Tearing Off the Masks That Slander Xue Baochai

This is so funny, am I the only one who has a bad relationship with Chai Chai and Dai? Everyone is not perfect, and it is precisely because of imperfection that they appear flesh and blood. Daiyu has a delicate mind but doesn't tell the truth, while Baochai is tactful and has great ambitions. Speaking of which, the tragic fault of the two of them is not their own but in this era, if Baochai can do business and serve as an official, and Daiyu, as a woman, can inherit the family property, do you think who of the two can still like Jia Baoyu? The two of them have similar personalities and make up for what they lack. The two of them are so close to each other when they both judge together.

Anyway, I don't like Lin Daiyu, she always looks like the cousin of the ancient white lotus Every day he is either feeling sorry for himself or sarcastic about others. When others say she can't stand on stage, she cries and feels sorry for herself, as if no one feels sorry for her. She is very happy when she mocks others for not being able to stand up. When nothing happens, I feel like I am living in someone else's house When Baoyu coaxed her, why didn't he want to live in someone else's house? Do you stab other people's children every day? The famous double standard Lin Daiyu

They are all good girls, each with their own faults, but because Daiyu is the heroine, everything she does is right. Similarly, Baochai must be wrong, and they can't explain it to them. In fact, Baochai and Daiyu only represent two attitudes towards life. Daiyu comes out of the world and Baochai enters the world. Daiyu speaks bluntly and euphemistically. Anyway, whoever matches Baoyu will ruin them.

There is also the Didi Cuiting incident you mentioned. You said yourself that Xue Baochai was "worried about Xiaohong pestering him to spare her." It is obvious that Xue Baochai knew that Xiaohong would pester anyone who she thought had eavesdropped. She was worried about herself, but what about Lin Daiyu? Isn't this a double standard?

I also like Baochai very much. In fact, Daiyu can basically be regarded as the template for the cousin of the White Lotus in the ancient novels. In addition, the relationship between Chai and Dai was really not good during the Didi Cuiting period, because at that time, Daiyu made Baochai unable to step down several times. Baochai was not a saint, but more real. As for the golden clothes, what's wrong with comforting your aunt? It's like a modern aunt's nanny being fired and having a car accident. You think it's not enough to help for the sake of relatives. You have to be as sad as if a relative died, and in turn blame your aunt to be a good person?

