苏俄1920：从护卫斯大林开始

I saw Chapter 25. The subject matter is great and the writing is okay. The description of language and style is not very good. You have to use Soviet thoughts and language to describe, and don't use too much Chinese thinking and tone. It is difficult to substitute and it is very dramatic. I think the author should search a lot of information and read previous novels about the Soviet Union. Learn from it. I hope to write better.

I have read more than fifty chapters so far, and the overall content is very well written. The protagonist's setting is very unique. He is of mixed Chinese descent, but uses a Russian-style name, and the character design has a strong sense of substitution. The plot begins with the protagonist signing up to join the Cheka and receiving rigorous training. He grows up step by step, and then enters the Kremlin and is assigned to serve as Stalin's bodyguard. The plot progresses layer by layer, the rhythm is very well controlled, and there are also famous highlights: on the first mission, he desperately protects the leader and saves Stalin's life. The plot is full of tension. The emotional lines of the characters are naturally unobtrusive. Under the arrangement of Stalin, he gets along with his best friend's daughter, and his daily life is warm and reasonable. The overall writing style is solid, the plot logic is online, and the historical background is restored in place. It is very enjoyable to read. I sincerely recommend it and give it a five-star rating!

Summary: So far I like this novel very much. Let's start with the short part of this article and end with the long part of this article. Short: The beginning of this article is a bit boring and lacks tension. The motivations of many characters are full of excessive idealistic rhetoric and are slightly optimistic about the description of human nature. The Soviet-Finnish Winter War not only describes the grand narrative of the "justifiable reasons" for the Russian-style security pretext to invade other countries, but also describes the conscience condemnation of many people, including the protagonist, and also describes the determination of the Finns to resist. The descriptions of these three points are very good and three-dimensional, but at the same time they are extremely unified to the protagonist and the protagonist's colleagues. It seems far-fetched: in the real world, there are such strong views of good and evil, and people who can sympathize with the suffering of the people of the enemy country and people who can resolutely execute the order of aggression cannot be the same kind of people. Power can change people, and decision-makers who can make cold-blooded decisions are without exception either born with cold-bloodedness or acquired cold-bloodedness. This kind of narrative is intended to create a willed superman who is free from schizophrenia. The sentence "I know it is sinful but I don't regret it" cannot bridge this logical gap at all. In addition, the progress of the novel is quite fast. The two decades from the 1920s to the 1940s have passed by in vain, and the family life has even changed directly from happiness to the betrayal of the wife and son. (It is understood that the author wants to create a reflection of Stalin's family tragedy in order to show the tragic hero's sense of fate that cannot take care of himself, but the lack of foreshadowing is too unconvincing.) Whether it is struggle, farming, or interpersonal communication, it can be more delicate. There is no need to press the fast forward button (after all, it can be done whether it is the author's idea or AI method) Although the author describes how dangerous the struggle is, in the end, everything went too smoothly for the protagonist, whether it was career promotion or surviving the purge. Yezhov and his ilk did not pose any problems to the protagonist at all. The suspicion and stubbornness shown by Stalin were always only expressed in words. Every time a dramatic conflict really occurred, Stalin would always become a real wise man and seriously consider the protagonist's excessive demands... Another thing I want to complain about is that the general reading of this article shows that the Soviet Union's customs before and after World War II have been researched, and many descriptions are very authentic. However, there are still many small loopholes that are really glaring, including not limited to the premature appearance of walkie-talkies, electronic displays and radars, and the Chinese father who eats book bags and turns into a Ukrainian, etc. Combined with the fact that this article was quickly updated, it is difficult not to suspect that it was written using AI. (AI is fine, the writing is quite good, I just ask the author to review it more before publishing) Chang: This article has been very interesting since the middle and late stages. It is really exciting to see the protagonist transform into a minister after 41 years of preparation. There is also the loneliness of the protagonist when his wife dies and his son rebels, and the condemnation of conscience and the devouring of guilt when he inspects Finland all make the protagonist's behavior very three-dimensional: in the grand narrative, he is a loyal soldier for the safety of the Soviet Union, but at the same time he hates himself for infringing on the weak. Although I criticized the unification of the two as unrealistic, I also hope that the story can be that the male protagonist does not realize the great pain he has caused to the Finns at the beginning, and then finds that he is guilty of the crimes he committed against the Finns and his family for the so-called great cause, so that the arc of the character can be more complete and natural. What satisfies me about this article is that the protagonist can keep his conscience in the torrent of history, and has a feeling that "the right path in the world is subject to vicissitudes of life." It fully satisfies our expectations for a true hero: "True heroism is to see the world for what it is and love it." So I still recommend it as a four-star, both refreshing and textured.

