
Stats
12 Chapters
104 Favorites
Readers who added it to their shelf on JJWXC1.8k Avg clicks
Clicks per chapter: average reads of a chapter8.0 Score
JJWXC readers' rating38 Comments
Reader comments on JJWXCSynopsis
Where to read
The Children of Wei Garden (Revised Female Assassin Edition)
In My Thirties (2022 Essays)
Flowers at Noon, Gathered at Noon (2021 Essays)
The Children of the Wei Family: A Journey (Part Two)
Miss Yan (The Tale of Xiulan)
The Ups and Downs of a Public Company
The Inch-High Grass Temple (2020 Essays)
Green Papaya
The Black Humor I've Seen
Born at Dawn, Dead by Dusk, Gone in a Flash
First Love, the Cuckoo
Vale (Essays, 2017)
Reader comments 28
Machine translated: Title and synopsis by GPT-6 Luna, Comments by Google Translate.
From a personal perspective, I don't like Baochai. Putting everything else aside, I just think she's insincere and not genuine enough. She's incredibly clever, treats everyone well, avoids giving anyone cause for gossip, and never makes a single mistake. She always speaks only three-tenths of what she means, leaving seven-tenths unsaid.
Baochai's marriage under someone else's name is a continuation of another story. I think it's impossible. Her fate also hints that she will be alone for life, so it's possible that after Daiyu's death, Baoyu had no choice but to marry her, but ultimately left, leaving Baochai behind. The Jia family's downfall was complete, but a newborn represents hope and prosperity. I think Cao Xueqin is unlikely to arrange a hope for revival for the Jia family.
The phrase "the more vulnerable one is," reminds me of Qingwen, whose image is a reflection of Daiyu. Sigh.
Teacher, after reading your article, I feel there are Western religious elements within it. What kind of books do you usually read? (A question from 11 years later [glasses])
I've picked up and put down *Dream of the Red Chamber* repeatedly, often forgetting the relationships between the characters, but every time I see it, I feel afraid, just like before. After reading your essays, I have another reason to browse through them.
I've seen people who lived like Qingwen. I loved him, I hated him. Then he left, and I missed him, yet dared not think of him. Now, when I mention him, I can't even remember his name.
Daiyu wasn't always frail and sickly. She actually fell ill about the same number of times as others, but every time Lady Wang saw her, she would inevitably mention her illness—a thought that sends chills down my spine.
Actually, I have a question... The grass is growing by the river, so there's no shortage of water. Isn't Shenying Attendant just bored out of his mind?
Actually, I feel you're being a bit extreme. Xue Baochai is one of the few female characters in literature that I admire. Yes, Lin Daiyu and Qingwen are indeed rebels as affirmed by the author, so I won't comment on them. However, I completely disagree with the "cold-hearted" label. While chasing butterflies might have disturbed someone's privacy, framing Lin Daiyu seems a bit far-fetched.
My favorite woman in *Dream of the Red Chamber* is You Sanjie, followed by Qingwen. I admire her so much for her fiery spirit, it's a pity so few people comment on You Sanjie.