqing said, "Why don't you just say something? If you don't follow your words, why not go?" Shenzong had no choice but to explain: "How can we argue with each other?" 4. Fu Bi Wang Anshi dismissed the prime minister and changed the sentence to Ruzhou. Wang Anshi was still willing and said, "Although Bi is responsible, he still does not lose his wealth and honor. In the past, Gun was killed by Fang Ming, and Gonggong was killed by Xiang Gongliu. Bi committed these two crimes and stopped seizing the chancellor. Why should he punish the traitor?" The emperor did not answer. Bi said: "I don't know the new law, so I can't govern the county. I would like to return to Luo to take care of my illness." Fu Bi was eventually forced to become an official.

Anda, I think that after the book "A Life of Wealth" failed to end, you will definitely be able to write a great Song Dynasty book.

Let's start with a little story. In the early years of Xining, Sima Guang made suggestions on the management of the Yellow River. Emperor Shenzong saw it and thought it was good, so he planned to appoint Sima Guang to take charge of the management of the Yellow River. Then an important minister, Lu Gongzhu, a veteran of the old party, stood up and said: "River management is complicated, so it is not the reason why we should praise those close to the job and treat Confucian officials." This means that river management is not something that the state should send Confucian officials to do for the purpose of giving preferential treatment to Confucian officials. At first glance, this question seems to mean that Confucian ministers have a special superior status. However, the question arises. River management always needs to be done by sending people to do it, and the person who does it should be at a similar level to Sima Guang. So it should be more than two systems. If he is a Jinshi, he is not considered a "Confucian minister" who needs preferential treatment? There is no such truth. Therefore, the "Confucian ministers" in this sentence may have a specific reference, and the country's use of such Confucian ministers also has specific appointment and transfer routes. In this context, Lu Gongzhu came up with the words "no method of treating Confucian ministers." What it actually means is that there are special methods for using cadres like Sima Guang. Emperor, you'd better use them according to the established methods. So what is this kind of Confucian official? What are the specific ways to use it? I think this kind of Confucian officials are cadres who, after passing the imperial examinations and high-level subjects, have held various government positions, mostly working in retreat departments in the capital, focusing on ideological construction but lacking practical work experience at the grassroots level. A typical example is Sima Guang. There were many such figures in the Ming and Qing Dynasties, such as Weng Tonghe, Guangxu's emperor. The way to treat Confucian officials is to make the best use of their talents. Let them do ideological work, write documents and talk about things, and let others do the actual work and the things that require responsibility. Most emperors have no big problem in effectively performing the job of "head of state", but they are often unable to perform the role of "head of government" well. At this time, some professional "professional managers" must be needed to solve this problem. The role of these professional managers is the prime minister. For the emperor, the prime minister is also the biggest threat to his authority. It is not uncommon in history for the prime minister's power to usurp the imperial power. Therefore, the emperor must have a group of people to restrain the prime minister. For the emperor, it is often difficult to catch the prime minister's shortcomings in specific work and the consequences are serious, because finding problems in specific work will make it difficult for subsequent successors to adapt. Then the most effective "opposition party" is the "Confucian ministers" who hold high the banner of Confucian ideology. From an ideological point of view, The rebuttal was based on a high moral level, and the emperor had relatively large discretionary power in handling the matter, which was just right. Since the prime minister was the head of the bureaucracy, it was actually impossible to handle everything in line with Confucian ideology. After all, he had ammunition and achieved the sustainable development of the entire mechanism.

I couldn't stand it after watching the beginning. The author does not understand the privileges of the ancient literati class. In the Song Dynasty, the scholar-bureaucrats ruled the world together. Did they think they were just a few officials above the temple? Are you kidding me? No matter how depressed the literati are, how dare a few restaurant businessmen dare to bully them? They are the ones with the lowest status

After reading more than a dozen chapters, no wonder the author's book is not on the list. He buys good wine with distiller's grains, and then he is afraid that others will have no food to eat, so he goes to charity? He can't even take care of it. Where is the Holy Mother from? According to your heart, do you seek peace of mind in every business you do? This kind of thinking doesn't matter in modern times. In ancient times, it might have been said to be deceptive and evil-intentioned.

