
I Gave You My Heart, and You Left Me with Empty Joy
掏心于你,赠我一场空欢喜
- Status
- Completed
- Length
- 49k Words
- Genre
- Two Male Leads
- Released
- Oct 2021
- Updated
- 4y ago
- English
- RandomTL · Request
Synopsis
Stats
More by this author
In booklists 48
See allHeartbreakingly Angsty Stories That Make Your Heart Hurt
I've read quite a lot of angsty stories before, and I'm usually a bit sentimental. I love listening to sad songs and hearing sad stories, too. I've already read "Bone-Deep Crisis", "He Said Our Love Came Too Late", and "May You Shine as Bright as the Stars"... I'd prefer something with lots of chapters, since I'm a night owl.
I Have a High Crying Threshold, Any Novels That Will Reduce Me to Tears?
Tragic Bad-End Stories That Wreck Me, and Are Super Short
Short, Brutal, Heartbreaking: The Kind That Keeps You Crying the Whole Time!
Who Are the Four Heavyweights of Tearjerker Fiction?
Who is there besides Bo Ye?
Absolutely Heartbreaking!!!! Short! Short! Short!! Please Recommend Me Something!!!!
Angst, Short, Brutal, Painful
The kind that makes you sob so hard you can't catch your breath, perfect for reading in the middle of the night.
Angst!!! Angst!!! Short!!! Heartbreaking!!! Get It????
Angst!!! Angst!!! Short!!! Angst!!! Got it????
Looking for That Kind of Betrayal Angst, Male-Male
Looking for books like Host, Give Me a Little Wink and the Villainous Big Shot Surrenders. The kind where the protagonist hasn't figured out their feelings in the early stages.
The Male Lead's Eyes Are Hollow After Being Hurt, Like a Puppet's
Angst So Painful It Makes Your Liver Ache
Something really heartbreaking.
It Feels Great to Hurt Your Husband for a While, Until You Have to Win Him Back
Making your husband suffer is fun for a while, then you chase after him and beg for forgiveness.
Tragedies, the More Heartbreaking the Better. I've Finished Seven Already, Give Me More Pain
Two Male Leads! Heartbreaking! Bad Ending! Super Short!!
Looking for books similar to "The Flowers Have Bloomed".
Two Male Leads, Angsty Story, Bad Ending. Please Recommend Some
I’ve Had Nothing to Read for Ages. I Need a Good Book.
Any book recommendations, folks? Give me something good!
A Rational Madman Is the Most Terrifying of All
Any stories with a highly intelligent, crazy male lead, a scheming personality, and no female lead?
Short Tragic Stories Worth Reading, Highly Recommend the First One
Short, angsty stories.
Looking for a Tragic BE That’ll Make Me Sob, Lose Weight for Days, and Leave Me Reeling Long After I Finish
Angsty stories with a lasting emotional impact.
Short Stories With Dual Male Leads
Short stories with two male leads.
Tragic Endings! Break My Heart! Angst! I've Finished 'No Fate for Us'; Give Me More Pain!
Quick Transmigration BL: A Tragic Romance, With Angst From Start to Finish
BL: I Want a Substitute-Lover Story
The stand-in is the protagonist, and everyone loves them. The White Moonlight returns home and falls for the stand-in 😍😍😍
Two Guys, a Bad Ending (^3^), Please!
In same booklists
Big Brother, Will I Be Able to See You When I’m Dead?
Forced to Become His Substitute Husband
Loving You Is My Fated Ordeal
I Hate You
A Love's Grief, No Regrets
The Little Crybaby Pouted: Uncle Fu, Are You Going to Be with Me?
After I Faked My Death, the Whole World Started Loving Me
After the Divorce, My Ex-Husband Wept and Begged Me to Remarry Him
After Being Diagnosed with a Terminal Illness, I Discovered My Substitute Was His One True Love
Each Gets What They Want
Soul Shackles [BE]
President Yao Doesn't Want a Divorce
The CEO Pursues Her Husband: Fierce, Flirtatious, and Clingy
Loving You Like the First Day
Beibei's Diary
That Year, It Was You
No Spring Affairs
Your Love Is Just a Joke
I'll Chase My Own Wife
Pathological Obsession
Reader comments 20
Google Translate








































































































There's not much to say. It's not a regret; as Huo Zhanting said at their wedding, it was a case of mutual consent, nothing more to say. To me, it's just physical abuse followed by forced emotional torment. The story is also very short; read it before bed.
The story begins with Huo Zhanting threatening Shi Yi with the person he cares about most, forcing him to return to the Huo family. Huo Zhanting says, "You have to protect Qiao Ran's health," implying Shi Yi is someone who can't be seen in public. Then Huo Zhanting says, "Let's get married; all we need is a wife who'll agree." The story ends with Shi Yi saying, "I'm a selfish person too.
Speechless. The protagonist is totally love-struck. Even after having her heart ripped out and her younger brother dying, she forgives the male lead so easily. Speechless.
I still can't stand love-struck characters. Even if Shi Yu wasn't killed by Huo Zhanting, he did deceive Zero's feelings, suppress Zero's family and company, trample on Zero's self-esteem, and even ripped out Zero's heart—weren't those all his doing? And in the end, Zero still had the nerve not to hurt him. I don't like this ending.
I'm so angry! My sister and I have a grudge against each other! What the hell?! Everyone except the second male lead is sick! And there's this scumbag seme and this slutty uke, a perfect match! Both of them are legally illiterate and have questionable intelligence. Xiaoyu is so unlucky to have this brother. No wonder Father Shi is biased. I want to kill this slutty uke! Half an hour of reading, half a month of anger! So unlucky, damn it!
The protagonist (shou) is constantly abused and beaten by the other protagonist (gong), and later even has his heart transplanted to the gong's "white moonlight" (a term for someone who is unattainable in love). The gong inflicts long-term trauma on the shou, yet the shou still chooses the gong in the end. Is this a normal human thought process? (Is this even possible?)
However, I still believe that Shi Yi shouldn't be forgiven, and Huo Zhanting doesn't deserve forgiveness. Because of him, Shi Yi lost everything in three and a half years—his family, his health, the abuse he suffered during those three years—and Shi Yu died too. What did he do wrong? Such a living, breathing person died at Qiao Ran's hands.
9 (because 6 was flipped)
I'm speechless 😒 Even if Shi Yi's brother wasn't killed by Huo or something, he's definitely involved with that thing, okay? I feel like he forgave it just because that thing wasn't tortured enough? Seriously, I was a little upset at the beginning, but then Shi Yi said he'd get his revenge, and then what did he do? In the end, he was still with him? Thank goodness he died, that thing… damn it. Thank goodness it's a bad ending, otherwise I'd be so angry I couldn't sleep 🙂🙂🙂
It was so heartbreaking to watch! First it was agonizing, then there was all the repentance, and just when things were finally starting to get a little sweet, Shi Yi died from a rejection reaction. But it was so good! Qaq