Cao Xueqin's writing portrayed the Twelve Beauties with exquisite detail, yet fate played cruel tricks on them.
In circumstances like these, their tragedies seem all the more heartbreaking.
But if they had the chance to live their lives over, with their identities changed beyond recognition, perhaps their lives would not have to end in tragedy.
When Yingchun, gentle by nature and as dull as a block of wood, died at the Sun residence, her soul returned to her mother's womb. She became the daughter of Zhou, a concubine in the second branch of the Jia family, Baoyu's half-sister and a daughter born to a concubine under Madam Wang's roof.
When the sharp-witted Tanchun died in the palace harem of a foreign kingdom, she became a daughter born to a concubine in the main branch of the Jia family, a rose covered in thorns.
When Lin Daiyu, the Lady of the Xiaoxiang Pavilion, became a girl of the Xue family in Jinling.
When Xue Baochai, the Lady of the Hengwu Pavilion, became the orphaned daughter of the Lin family.
When Li Wan, who valued virtue over talent, married into the main branch of the Rongguo Mansion and became the wife of the dashing Second Master Lian.
When the clever and capable Feng-jie became the wife of the eldest son Zhu in the second branch, bringing the families even closer through marriage.
After living their lives over, what kind of futures would they make for themselves?
I picked three pairs from the Twelve Beauties of Jinling to swap identities. I really couldn't think of any other pairings that would work...
Yingchun's personality would actually suit being Madam Wang's daughter born to a concubine. But her natural abilities really can't compare with Tanchun's, so I may give her a golden finger.
Actually, as a child born to a concubine, Yingchun had it better than Tanchun. Unfortunately, Yingchun was unlucky and didn't get good parents. Let Tanchun go sort out the main branch, then.
Theme:
A rambling, repetitive, and verbose account—a waste of a great idea. The writing style is truly...
This is quite interesting.
Oh my goodness! Mrs. Wang here is hilarious!
In ancient times, the term "advancing in studies" referred to passing the imperial examinations to become a Xiucai (a scholar who passed the lowest level of the imperial examinations) or similar titles. Baoyu certainly did not fall into this category, but going to school was still an option.
The Li family married their daughter to the Jia family, and then ruined the only scholar of the younger generation in the Jia family? Is this a marriage alliance or an enmity? Don't talk about the first and second wives; in ancient times, clan ties were important. If the sister-in-law's family harmed her cousin and even affected her future nephew, how could they face the world?
While people in ancient times often had children in their teens, we modern people know that being in your twenties is not too late. So why did the author write that Yuan-chun was too old to have children? We know that Grandmother Jia and Jia Min were both in their thirties and still had children, so how could Yuan-chun be considered past her prime in her twenties according to genetics?
Fifteen is the age of coming of age, not sixteen. (The story is finished!)
May you be happy every day in the new year.
Happy New Year and all the best!
It's good that Daiyu is engaged; a smaller dowry doesn't matter, it's better than losing everything and being disliked or driven to suicide. Although Baoyu is somewhat rude, he shouldn't do anything too outrageous to his engaged cousin. Daiyu wouldn't allow it anyway, and without Grandmother Jia's interference, Daiyu should have a good outcome.