
You Were Asked to Write a Love Song, So Why Did You Write Puella Magi Madoka Magica?
让你表达爱,你写魔法少女小圆?
- Status
- Ongoing
- Length
- 280k Words
- Genre
- Anime Fanfiction
- Released
- Dec 2024
- Updated
- 1y ago
- English
- RandomTL · Request
Synopsis
Stats
More by this author
In booklists 12
Are There Any Puella Magi Madoka Magica Novels?
Looking for Stories Where the Protagonist Gets Famous Singing Songs from Their Past Life
Entertainment-industry stories these days always start with the protagonist being betrayed by his ex-girlfriend. I just want a story about someone becoming famous for singing, without all those ridiculous plotlines. Please recommend something, fellow readers. I’m begging you!
The Protagonist Transforms Into a Magical Girl Madoka
I'm looking for books similar to The Reincarnated Kamen Rider: Madoka Kaname. The protagonist transforms into Madoka, the Law of Cycles. Her first disguised identity is Yuno Gasai, and the director of the Supernatural Administration is Hongjun. Which novel is that?
Any Stories Where a Man Transforms into a Magical Girl, or Other Male-to-female Transformation Novels?
Looking for books like "I'm a Witch, Not Your Magical Girl Teacher". Preferably no System and lots of fighting, but a modern slice-of-life story with cute interactions would be fine too. I'm really out of things to read 😭
Puella Magi Madoka Magica Watch-Party Fics or Fanfiction Written by the Characters
Any Fanfiction Based on Puella Magi Madoka Magica?
Protagonists Who Make Comics or Animated Films
Any Novels About Making Anime?
I'm running out of books, fellow cultivators. Please share some recommendations, preferably about making anime. I'd like ones that update quickly.
Magic Novels
Looking for books similar to The Growth of Little Ye the Mage. A magic novel to satisfy your craving for magic.
Any Genshin Impact and Yu-Gi-Oh! Crossover Stories?
The Protagonist Must Be Female, No Anime. Don't Recommend Anything Without Ultraman and Genshin Impact
Books That Make You Fall in Love With Reading
In same booklists
Magical Girls Need to Start a Band Too
Puella Magi Madoka Magica: The Unfinished Journey
Puella Magi Madoka Magica: The Substitute Who Can Change Fate
You Asked Me to Write About Love, So Why Did I Write Madoka Magica?
I'm Just a Couch Potato! You Want Me to Make an Animation? Does That Make Sense?
You Were Supposed to Write About High School, So Why Did You Write Jujutsu Kaisen?
Making Anime in Another World: The Whole Internet Begs Me for a Sequel
Puella Magi Madoka Magica: Across Time and Space
Puella Magi Madoka Magica Side Story: A Beef-Free Journey
Turning Anime into Live-Action: From the Start, I Produce Heaven's Feel
Record of the Mirror of Sighs
Magical Girl Soulfire
Reborn as the Father of Anime: I Start by Creating Pokemon
Making Cartoons in the 1980s
Magical Girl, Bearing the Burden of Evil
Puella Magi Madoka Magica: A Journey of Fate
Puella Magi Madoka Magica: I Have a Stand Called The World
I'm Just an Art Student, So How Did I Become the God of Anime?
A Journey Through the Heavens, Starting as Kyubey from Madoka Magica
Making Anime: Starting with A Record of a Mortal’s Journey to Immortality!
Reader comments 50
Google Translate


























































This story is a bit toxic, so toxic that I feel "My Life, I'll Give You" isn't even that bad 🤦. It's not particularly long, but it's incredibly boring and drawn-out. Most of it is just a verbatim retelling of the Madoka Magica plot, but what readers usually crave in this kind of story is the audience's reaction—that's the satisfying part.
Good news: There's Madoka Magica. Bad news: It's not in Madoka Magica.
It's very well written; I've almost never seen anyone write about Madoka Magica. But why are there always duplicate contents?
The plot is good, but so far the judges' comments are too one-dimensional. The more I look, the more boring it gets; I'm leaving.
The writing is decent, but the referee's comments were too formal, almost to the point of sounding like a human playing against a machine.
Nice is a very good read. The characters are vivid and lifelike. The opening introduces the characters' backgrounds, setting the stage for the time-travel element later in the story. The vivid and engaging descriptions of the Madoka Magica plot make the story even more captivating. (Wow, I'm such a genius! 😏😏)
It's a rare find to read a good Puella Magi Madoka Magica novel. The only downside is that the descriptions of the judges could be a little lacking, although the plot itself is quite detailed. 😄
Shuang Ge is actually the epitome of a magical girl in the Madoka Magica universe. Originally, she was an ordinary, optimistic, and brave teenage girl. Kyubey's attitude towards her was simply to be happy and go with the flow, but in the end, she met such an end.
Quack... It's alright, just don't try to promote your own agenda.
Go for it! I'll support Yuanyan forever! 😘 The judges' comments were a bit too... Well, formulaic. Sometimes it would be better to incorporate a little of your own feelings. [Smirk]