
HP考据篇
- Status
- Completed
- Length
- 13k Words
- Genre
- No CP · Modern Era
- Era
- Modern Era
- Released
- Jan 2017
- Updated
- 9y ago
- English
- Request English
Stats
15 Chapters
285 Favorites
Readers who added it to their shelf on JJWXC2.5k Avg clicks
Clicks per chapter: average reads of a chapter8.5 Score
JJWXC readers' rating57 Comments
Reader comments on JJWXCSynopsis
Where to read
Deceiving the Whole World
Reborn as the Demon God Who Will Destroy the World
Everyday Cuteness on the Internet
[The King's Avatar] God of Investment
[Miraculous] I Am Not Crazy
[Crossover] A Beauty's Soul-Shattering Charm
[Crossover] The Right Way to Fool the Savior
Ready Player One
Reader comments 47
Machine translated: Title and synopsis by GPT-6 Luna, Comments by Google Translate.
One point I disagree with is that while Snape did have conflicts with the Marauders, most of the fights were one-on-one between James and Snape. In the books, Sirius Black was a malicious bystander who just wanted to see Snape suffer, Lupin was unwilling to intervene (partly due to his position as a prefect), and Wormtail simply watched and cheered.
Harry and Ron are definitely not academically weak. Just because they can't be with Tom doesn't mean they are. How could Ron be a prefect if his grades weren't good? Their grades are actually quite good. And even among OWLs (Overwatch League) students who get ten O's every year, very few have the status of Dumbledore or Voldemort. Harry seems weak because this book is from his perspective.
Snape is indeed incredibly talented from the original text—a master of Occlumency, a Potions Master, proficient in Dark Arts, and a formidable fighter. However, I still believe he falls far short of Dumbledore and Voldemort. This deficiency stems not only from his talent but also from his ambition and social skills.
If you have a teacher who's always watching you closely, your grades won't be very good.
I've never been a Dumbledore hater; I neither like nor dislike him, but I agree that he was a great man. I agree with the comment above; Dumbledore couldn't possibly have trusted Snape from the start. Frankly, I don't particularly like Snape, but I still acknowledge his greatness. However, to criticize Dumbledore simply because he didn't initially trust Snape is too prejudiced and narrow-minded.
It's all about Slytherins being driven by self-interest; I think they definitely knew that Voldemort's personal charisma was immense.
The original book explicitly compares Harry and Reedus through Harry's own words, both being pitiful victims of Muggle persecution.
This is actually normal. If someone from your opposing faction defectes to you because they have a crush on a woman, a leader who immediately believes them might as well go home and sleep. Many people don't understand politics, nor do they understand what it takes to be a leader.
Basically, it means that pure-blooded families, if they stay in a powerful clan for a long time, will naturally become wealthy, haha.
So it's a fairy tale, right? If such a leader really existed, I don't believe he wouldn't test his black magic experiments on others before slicing souls; he'd just use himself as a guinea pig.