I prefer a clear difference in affection. As long as the characters are well written, I'm into all kinds of tops, whether they're sweet, doting, clingy, or anything else. My personal priorities: emotional logic > writing skill > characterization. For everything else, see the comments.
It's clear the author has been heavily influenced by certain types of writing, but overall it's quite sweet and affectionate (no negative reviews), which is pretty good! I'll read the rest when I have time. Support!