A Year Without Song

The life experience of the heroine is so pitiful. Most girls in that era were unable to escape the shackles of fate. The author's writing is good, and I am looking forward to the development of the story. I hope the heroine will have a happy ending. One additional comment: the author's writing style should be rated 9 or above.

This article is very well written for me personally, but I can also understand why this book does not have high ratings and not many people read it. It is because it is too realistic and the heroine is too bitter, which does not conform to the mainstream of current novels. I still remember that a few years ago, abuse articles were prevalent in magazines like Miss Huahuolu. And it's the kind of bloody story that mindlessly abuses the heroine. Car accidents, amnesia, miscarriage, rape, inability to live without love... Such writing was mainstream at that time. More than ten years have passed, and with the current rise of feminism, it seems that everyone is more willing to see some happy stories about women killing everyone, being reborn as scum, and having a smooth journey. The past sadistic stories are gone. But this article is different from traditional abuse articles. It writes about the sufferings of feudal society and about women struggling in feudal society, persevering and carving out a life of their own. The first half of the article is very depressing and sadistic, but it is not because the author does not love the heroine in her novel and forcibly inflicts pain on the heroine, but because in the overall environment of feudal society, women are helpless and helpless as accessories, and all suffering is natural. Fortunately, the heroine has never given up her pursuit and yearning for life. Even if she encounters various blows, she only wants to live the rest of her life wonderfully and leave no regrets. I like this type of novel very much. I have read several of the author's novels, and I can see that the core of his novels is the same. Whether it is Teng Luo, Mu Yun or Sui Wan, they have all become the heroines of their lives. It is rare to encounter such an appetizing article on Tomato (whether it is writing style, character design, or the construction of a large framework). I also hope that the author can keep writing so that we can appreciate more excellent works.

Write a good introduction and get points. The writing is good, no nonsense, no random chapters, characterization and logic are very good, pure ancient language, considered sadomasochism, not blatant sadism, but chilling to the bone.

The 5 stars are for the writing style. I didn't expect that such a scumbag male protagonist could end up with him. I originally thought that this scumbag got all the glory, wealth and rights in the end, but he didn't get the cliché ending of the heroine, who is the only beauty. I didn't expect the ending to make people vomit blood. The scumbag got glory, wealth, power, power, his broken leg was cured, he slept with the most beautiful woman in the world, and the heroine also gave birth to a son for him. The author is really Shen's biological mother... [Petrochemical] Han Chan is also vicious and incomprehensible. The reason why she is so stupid that she seeks death is because she is extremely narcissistic and loves to sleep with different men. She kowtows to this man and kneels and licks that man. Then she has a bad ending. She has a strong description of misogyny [face covering]. The ending is quite miserable. Her family is ruined and she has no lifeblood. The heroine has written a lot of sober heroines' speeches, but in the end she gave the scumbag boy a son...

Alas, if it is really like the story told by Wei Gonggong, him and the heroine being together should be the heroine's salvation. Unfortunately, the story is just a story after all. The complete "Wei Qingxu" will not appear in Wu County, let alone fall in love with the heroine at first sight. On the contrary, I hope that the heroine will not choose two men. , Because both men have caused substantial harm to him, even if Wei Qingxu did it while unconscious, the harm is harm, and it will not change this fact because of anything. I support the heroine to be beautiful alone. It is not like she can't survive except for men in this world.

[Crying][Crying][Crying] I felt so sorry for the heroine. I cried while watching it in the middle of the night, for fear of disturbing my roommates. Please, no male lead, the two men now are not worthy of her, she healed her injuries bit by bit, and the only one she can rely on most is herself, no one else. The kind-hearted heroine [crying][crying][crying][crying]

The writing is very good. I have some suggestions for the author. If you start writing from the middle, don't write dozens of chapters about the past. This will make it boring to read. Interspersed writing will make it more interesting. My personal suggestion is that if I am wrong, please call me. Thank you.

I cried when I watched it [almost cried] but I really want to know who the male protagonist is

Several of the author's articles are very well written. Although he cried a lot when he was not dead, I feel that he was lucky because he did not die in the craziest and most helpless years. Being able to live a few more years with hope is already a blessing, and he is already a disabled body. Accompanying the heroine throughout his life is not a good match. Platonic love is difficult to be based on reality. People's hearts are changeable, and pure love from the heart is easy to disappear. If he had not died, the article would not be able to continue. At the same time, the lives of thousands of people may be unsatisfactory in one way or another, so in the end it is a perfect ending with the flawed Shen. Shen couldn't say how bad it was. People are like this sometimes. In the journey of life, they may have taken the wrong path and lost themselves, but in the end they found their way back. The heroines described by the author have all experienced low points in life, but they go against the wind, are strong, brave and fearless, and finally live out their lives. The author's writings have great stamina. Every time you finish reading one, it takes several days to digest the emotions. It makes you want to cry and laugh, sad and happy at the same time.

Every novel written by the author is very sad. The female protagonist is honest and virtuous, and takes care of the family well, but the male protagonist is careless. His only success is to find a woman, but he regrets it when he finds that his original wife is good. Why does the heroine have such a bad fate? She grew up in adversity in her childhood, and was punished by her family as a teenager. She finally had some expectations for life, but let her scumbag husband break all her wishes. Every time the heroine is frustrated, she will understand the true meaning of life. It feels like the author's own Zen understanding of life. Every time I read the author's novels, I will gain a lot of truth from it and feel that my realm is a little higher. I just ask the author to give the heroine a good ending! It is recommended that the author should not serialize it again in the future. Serialization will easily lose a large number of readers. It is best to do it in one go. I will always follow and pay attention to the author's works.