
HP同人文评论和推荐
- Status
- Ongoing
- Length
- 5k Words
- Genre
- No CP · Alternate History
- Released
- Apr 2015
- Updated
- 4y ago
- English
- Request English
Stats
8 Chapters
371 Favorites
Readers who added it to their shelf on JJWXC11k Avg clicks
Clicks per chapter: average reads of a chapter6.0 Score
JJWXC readers' rating86 Comments
Reader comments on JJWXCPaused Pace
Synopsis
Where to read
[Ashes of Love] The Cheerful Tale of Run Yu
[Harry Potter] The Story of Harry Potter's Character Collapse
[Harry Potter] The Messenger of Nurmengard
In booklists 1
Reader comments 64
Machine translated: Title and synopsis by GPT-6 Luna, Comments by Google Translate.





As a Harry Potter fan, I'm honestly quite pleased to see Harry mature, strong, and elegant years later. But deep down, Harry is a member of the Potter family; no matter how much hardship he endures, his kindness and sense of justice will never change. Harry wished for a happier childhood, hoping to find him a distant relative, someone almost entirely unrelated to him.
It's definitely worth reading if you're going to joke around with Mary Sue characters. I would recommend books like this without hesitation, because its emotion, sincerity, and beauty make me believe everyone will be moved by its content. I just want to praise the world for having such insightful and knowledgeable authors who bring these stories to life. You'll definitely be touched in those parts, just like I was. I look forward to you giving it a try.
The author of *Fate Spiral* has decent writing skills, and as an omnivore, I also followed her other paid *Dream of the Red Chamber* fanfiction. However, her problems were more glaring in this one, and I couldn't handle it halfway through and gave up.
That article's subtle satire of Sirius Black was a major reason why I dropped the series...
Professor Snape x original female lead, let me recommend The Butterfly Effect and The Singer, they're really super good! There's a really good book called "Looking at You" lately. It's about Snape and an original female protagonist, but it's set in the modern era (I've always felt that a professor who hasn't experienced everything is just a perfect, loyal dog imagined by everyone, so I've never…
Honestly, *Spiral* is a masterful blend of satire and whitewashing, and the writing is truly superb. Unfortunately, I'm a die-hard Gryffindor fan, and when I saw Sirius being portrayed negatively, I realized I'd read yet another Mary Sue fanfic about a black lion washing away a snake.
The Messenger completely changed my perspective on Harry Potter fanfiction; it truly captured the Harry I envisioned. Honestly, I absolutely hate saccharine, overly simplistic characters and mindless bashing! Harry really can't be the saccharine, overly simplistic character portrayed in those weird fanfics! Seriously!
I absolutely love Darkness Within!!! The Dark Prince trilogy is so well-written. The first book is incredibly dramatic, from identity to father and son, capture, battle, family, school, escape, attack, truth, rift, Horcruxes, infiltration... To arrest, trial, acquittal, threats... Until the final battle.
I never expected the author to actually read *Life in the Wizarding World* :) Such a serious attitude towards reading is truly admirable. Out of curiosity, I went to the comments section of *Life in the Wizarding World*, and indeed, everyone had their own opinions, especially the comment, "Writing trash is helping Japan destroy its own motherland," which made me laugh so hard I almost cried.
After all that, I still only like a few authors on JJ (a Chinese online literature platform), and this author's values are remarkably sound. I've been poisoned by JJ's Slytherin fanfiction for too long; the slightly subtle treatment of Ron and Harry in *The Spiral* was unacceptable and I couldn't continue reading.