In this book, I feel that the technological tree of steam engines has climbed too fast. In the early days, low-pressure steam engines were only so-so for driving cars and ships, and it was a bit exaggerated to use them for trains. With Du Jinglue's understanding of technology in the book, it is impossible to achieve practical medium-pressure steam engines in more than ten years. An Jun wrote well about the official system, military system, Confucianism and reforms of the Song Dynasty, but his writing about scientific and technological knowledge was really poor. You must know that it was not easy to develop a steam engine in the Song Dynasty, and it was not so fast to put into production practical railway locomotives. To make a steam engine, you must have machine tools. You must first solve the processing problems of bearings, spindles, gears, screw rods, etc., And other machine tool components. After the components are solved, the hydraulic machine tool can be assembled, and then the cylinder, piston, connecting rod, gear, flywheel and other parts of the steam engine can be manufactured. Okay, cutting tools are necessary, right? At worst, you have to get a crucible of carbon tool steel to make knives, right? How to measure carbon content? How to judge the temperature of molten steel? All these require a long time and a lot of practice to get results You also have to find a way to roll seamless steel pipes to transport high-temperature steam... And you also have to research and make oil-containing packing for sealing... You can't do all the mechanical processing alone, and you also have to teach your disciples basic mathematics, basic physics, and mechanical drawing. , Tolerances and coordination, machining technology, turning technology, boring technology, milling technology, grinding technology, casting technology, heat treatment technology... To make a low-pressure steam engine, we must first solve the power problem of the machine tool, and then solve the accuracy problem of the machine tool itself. Without higher-precision machine tools, a medium-pressure steam engine cannot be developed. The improved steam engine invented by Watt was far inferior to the steam engine developed by Du Zhongxiao. However, the error of the boring machine used by Watt to boring the cylinder was within 1.5 Mm. Think about it, can Du Zhongxiao's original machine tool be used to make a practical medium-pressure steam engine? Even after the steam locomotive has been built, it still needs dispatching, maintenance, and operation personnel, and it will take a lot of effort for the time-travelers to train. The ancients had no experience, so you have to lead some people first... So there are too many problems. In the Song Dynasty, if the time-travelers were not graduated in mechanical processing, they wanted to create a real-time travel system in the mid-to-late 19th century. It will take a lifetime to get to know the basics of using high-speed trains. Of course, even if you can build a low-pressure steam engine in a lifetime, it is still worth it. If you are a mechanical time traveler, you will have to spend fifteen to twenty years of exploration and talent training before you can hope to achieve the performance of the train in "The Wind and Rain in the Song Dynasty", and mass production may not be possible. An Jun, let me give you a piece of advice. "The Storm in the Song Dynasty" is worse than "A Life of Wealth". Readers who like "A Life of Wealth" just like your ideological nature. As long as Anjun demonstrates his thoughts and theories through stories one by one instead of preaching throughout the book, he will definitely be very popular. But you have to cater to the appetite of some people. You can climb the technology tree, or you can climb the technology tree. You have to write in a reasonable way, but the current result is that it is impossible to paint a tiger as an anti-dog. Anjun, the emergence of the steam engine was a major explosion of the industrial revolution. The Song Dynasty will face great changes. There will be development in various places. They will not stand still waiting for Du Zhongxiao to attack the Western Regions. Therefore, how to deal with the production relations after the Song Dynasty has the steam engine is the real problem. With medium-pressure steam engines, the Khitan, Xixia, Western Regions, and Jiaozhi are no longer a problem. The Song Dynasty can destroy them at will. It is completely boring for Anjun to write about these one-sided wars.

Have you ever discovered that Qidian is a group of fake textual research parties, using the historical phenomena of the Ming and Qing Dynasties to forcefully peddle the entire ancient Chinese history, and then using gossip materials from countless hands on the roadside?

