
他唱的都是假的
- Status
- Completed
- Length
- 306k Words
- Genre
- Danmei (BL) · Modern Era
- Era
- Modern Era
- Released
- ~2018
- Updated
- 4y ago
- English
- Request English
Stats
66 Chapters
3.7k Favorites
Readers who added it to their shelf on JJWXC
6.2k Avg clicks
Clicks per chapter: average reads of a chapter
9.8 Score
JJWXC readers' rating
2.1k Nutrients
Nutrient gifts: JJWXC readers' free vote
Synopsis
Where to read
A Summer of Random Sales
The Sparrow Sings Again
Everything He Loved Was Wrong
I Know What You Lost in the Garden
Innocence with a Touch of Slyness
Reader comments 50
Machine translated: Title and synopsis by GPT-6 Luna, Comments by Google Translate.
Is it Qi Chuan and Xi Bai?!
Wow, so Qi Chuan and Bai Bai have already made their appearances! Hahahaha (I saw "Innocent and Evil Me" first).
I'm so nostalgic! Ahhh, it's Xi Bai and Qi Chuan!! I'm so emotional right now 😭
Hooray! Unlike others who came from the "Innocent" side, I came from the "He's Wrong" side, so I knew most about twins. Therefore, I didn't really experience the "aha!" Feeling described in the comments. But perhaps because of this, I could see the characters from two perspectives, a kind of second-time understanding.
I first finished reading this book on April 23, 2019. Thankfully, I mustered the courage to send a private message then, otherwise I might not have remembered how much time had passed. I remember tears welling up the first time I read this part with Chuan Bai. I had just finished reading *Innocent and Evil* and was immediately drawn to his song, so the feeling was even stronger. It's so wonderful. It's so good that they met. May their love never fade, and may all lovers be united.
Actually, my complete smitten with Beihe began in this chapter. I'd liked him a lot before, but I always found myself getting strangely touched by certain things. For example, the part where Beihe finally touched me was when he told Xiaofei he was breaking up with Chen, and also when he subtly changed the lyrics. It's strange, isn't it?
I love their relationship dynamic—it's both passionate and enduring!
Waaaaah, I finally finished reading this book after finishing "Innocent and Evil"! When I saw the extra chapter about Chuan Bai, tears immediately welled up in my eyes. By then, they had been together for ten years TT. I'm looking forward to my love and his upcoming new novel. Thank you, Ming-ge, for bringing me love and emotion once again!
Ahhh, it's Xi Bai and Qi Chuan! Waaaaah!!
Having come from a naive past, I really love the delicate and tender feeling that permeates the words, just like their century-long love. Actually, I almost got turned off by the love triangle in the synopsis, but I couldn't resist clicking in, and I'm so glad I did—I was completely captivated. It's not the kind of love triangle I imagined, where "I love you, you love him, he loves me."