
Silently, I Thought It Was a Song
默以为歌
- Status
- Completed
- Length
- 100k Words
- Genre
- Two Male Leads
- Released
- May 2023
- Updated
- 3y ago
- English
- RandomTL · Request
Synopsis
Stats
More by this author
In booklists 31
See allTomato's Four Great Tearjerkers 🍅
Nothing But Angst!!! Knives Flying Everywhere!!!
No sweetness. Don't leave me any way out! Please!
Desperately Seeking Heart-Wrenching Male-Male Angst!!!
Looking for books like "Quick Transmigration: After I Faked My Death by Dying of an Incurable Disease, the Obsessive Big Shot Went Crazy". Note: I want angst, not rage-inducing drama. I don't want a story that leaves me feeling frustrated!!
Short Angsty Stories! A Dozen Chapters or So! The Kind That Makes You Cry Nonstop!
Short, heartbreaking stories, around a dozen chapters!!! Make it hurt, hurt, hurt!!! The kind that leaves you sobbing and gasping for breath!!! Crying T﹏T!!!
Looking for a Sickly, Beautiful, Tragic Strongman Who Is Seriously Ill but Pretends He's Fine and Never Says a Word. I'm Trash
I’m a Simple Reader: Give Me Groveling Exes, Fake Deaths, and Two Male Leads!
Angsty Stories: Short and Heartbreaking, Enough to Make Your Eyes Swell from Crying!
Something short, not an overly long tragic story.
BL + Extreme Angst
Looking for books similar to After Being Abandoned, the Spoiled Little Brat Gives Up on Life. The author has five books, and I've read all five: the first, second, third, fourth, and fifth. Are there any others like them? I'm just asking if there are any besides the one I mentioned here...
Any Fresh, Original Stories About Two Male Leads? Really New, I Mean Really New!
Two Male Leads, Either a Reconciliation After a Breakup or Rebirth, with One of Them Suffering from Depression or Something Similar
Please Recommend BL Novels With Lots of Reviews
Let's see what everyone thinks of these books. I'll decide for myself whether they're any good!
Discovering You're a Replacement, Then Leaving in Despair
Looking for Recommendations: Two Male Leads
Looking for books like "Vodka and Americano". Any more down-to-earth stories that aren’t so over-the-top, with two male leads?
I’ve Read So Many Tearjerkers I Could Go Crazy, but I’m Already Crazy
Anything with plenty of angst and heartbreak 🔪 Hehe 😀
Looking for Great BL with Two Equally Powerful Secret Guards and Political Intrigue, No Letting Emotions Get in the Way. Please!
Looking for books like After the General Entered the Capital. Two male leads, both powerful, with secret guards and political scheming. Please, whatever you do, don't have one give up the throne for love. I really can't stand that. Please, please, please, please, please, please, please, please, please, please, please!
Two Male Leads, Bad Ending, Please Make It Hurt *^O^*
There are too many couples around me in real life :), so I'm here to get my heart broken ⊙▽⊙
Heartbreaking Quick Transmigration Stories
I Haven’t Found a Book That Can Hold My Attention Lately, You Know What I Mean! Female Leads, Please
BE, Male-Male Pairing, Preferably the Kind That Makes You Cry. I Really Want to Read One
BE
Any Really Short, Sweet Stories with Two Male Leads?
Looking for books similar to "After Marrying the Green Tea". I want something short, around thirty or forty chapters, and sweet.
It's Great, I Love It, Go Read It
Looking for books similar to The Fool's Game of the Gods.
Any Sweet Stories, Guys? I've Suffered Enough This Year. No Romance!
I Want to Lose Weight Lately. I Heard Angst Novels Can Make You Slim Down Fast
Could all you lovely ladies and handsome guys recommend something for me? The more heartbreaking, the better, especially the kind that makes you cry until you have no tears left. I want something really, really angsty, so I can finally reach my goal of losing a ton of weight. Thank you, fairies and lovely ladies.
Great Books Vetted by the Most Veteran of Readers
I'm looking for a book like "Xuan You Lu". You can tell it's a good book just from the title. The plot is witty and entertaining, the logic holds up, and it has neither brainless characters, a harem, nor a saintly heroine. The transitions between exciting action and everyday life are seamless, and the writing is nuanced and polished. It's absolutely worth following.
In same booklists
The Traitor's Game
The CEO Is Reborn and Embarks on a Grueling Quest to Win His Wife Back
Black and White
Spring Runs Deep in the Bronze Sparrow Palace
One Step Closer
I Came Back After the Substitute Took My Place
A Decade's Difference
I Imprisoned Him in My Heart and Broke His Wings, but This Mad Tycoon Is Too Possessive
Poor Me, They Took Revenge on the Wrong Person
His Past Devotion Was More Pathetic Than Grass
Reborn, I Married the Scumbag’s Second Uncle
The Day After Same-Sex Marriage Was Legalized, We Broke Up
President Yao Doesn't Want a Divorce
After My Heart Turned to Ash, Mr. Gu Knelt and Begged Me to Treat Him
Forced to Become His Substitute Husband
Love Scam? This Dramatic Omega Is Done Pretending
Marriage Without Love
Cold Lapel
That Year, It Was You
At Last, I Don't Love You Anymore
Reader comments 53
Google Translate





























































































I finished reading it with tears in my eyes. Seeing Ning Ge get beaten and misunderstood was so heartbreaking 😢. It was so cruel. It's good to see two different endings. Cherish the people in front of you. I hope the author continues to work hard and keep going!
I actually cried while reading this book because Ning Ge said something like, "Yuan Moyan, I beg you, please let me go." "It was my mistake to take the place of Ning Luozhou's marriage, but now that you're together, my sins are atoned, right? Look, I'm blind, my life is ruined, I've given away my kidney, I'm about to die, and you still won't let me go?" That line made me cry.
I've read this book countless times, and it truly resonates with me. The scene where Ning Ge proposes a divorce is incredibly moving; it sends a pang of heartache through me, and I feel so sorry for him. Their relationship was fraught with difficulties, but the ending is perfect, just like the saying goes, "You can look back, but you can't go back."
Super good! 😢😢😢😢 The author's writing is so good! 😢 It was so heartbreaking, even I, someone who cries easily, cried! 😢😢 If Ning Ge and Yuan Moyan hadn't had so many misunderstandings, it wouldn't have been so tragic. But the extra chapters fulfilled my wish! 😢😢😢 Super good!
I really love this book. It's the kind of book that's angsty at first but then blossoms into love, and the ending isn't a sad one, which I especially appreciate. They end up having a child, so I feel this book is exceptionally well-written and highly recommended. 😫😫😫😫
It's quite abusive, but I'm also speechless about the protagonist. If you're going to investigate, why not do it thoroughly? Just because of a perfunctory investigation, you can turn a blind eye to all sorts of unreasonable things later on. The happy ending felt forced; the protagonist's body was truly like a cockroach, as some comments described.
I think it's pretty good. Although I like angst-filled stories, I prefer stories that are sweet at first and then angst-filled, or angst-filled at first and then sweet. Anyway, everyone has their own opinions, and no one can agree with everyone else.
I think the ending was pretty good, and I liked it too. But I still really hoped Ning Ge and Gu Fangzhuo would have a little more of a story. Their story was a bit short; although he only appeared twice, I still really liked him. 😀
I only watched a little bit, but my heart aches for Shou Shou. He works long hours, leaving early and returning late, and can even fall asleep standing up on the bus. It really breaks my heart 🥺🥺🥺 I hope he finds happiness 🥺🥺🥺
It's so good! So good! So good! I'm a country bumpkin, but I love watching it!