In Classroom of the Elite, My Desk Mate Is Haruno
人在实教，同桌阳乃
- Status
- Completed
- Length
- 1.4M Words
- Genre
- Urban Youth
- Updated
- 13d ago
- English
- Request a translation
Synopsis
Stats
All-time: Clicks, Favorites, Recommendations.
In booklists 2
Classroom of the Elite Personal Ratings
To avoid disputes and make it easier for everyone to find books they want to read, please read all the notes for this list first: 1. Updated December 31, 2025. Self-recommendations are welcome. 2. I guarantee that I have finished or followed every included Classroom of the Elite fanfic, and have read at least three-quarters of it. Based on that, I give each book my subjective rating and review. Please don't attack me just because you disagree. 3. Rating criteria: I rate content and characters on
My Personal Review List
I was browsing reading lists for something to read and noticed that, on some lists, the owner's comments were more interesting than the books themselves. That got me thinking, and I decided to go back through all the books I'd read before. (Just the books, no discussion of anything outside them.) Sigh, some of these old titles are really old. I wonder if I can still get through them now (눈_눈) Before you read: These comments are entirely subjective, and everyone's tolerance for flaws is different
Reader comments 3
Google Translate
The female lead of the real-life school The names listed are: Attack Base, Megumi, Kikyo, Arisu, Asahi-senpai, Amasawa Ichika, and Ichinose. Those who stayed together after graduation (for company or other reasons): Kamuro, Kaka, Horikita, Wang Meiyu, Sato Maya, Airi, Haruno, Matsushita, Nanase, Ibuki, Chabashira-sensei (not sure if all of them are included). My favorite library NPC, the lady, has virtually no presence in this book; she's barely described. The female names in Class A are Itagi and Kamuro; no others were mentioned. Ichinose (B-board), others don't seem to be mentioned. The character described most in Class C is Ibuki, while Shiina's description seems to be less than 100 words, and the other names aren't mentioned at all. In terms of plot Horikita disappeared without a trace, and Kikyo didn't relentlessly target Horikita in this book. In fact, when they were grouped in Hokkaido, Kikyo expressed confusion and didn't recognize him (not that they were in the same class or the same student council). Yang Nai is good at everything, but he's not the best at anything. Yamauchi, who was secretly filmed in the swimming pool, was expelled from school. What a terrible thing to do. The rumor about walking in Ichinose is about Ryuen. On the second deserted island, Baoquan died, Longyuan died, Yagami died, Lu was kidnapped and taken back to the White House, and Nagumo dropped out of school.
To be honest, I was disappointed when I saw it was going to be released. At first, everything was fine, but as the release date approached, the amount of Goat Milk's storyline suddenly increased, and many parts felt like actions were just for plot advancement. There were many forced connections between characters, and the character development was severely off-screen. I completely couldn't understand how Goat Milk, Koenji, and the protagonist, who were initially established as all-around fun-loving fighters, handled Class D. Koenji's issues were somewhat acceptable because he had limited screen time, at least his character was well-developed. Goat Milk really felt like a mere shell, and the protagonist's sudden transformation from a fun-loving character to a caretaker, and the automatic intimacy between Goat Milk and Koenji upon her appearance, were all too abrupt.
Well, the plot is a mess. The protagonist comes from Kengan, so shouldn't the fun come from physical strength? Instead, it's all about talking, and even that's not very good. There are a lot of plot holes. Finally, to save some time: Ishii (just one more thing, they really know how to delete comments).