I think the reason for the slow progress of this book is that the author wants to write it seriously. Boss Du has no connections and is too young. He wants to carry out drastic reforms but has no capital. He doesn't want to rebel and is not an emperor. When the powerful officials are old and no one cares about them, they just want to develop the economy and develop rapidly in the officialdom. First, they have mixed seniority, and second, they support their own people, develop a community of interests, and a community of ideas and destiny. By then, being a powerful official will not be in place. The most important thing is that the author is poor and has no money to cheat Xiao Du...😁😁😁

This book is written like a history textbook, the plot has no ups and downs, and is even more flat than my great-uncle's electrocardiogram.

​ ​ First, I subscribed and voted, but I can't stand it anymore. It made me very angry, and I wanted to complain about it under the book. Isn't it too much? Some people say that the beginning is very poisonous, but it is just a little poisonous. The growth of the characters requires a process that can be tolerated. The middle part from the imperial examination to the external recommendation to the county magistrate is very well written. The author has an understanding of the official system and customs of the Song Dynasty, and he is not a copycat. As for the fact that he went from a modern person who has no knowledge of classics and history to becoming a Jinshi within two years, this is a golden finger. This is why I subscribe and actively vote. It is reasonable to go to Bianzhou for a period of time later. Steam engines and fire cannons (why must they be called muskets) can be built with money and resources using Song Dynasty technology, but your craftsmen? Relying on a beggar boy? Is it okay to be taught casually by you? It can be explained that the boy is very talented and has to drill the gun barrel. It is enough to cast the cannon in iron mold. During the Opium War, the British still used copper cannon and clay mold iron cannon! Trains are made casually. Trains are the flower of industry! How many months will it take to lay 300 kilometers of railway? Do you know how long it took Britain to lay the first railway? The Westernization Movement in the late Qing Dynasty had not been able to build a locomotive for many years... And it had been going on for so long without being impeached by the imperial censor... Obviously what was written before was pretty good. When the county magistrate was appointed, he would work hard in the fields, and when the border state was open, he would set up a small army with a golden finger, and then find theoretical basis to support scientific development based on Confucianism, and just fan his wings at certain nodes. The industrial hair that the author writes about is really a poisonous point. I feel like I went to a restaurant to eat, half of the meal was eaten, and a fly appeared in the meal. Why, I paid the money and I can't refund it. I don't want anyone to say... I slipped away. I can't afford to offend the boss.

The protagonist will do more and more scientific and technological work in the future, and it is impossible for one person to complete it.

As soon as I entered the door, I saw Xia Yun beating Chang Wei until he was covered in blood.

[To avoid arrogance, I will first indicate that I am the deacon of this book with 8,000 fans] . My biggest dissatisfaction with this book is the author's treatment of Han Qi and Di Qing. Damn Han Qi's historical sentence [Donghuamen roll call] , Fang is a good man] It's so disgusting. It wipes out Di Qing's achievements and contributions to the country, and insults Di Qing's origin. Why in this book, the author praises Han Qi so much and makes Di Qing fade away. I really can't accept it.

Novels are meant to be enjoyable to read, but this one was really irritating and frustrating. The protagonist of the novel was insulted and women were bullied. The protagonist only picked up the discarded sheep's hooves and did not even care about his own woman. Women are worse than sheep's hooves. Reading this novel is simply asking for abuse. Abandon the book, abandon the book decisively. I have never felt so frustrated. Not giving up the book is simply asking for trouble. Abandon the book, abandon the book decisively...

I've read dozens of chapters, but I can't stand it anymore. It's so toxic. Farewell.