They also said they slandered Xue Baochai First, an explanation on the theory that "certain big figures in certain eras like Lin Daiyu but dislike Xue Baochai." Textbooks once characterized Jia Baoyu and Lin Daiyu as anti-feudal fighters, and Xue Baochai as a feudal defender. Everyone will inevitably think about why, and then they come to the above conclusion. What I want to say is: In the Qing Dynasty, there was no such statement, and at that time it was generally believed that Lin Daiyu was extremely affectionate and sexual, and Xue Baochai was the female version of Cao Cao, a typical female supporting role, used to set off the heroine Lin Daiyu. Although she was indeed compassionate, her dark side was obvious and needless to say. When did Xue Baochai start to become a positive character? It started in the Republic of China. Because foreign ideological trends entered the country, Xue Baochai became a representative of freedom and bravery, pursuing one's own happiness, which conformed to the ideological trends of the times, and thus the image became positive. Therefore, at the beginning of the founding of the People's Republic of China, the country considered incorporating excerpts from Dream of Red Mansions into teaching materials, and organized experts to discuss it. Then they discovered that Xue Baochai herself was unsatisfactory, her image was not positive enough, and she had a dark side of selfishness in her nature. As we all know, textbooks must tell children what is right and wrong, what can be done and what should not be done. Define Xue Baochai as a positive image and encourage children to hurt others and break the law for selfish purposes? So don't throw out the sentence lightly: certain big figures in a certain era like Lin Daiyu but don't like Xue Baochai. To put it nicely, it's because you didn't know. To put it badly, it makes me think that you were irresponsible and didn't figure out the cause of the matter, or you knew it, but you told half of it and hid the other half. Intentionally causing a dispute. There is no basis for what you say, let's give an example. The plot of the reform of Grand View Garden. Those who are familiar with the original work know very well that Mrs. Wang entrusted Xue Baochai with great care. The original text is as follows: ——Now that Mrs. Wang sees him like this, Tanchun and Li Wan can't thank him for the time being. There are many people in the garden and they are afraid that they will lose their care. So they specially invited Baochai to come and ask him to be careful everywhere. Because he told him: "Old ladies are useless. They eat wine and play cards when they have time. They sleep during the day and play cards at night. I know it all. They are still afraid of Feng girl outside, and now it's time for them to take advantage of it. Good boy, you are still a proper person, and your brothers and sisters are young. , I don't have time, so you have to work hard for me for two days to take care of me. If you have anything unexpected, please tell me, and don't wait for the old lady to ask. I have nothing to say. Just tell me if they don't listen to you." Baochai had to agree after hearing this. At this time, what is Xue Baochai's identity? The daughter of the Xue family. Is her marriage to Jia Baoyu settled? It's undecided. (If it is decided, what will happen to the Xue-Lin dispute?) In fact, it was very inappropriate for Mrs. Wang to make such a request to Xue Baochai. Because Xue Baochai is the daughter of the Xue family, Mrs. Wang herself has a daughter Tanchun and a daughter-in-law Li Wan, both of whom live in the Grand View Garden. If Xue Baochai really obeys the etiquette, she should refuse. If she cannot refuse, she can pretend to be a Bodhisattva. In other words, Xue Baochai had three options at that time: First, tell Mrs. Wang clearly that this is against the rules, I can't do it, and I can't do it. Second, he could not refuse, reluctantly agreed, and then in the actual action process, he maintained the standard of being sensible and protecting himself from beginning to end. He always let Li Wan and Tanchun do things, while he sat back and expressed his stance at critical times. The specific matters were always left to Li Wan and Tanchun. Third, since you have agreed, you should simply take up the task and fulfill your duties from beginning to end, and then wait for Mrs. Wang to come back and hand over the task neatly. No matter which one of the above three paths Xue Baochai chose, I have nothing to say. But what did Xue Baochai do? Let's look at the original text: ——Everyone first heard that Li Wan was doing it alone, and everyone was secretly happy, because Li Wan had always been a kind-hearted person, and naturally he was easier to deal with than Sister Feng. So they added a Tanchun, thinking that she was just a young lady who had not left the boudoir, and she was usually the most peaceful and calm, so they didn't care, and they were much more slack than Sister Feng before. Only three or four days later, after several things had passed, I gradually realized that Tanchun didn't let Sister Feng know the subtleties, but that she was just quiet in speech and gentle in temperament. Coincidentally, in the past few days, there were more than a dozen hereditary officials from princes, princes, and uncles, all of whom were relatives or family friends of Rong Ning. Some were promoted, some were deposed, some were weddings and funerals, etc. Mrs. Wang was busy with greetings and farewells, and she was overwhelmed with entertainment, and there was no one to take care of her in front. The two of them sat up in the hall all day long, and Baochai