The Secret Song

The author's research on the official system and customs of the Northern Song Dynasty is meticulous, making the reader feel as if they are there. The writing is concise and thought-provoking. A great book!

OMG I thought I was reading a book by Ma Boyong, but when I looked up, I realized it wasn't by the author. This platform actually has such a gem. I've only read a few dozen chapters; I hope it doesn't have a bad ending. I'll give it a 5-star rating first. At least for now, the writing is skillful, the characters are vivid and lifelike, and the historical knowledge is also very solid.

I spent more time reading this novel than usual... I started to feel like giving up as summer approached and I entered the desert, but I persevered and finished it... The ending was a bit rushed... The story is still coherent... There are always some issues... But it's undeniably one of the better historical time-travel novels... Looking forward to your new work... (●'◡'●)

It seems the author simply couldn't write anymore... I can emotionally understand their current physical and mental exhaustion. But looking at the work itself, things are unresolved, plot holes remain unfilled, and at best, it's just a minor, albeit somewhat clumsy, attempt at writing...

I've always said that a writer's style reflects their character. The era of online novels illustrates this even better. Men all have a heroic streak, the so-called "cultivating oneself, managing one's family, governing the state, and bringing peace to the world." It's certain that a man with certain ambitions will write a certain kind of online novel.

The writing is good; the character portrayal might be slightly lacking, but given that everyone has different tastes, it's still commendable; the plot is intricate and captivating; the local dialect and slang are well-suited to the historical context. Deserves 5 stars.

It's clear the author put a lot of effort into writing about the Song Dynasty. The character portrayals and plot are quite reasonable and historically accurate, without any abrupt transitions. The most regrettable part is the ending; it feels like the story was abandoned, or rather, it left readers unsatisfied, with too many loose ends. However, I still have to commend the author's writing style.

I'd give it a perfect score. It's a very good book with delicate writing.

The content is superb, the descriptions are detailed, and the plot is vivid and interesting; it's definitely worth watching!

It would be even more interesting if we took Sima Guang down with us! That would be so satisfying!