Mostly saving stories with fewer than 30,000 favorites. These days, I don't care about the protagonist's gender preference, as long as I'm invested in them. Five stars means highly recommended; most four-star stories are good but unfinished.
The Madoka Magica setting involves repeated restarts, but past memories are eroded, and when they meet again, they are no longer the lovers they once were. Whether it's the countless restarts in the early stages driven by a single conviction, or the later team's reunion in the battle against the witches, Akemi is a truly admirable character, and the ending is incredibly moving. The original female characters are also vividly portrayed; they became magical girls simply for their own wishes, yet sacrificed themselves for the public good. Each character in the final episode is unique and irreplaceable… The side story, told from the game's perspective, reveals Akemi's previously unknown contributions, and I cried buckets last night. Highly recommended!