stayed in the upper room to monitor her until Mrs. Wang returned. Every night when I have free time for needlework, before I go to bed, I sit in a sedan chair and lead the night watchers in the garden to inspect every place. This paragraph is written very clearly. At the beginning, Tanchun was the one working in the Grand View Garden, and Xue Baochai just sat there, just like Wang Xifeng said, making up his mind and not speaking, shaking his head when asked, but not knowing. It looks like she chose the second path. There is also a reason: Xue Baochai is a girl with a foreign surname, and it is not convenient for her to interfere in the affairs of the Jia family and the Grand View Garden. If Xue Baochai has always been like this, then I have nothing to say As a result, the style of painting changed next. Tanchun wanted to test reforms in the Grand View Garden, and then Xue Baochai snatched Tanchun's ideas and rights! Everyone is familiar with this section, so I won't go into details. Anyway, this paragraph is very clear. Why would Tanchun want to try out reforms in the Grand View Garden? Because she knows that the Jia family has been unable to make ends meet for a long time, and it is imperative to try reforms. Today, if you save one sum here, you will get an extra 400 taels of silver. Tomorrow, you can save two sums there, and get an extra 800 taels of silver. If you gather the sand into a tower and gather the armpits into fur, step by step, maybe the Jia family really has room for change. This is related to the future of the Jia family! It is no exaggeration to say that it is the starting point of the Jia family's century-old plan! But what did Xue Baochai do? She used this extra income of 400 taels of silver to bribe the Jia family's servants and put several eyes and ears around Jia Baoyu! Yes, her goal has been achieved, and the good relationship she values ​​​​has taken another step forward, but what about the Jia family's century-old plan? Which one is more important, her golden match or the Jia family's century-old plan? So I said that what she showed in the reform section of the Grand View Garden was short-sightedness and using public tools for personal use. Jia Baoyu repeatedly called her a coward and a ghost, and she was not wrong at all. The second episode where I hate Xue Baochai comes from Chapter 62. The original text is as follows: ——Baoyu was busy and confessed his crime before he came back with his sister. As soon as he entered the corner door, Baochai ordered his mother-in-law to lock the door, ask for the key, and take it herself. Baoyu hurriedly said: "Why should this door be closed? There are not many people leaving. Besides, my aunt, elder sister and younger sister are all inside. Wouldn't it be troublesome if I wanted to go home to get something?" Baochai said with a smile, "Be careful. You have been doing all kinds of things these days, but we are not here." People over there know that the door is closed. If it's open, it won't stop people from taking the shortcut. Why don't we lock it, and even mom and I won't be able to leave. Even if something happens, we won't be able to rely on the people here." Did you see that in Chapter 56 of the Grand View Garden Reform, Xue Baochai had just taken away the right to Tanchun, and the leading power in the management of the Grand View Garden fell into her hands. Many fans of Chai Chai will say that it is a sign of her courage to take responsibility. OK, if she really has the courage to take responsibility, then as long as she keeps it up, I have no problem with it. But what about the facts? In the sixty-second chapter of the story, chaos broke out in the Grand View Garden. Xue Baochai ignored it and directly closed the door from the Grand View Garden to the Xue family's small courtyard. As long as the responsibility was not on their Xue family but on Xue Baochai's head, she didn't care how much chaos there was in the Grand View Garden. This is Xue Baochai in my eyes! Normally, she pretends to be a good person, speaks nicer words than anyone else, and is well-rounded. No one is better at superficiality than her. But when it comes to the critical moment - there are two types of critical moments, one is good, when it brings benefits, and the other is bad, when it brings disadvantages - Xue Baochai's performance is more than chilling! When it's beneficial, she grabs credit and power more ruthlessly than anyone else! When things are bad, she runs faster than anyone else! No responsibility at all! This is Xue Baochai in my eyes! I would like to ask, are these the contents of the original work and are they clearly put in front of everyone? I hate that Xue Baochai has nothing to do with Lin Daiyu. It was Xue Baochai's actions that left me such an impression. The original work was clearly written. Therefore, please don't say in front of me that Xue Baochai is the savior of the Jia family. Even though she has this intention, she does not have the responsibility. What's more important is that she doesn't have this pattern. Xue Baochai is just as Jia Baoyu scolded him, he is a worm of the country and a thief of salary. PS: Some people want to say that I am a fan of Dai, so I give you a thumbs up. So I would like to ask, is the one I used in the above example the original text? Did I use Lin Daiyu to step on Xue Baochai?

It's a pity that the black men just say "I won't listen, I won't listen", there is nothing they can do

Thumbs up and applaud for you. What you said is great. I like Baochai very much. When I saw Hei Baochai's article, I was very angry. But I am stupid and can't write a rebuttal. I personally expressed my feelings.