A Family's Daily Life in Exile in Ancient Times

My impressions of this book can be divided into three parts. The first third focuses on the female protagonist's parents, and the most touching part of the entire book is the early exile and their struggle for survival under the harsh conditions of slavery.

Highly recommended! It's a great read. The descriptions of the clothing, language, and food of the ethnic minorities in Southwest China are excellent and very distinctive. Whenever the protagonist encounters difficulties, those who have already benefited from the system coldly watch, fuel the flames, or even are the very creators of suffering.

It's really well-written, with a great writing style and a captivating story. The tragic beginning of an ordinary person feels so real. I don't understand why the rating is so low. The writing is far better than those terrible wish-fulfillment novels, fantasy novels, and time-travel novels that score 9 or higher. Only good writing and a good story can keep me reading.

Excellent. The author has a thorough understanding of the customs of Southwest China. The characters are well-developed. There are no stereotypical good or bad guys; they possess a vitality like wheat straw. The children's emotional storylines are handled beautifully.

It's a picture book about the lives of people at the bottom of society. Stripping away the highbrow and glamorous, it depicts the struggles of those who rise from the mud. The protagonists are kind, resilient, and responsible. It's a very good read; you won't regret it.

8.4 Is definitely too low. It's a great read. If you can get through the first 15 chapters of the first volume, there's basically no more angst after that. It's really good. There are no melodramatic plot twists, just a story of mutual help and support as they move towards a better future. The first 15 chapters were horrific. Although the villains all died, I almost gave up on the story.

This is the first time I've seen a book where every character is so vivid and three-dimensional. These ordinary people carve out a brilliant life from the mire, relying on the unity and support of their family and friends. Everyone strives to live and learn amidst adversity, which is how they achieve their current good life. This could be made into a TV series, it's really great!

This is an exceptionally good article. The author portrays the characters vividly and delicately. A family of three falls into hardship and becomes government slaves, enduring the arduous journey to their exile destination. From being illegitimate sons of a wealthy family to slaves in the household of a local prefect, the author depicts their psychological anguish with remarkable subtlety.

The author's writing is exceptionally delicate and warm, the narrative natural and not stiff or straightforward, every word polished to a high degree of quality. They excel at detailed character portrayal, depicting characters' expressions, emotional fluctuations, and everyday moments with remarkable depth and realism, creating vivid and lifelike figures without any dryness or emptiness in the…

Overall, it's clear the author put a lot of effort into writing this. However, from my personal reading experience, the abundance of metaphors, scene descriptions, and psychological portrayals makes the pacing feel rather slow. I think the author intended to create atmosphere throughout, but the excessive use of redundant vocabulary wears down the reader's patience, especially since the content…