
老调重弹,也说李寻欢和林诗音
- Status
- Completed
- Length
- 13k Words
- Genre
- –
- Released
- Jun 2014
- Updated
- 12y ago
- English
- Request English
Stats
1 Chapters
24 Favorites
Readers who added it to their shelf on JJWXC4.3k Avg clicks
Clicks per chapter: average reads of a chapter7.0 Score
JJWXC readers' rating22 Comments
Reader comments on JJWXCSynopsis
Where to read
The Flying Dagger of Little Li: Fei Huan, Like a Dream of Swords
The Legend of the Flying Daggers Reading Notes: Did Lin Shiyin Really Love Li Xunhuan That Much?
Guan Li - Flying Dagger, Seeking Love - Memory Fanfic Extra: Night
The Loneliness of Heroes: A Xiao Li Flying Dagger and The Heaven Sword and Dragon Saber Fan Fiction
A Closer Look at the Heart-Stopping Moments in The Sentimental Swordsman and the Ruthless Sword, and at A Fei and Li Xunhuan
The Flying Dagger of Li: A Dream of Flying Joy
Reader comments 20
Machine translated: Title and synopsis by GPT-6 Luna, Comments by Google Translate.
I'm a bit angry at the author's double standards. I didn't finish reading it, so I don't know if there's any criticism of Li Xunhuan later on. I just want to say that the author's analysis of Lin Shiyin is very accurate; she's definitely not a suitable soulmate. The author's analysis of her personality and other aspects is very accurate. But is Li Xunhuan a suitable soulmate?
Honestly, even after reading the original book, I still don't understand whether Li Xunhuan truly loved Lin Shiyin. If he did, for the sake of Long Xiaoyun, as her partner, he completely concealed his feelings from Lin Shiyin, forcing her to leave. If he didn't, later on, there are stories about him becoming a statue and coughing. I think he didn't actually love her.
The happiness of Li Xunhuan, Lin Shiyin, and Long Xiaoyun is inextricably linked. The best decision is to ensure the happiness of two, the next best is to ensure the happiness of one. However, Li Xunhuan made the worst decision, leaving all three unhappy. Li Xunhuan is indeed a man of considerable talent. His first mistake was giving Lin Shiyin to Long Xiaoyun.
I really don't understand why anyone would say that Li Xunhuan gave Lin Shiyin away as a gift at this point? Did he arrange the marriage? Did he force Lin Shiyin into it? Was Lin Shiyin bound by feudal ethics? Is this a concept in Gu Long's works? Are Li Long and Lin the only two men in the world? Is their existence the only meaning for Lin?
I wonder if the author noticed a line Sun Xiaohong said—Sun Xiaohong sighed, "I never understood why some people always listen to others and let others change their fate. Now I understand, you listen to others not because you're afraid of them, but because you love them, and you know that whatever they do is for your own good."
I don't understand why some readers immediately categorize Lin Shiyin as a "lady of high society," saying that such ladies can't be involved in the martial arts world! Aren't Lin Shiyin and Li Xunhuan childhood sweethearts? Couldn't Lin Shiyin see Li Xunhuan practicing martial arts?
If Lin Shiyin had entered a nunnery or remained unmarried after Li Xunhuan left, she could blame Li Xunhuan for not giving her happiness, since he had betrayed their love and Lin Shiyin had chosen Long Xiaoyun. The love between Li and Lin was over. It would be too selfish for her to be unhappy and then blame the relatives who had given away their entire fortune as dowry.
Li Xunhuan lived in ancient times, specifically the Ming Dynasty in the TV series. The Ming Dynasty was famous for Zhu Xi's Neo-Confucianism, which, simply put, emphasized principles of justice and suppressing human desires. The Three Cardinal Guides and Five Constant Virtues upheld the ruling class.
Lin Shiyin's situation was indeed better than Daiyu's, but this was because society was more tolerant of women due to the influence of the martial arts world, rather than because she actually had more care for Lin Daiyu! First of all, it is undeniable that she was indeed seriously hurt by Li Xunhuan.
In the context of the story as a whole, it's not entirely Li Xunhuan's fault. This doesn't mean he was without fault. The author criticizes those who vilify Li Xunhuan, but isn't the author also vilifying Lin Shiyin? There's not a single word explaining Li Xunhuan's mistakes. He vilifies you, so who's right and who's wrong? Li Xunhuan could be a friend, but not a husband; Lin Shiyin could be a wife, but not a confidante.