[Western Crossover] The Spider Files

The three boys I've liked all happen to be named Peter Parker.

I fell for Spider-Man.

Then I discovered my neighbor and my friendly neighborhood Spider-Man were the same person.

After reloading my save, I found another boy named Peter Parker at school.

I fell for him all over again.

In my third playthrough, I was so fed up that I decided to stay away from anyone named Parker.

Who knew this time Peter would be the one to fall for me first?

1. First-person narration.

2. The three Peter Parkers are the first, second, and third versions: Tobey, Garfield, and Holland. Their characterization is based on the movies, though they may be a little out of character.

3. Reloading means dying.

4. The love interest is Peter Parker, but which version is uncertain.

5. The first two Spider-Men initially like the original female lead.

Theme: If you could start over