Whenever people mention Emperor Guangwu of Han, Liu Xiu, most cannot overlook Yin Lihua and Guo Shengtong.
Most people just go along with the popular opinion, thinking Guo Shengtong was a sacrificial pawn, while Yin Lihua and Liu Xiu shared the kind of love fit for an emperor.
I've never agreed with the idea that Yin Lihua and Liu Xiu shared so-called true love. But that doesn't mean he didn't love Yin and only loved Guo instead.
For an emperor, it isn't a matter of one or the other. Even if there was some affection, Yin Lihua was still a long way from happiness.
I wrote this story simply to tell everyone that historically, Guo Shengtong was no sacrificial pawn or mere spectator to an eternal love story. Her presence was impossible to ignore.
If a woman spent sixteen years as empress, keeping her romantic rival in check for all sixteen years, and bore five children, all of whom except her eldest outlived her rival's children and did quite well for themselves; if she received enough money in her divorce settlement to live on for hundreds of years, became Queen Dowager while her ex-husband was still alive, and no longer had to endure her rival's oppression; if her son also gained many benefits and her maternal family was properly taken care of, then her divorce settlement was beyond belief.
Her ex-husband even compensated her maternal family so generously that they were known as the "Golden Cave." Though her rival became empress, she couldn't celebrate and still had to be cautious. She never got to enjoy much in life because of her reputation for frugality, and before her ex-husband died, he even warned her not to follow in the footsteps of Empress Lu and Huo Guang's wife. Her rival's son also had to treat her children and maternal family as well as he had when his father was alive. By any measure, she lived a remarkable life.
Theme:
Having given birth to so many children, I, as Yin Lihua, would never believe that she didn't love them. When the emperor deposed the empress, there was no question of fault, only reasons. Therefore, there was no question of compensation. Guo Shengtong had no support in court, no need to put on a show for the world, and no need to be cared for for so long. Therefore, I still believe that the deposition of the empress was a helpless act under specific historical circumstances.
Forget it. If compensation equals love, then Liu Qiangdong probably loved his ex-wife terribly, and so did Rupert Murdoch. Those wealthy men who risked their fortunes to divorce their ex-wives and remarry must have loved their ex-wives deeply, in ways others couldn't understand.
Liu Xiu was considered a relatively benevolent emperor; he tried his best to balance the status of his two wives, which was commendable. However, the edict he wrote to depose the empress was so harsh! I find it strange. If he felt any guilt or affection for Guo Shengtong, the edict wouldn't have been so harsh—it was like a series of slaps in the face!
Actually, what you've written is a lot of old stuff, and I've seen it many times elsewhere. The counter-arguments from Yin Lihua's fans are just as numerous, listing examples where they argue that Empress Guo Shengtong's life as Empress was more aggrieved, and Yin Lihua's was also miserable. The only winner is Liu Xiu.
Liu Xiu was considered a relatively benevolent emperor; he tried his best to balance the status of his two wives, which was commendable. However, the edict he wrote to depose the empress was so harsh! I find it strange. If he felt any guilt or affection for Guo Shengtong, the edict wouldn't have been so harsh—it was like a series of slaps in the face!
I cannot agree with the author's view that the more compensation one receives, the deeper the relationship. Especially since this so-called compensation is mostly material things like money. If this logic holds true, then wouldn't men who leave with nothing in a divorce be considered to have deep feelings for their ex-wives? Then why get divorced in the first place?
Liu Xiu was considered a relatively benevolent emperor; he tried his best to balance the status of his two wives, which was commendable. However, the edict he wrote to depose the empress was so harsh! I find it strange. If he felt any guilt or affection for Guo Shengtong, the edict wouldn't have been so harsh—it was like a series of slaps in the face!
Actually, what you've written is a lot of old stuff, and I've seen it many times elsewhere. The counter-arguments from Yin Lihua's fans are just as numerous, listing examples where they argue that Empress Guo Shengtong's life as Empress was more aggrieved, and Yin Lihua's was also miserable. The only winner is Liu Xiu.
I'm not a fan of Yin Lihua, but I don't think either woman was a winner. Liu Xiu was a competent emperor. I feel the author is biased towards Guo Shengtong, and I don't like articles with strong biases in their historical assessments. Besides, regardless, Yin Lihua was the first wife, and I think she deserves more sympathy. Guo Shengtong was a victim of her family, but her ending was acceptable.
I'm not a fan of Yin Lihua, but I don't think either woman was a winner. Liu Xiu was a competent emperor. I feel the author is biased towards Guo Shengtong, and I don't like articles with strong biases in their historical assessments. Besides, regardless, Yin Lihua was the first wife, and I think she deserves more sympathy. Guo Shengtong was a victim of her family, but her ending was acceptable.