My Classmates and I Were Transported to a Cultivation World, but I Was Sent to One Extra Immortal Realm

It's very interesting. Don't doubt the author. As a book fan for fifteen years, I think your content is more novel than most people nowadays, and your writing is also very fluent. Come on, don't be discouraged, just follow your heart.

The writing is quite good; I've been following it on and off until the latest chapter. The character development and plot tension before Core Formation are excellent. However, after Core Formation, it feels a bit too much like a solo story, with many events simply described in a straightforward manner (like a diary entry). Sudden events lack foreshadowing, making them feel somewhat abrupt.

It's a very good book. I finished it in two days and am looking forward to the follow-up. The front part is a bit baffling and I wanted to run away. The more I see the back part, the better I feel. The group portraits are average, but I am quite surprised to see some group portraits in Tomato.

For me, it's a very good read. It has both a traditional cultivation story background and new content. In all my years of reading novels, I would give it a high rating. I hope it doesn't end too soon, so that Song, Qi, and Deng can have a proper showdown. I finished reading it, and the ending was too rushed. I can understand the author's desire to start a new book, but why give it a dream ending?

I was so engrossed in reading it that I didn't want to stop! 🤔🤔 I didn't want to read this book at first because of the title, but then I was looking for something to read and read a few chapters. I almost gave up at the beginning because of the predictable plot, but I liked it more and more as I read on. The 10-year promise is the best part of the book and it is also the main storyline.

I read it in one go, and it was actually quite good. The characters were well-defined, the villains were intelligent, the protagonist was steady, and finally, it wasn't that kind of mindless cultivation where you reach Qi Refining in three days, Foundation Establishment in three years, and Golden Core in five years. Cultivation should be like this—slowly increasing your lifespan. Otherwise, what's the point of increasing your lifespan like that?

It's well-written and realistic, with a deep understanding of human nature. It's not the mindless, feel-good kind of novel, nor is it the mindless, dark kind of novel. The portrayal of human nature is very realistic. As for why your score is so low, what do you think? Good people don't live long; that's an international norm.

This is incredibly well-written. It's one of the best cultivation novels I've ever read on Tomato. The world-building, plot, political intrigue, and character portrayals are all incredibly vivid and memorable!

I've been following Yue Liang's books since his first one, *The Divine Doctor*. There's no system involved; everything is conceived by Yue Liang from the ground up, gradually developed step by step with the help of various destinies. The plot is incredibly engaging, full of foreshadowing and twists, yet perfectly logical. It's not some mindless system that just hands you some magical artifact.

This kind of ensemble piece, with its human touch and good pacing, is really good. It's definitely much better than those cultivation novels that are all about gangsters; if cultivators had no emotions and were all selfish, the cultivation world would have been in chaos long ago.