Some thoughts, I hope the author can see it. What can I say about this book? The short white text at the beginning has a sense of visual acuity, and the rest of the content is okay. What makes me feel most uncomfortable is the author's description of the technology tree, from steam engines to trains. It is really uncomfortable to watch, and the sense of dissonance is overwhelming. Maybe the author is a little confused now after going through the final madness of the previous book, or it may be said that he was led by some readers. How to cater to readers' preferences while maintaining their own style is something every author who wants to succeed needs to consider. Although it is difficult, it is not impossible to find. I think the first thing an author should do before writing is to pre-plan the audience for his book. In other words, the content logic of your book should try to "please" some of the readers you intend to attract. It is unrealistic to expect a book to attract so many readers. A simple approach is to continue to attract this type of readers based on the readers of the previous book, and at the same time avoid the content that these readers are taboo about. In order to make a breakthrough, try to make sure that the new elements cannot be rejected by old readers, such as rigorous history and Xiaobailiu science and technology. As for Qidian's current new book recommendation and search mechanism, for old authors, I think most of the first readers of new books are drawn from old books. I think we cannot ignore the consideration of the feelings of old readers. After all, fans are accumulated one by one, and compound interest benefits must be taken into account when opening new books. You can't offend old readers until they finish a book, and then attract new readers, instead of retaining old readers and attracting new readers at the same time. (Insert, I came from the old book, but I can't read it anymore!) I think this is also the reason why there are a lot of disagreements in the book review area. Old fans and new book readers are arguing. After all, they are not a group of readers, so their evaluation standards for books are naturally different. Although they are all speaking for the author and doing it for the author's good, they still can't tear it apart.

The author's biggest shortcoming is that he doesn't understand economics. You should read Adam Smith's "The Wealth of Nations". How can government-run enterprises compare with private enterprises? It seems that businessmen are exploiting. Without interests, humans have no pursuits. This is human nature.

I read everyone's book reviews, combined with my personal point of view, the characteristics of Anhua Army: It's a slow start. The protagonist spent nearly 300 chapters laying the foundation, trying his best to lay the foundation for transforming the handicraft workshop into an industrial workshop, and at the same time entering new technologies, new products, and new industries. Then transition to the military, and after achieving military merit, enter the top political level, develop the economy from a higher level, improve people's livelihood, promote the reform of the political system, economic system, and social system, while maintaining social stability. An Huajun and Crimson Moon are both my favorite authors. They both borrowed a lot from the governing methods of the party group led by Mao Zedong. This is the only correct development path for China.

The author's books tend to be lengthy in the later stages. Sometimes a chapter is all discussion and there is no story at all! ! So even though you learn well, you can't become a great master. When I saw it, I had no motivation to follow it, because it was all about blockbuster movies, and the story became an embellishment. .

I remember that I used to read historical novels. The protagonists were all kinds of colonization, and the development of capitalism was almost entirely Western. In the end, they ended up with some kind of constitutional monarchy, some kind of federation, some kind of empire. Although I continued reading, I still felt a little uncomfortable. It felt like the China I knew was completely different from the other country. At that time, I learned about the West from history textbooks. The books were almost all about analyzing the various advantages of the Western system, and actively Polarity, now that I have graduated from college, China is also rising and rejuvenating. I have also learned about some aspects of the Western system from various channels. After watching the videos of some experts, such as Professor Chen Ping, Professor Zhang Weiwei, Professor Wen Tiejun, etc., I feel that although the Western system has advantages, it also has many shortcomings. There is no need to envy their "democracy", "freedom", "human rights" and so on. We are living very well now. (To be honest, the West is really good at playing double standards.) I really don't understand what kind of "Jingri" there is now, including post forums and so on. I feel like there are a lot of people saying that the United States and the West are better. They all think that the West is superior. It's really annoying. I have been reading historical novels for a long time, and I sincerely hope that there will be more novels that can reflect the current system of my country, excellent national thoughts, and novels that can reflect our Chinese culture. When I read the author's book, I felt that what the author wrote could reflect the character of the Song Dynasty and our own things in China. I said this here today in Anjun, and I hope the author will not blame it. (If anyone disagrees with my point of view, please argue rationally. This is just my own opinion. I just want to express my opinions after reading the novel for so long.)