Thoughtful, warm, truthful and objective . Chapter 21, Shopping in Moscow, is the name of the Moscow train station Kiev? Moscow is more than 900 kilometers away from Kyiv. Electronic computers appeared in 1946. How come there is an electronic display screen in Chapter 150 of 1938 [laughing and crying] [laughing and crying] [laughing and crying]. Chapter 156, Xie was commanding in Moscow, why did he go to the front line and start working directly? ! 180, I traveled through time in vain, and I didn't bring any experience of the new era with me. Returning to Finland to fight a traditional war, have you forgotten the case of the United States' cross-island battle in World War II, and Israel's case of positional warfare and rear logistics? ! "We want to turn Vyborg into Stalingrad and let the Russians bleed here." Is this an advance of the Stalingrad defense case in the Soviet-German war? ! [Angry] [Laughing] [Laughing and crying] [Laughing and crying] [Laughing and crying] Chapter 367, electronic clocks were only developed when quartz technology was discovered in the 1950s and 1960s. In 1840, electric clocks became less popular.

Very good novel! The author uses a unique perspective and story entry point, and cleverly constructs suspense and tension storylines to quickly draw readers into the situation, making it impossible to put down the book. Looking forward to the follow-up articles as they are still fascinating!

The writing is relatively good. I personally feel that many things should be analyzed and written through my own independent thinking. It has a certain inspiring effect, and this inspiring effect is very down-to-earth and has a foundation that ordinary people can understand.

It's good-looking, and it expresses a different feeling. It's humane and confusing. It's good.

😨The main reason is that I haven't found any meal replacement. The writing is pretty cool. [Thinking] There will be more bugs later, and then I think my son Misha's problem is inexplicable. The rest is fine👌🏻

Germany has not yet attacked the Soviet Union, but the Soviet Union is fighting Finland. The Finnish generals said that if they do not agree to the conditions, they will give in. Helsinki will become the second Stalingrad, and each Soviet soldier will be exchanged for ten corpses. Are you a prophet? Interesting [face covering] The protagonist's wife is suddenly written to death, and the son turns against him. I don't understand it. If it weren't for the Soviet-German war later, the son will also die, and then the protagonist starts to live together in the world?

A very good novel, very Russian and Soviet, but a bit weird, indescribable, and a bit like AI. The plot developed later is a bit fast, but it is understandable. Come on.

The author's writing style is excellent and his language is concise. Many scenes convey the feeling in just a few strokes. What a rare masterpiece. Nowadays, many books are not even accurate, so this book is even more precious. Come on, update the author soon

I feel really sorry for the author. Such a thoughtful, artistic, and insightful book, why did it get a rating of 6.9? To be honest, it should be above 8.9, Entering the realm of 9.0. It seems your ratings are unreliable!

The characters in the book are three-dimensional, with distinctive personalities and wise dialogues. The author's writing style is smooth and the logic is reasonable. Through the eyes of a Stalin guard, he objectively depicts the people in the throes of the era of social change. It is like a mirror, which relatively completely reflects the internal and external troubles and the rigid coercion of society after the success of the Soviet Russian socialist revolution but before the founding of the country. It makes up for most people's lack of this period of history. It is highly ornamental, informative and interesting.

It was as if we personally participated in the construction of the Soviet Union.

Very nice. You can read it slowly. Never be a eunuch.

I finished reading it in one go, excellent product There are flaws, but not many (more stereotyped characters), the rhythm is stable, the plot is neither fast nor slow, and the description is very delicate [Like][Like]

I've read more than seventy chapters, and it's pretty good so far, but why is the rating so low? If I were to rate it, it would be at least 8.5 Points!?

Like Ai, this age changes often.

I love watching it. I watch it every day. Is this update rate human? ! Chapter 16 a day is too much!

Theme, plot, writing, all three are good.

It's okay, at least the plot doesn't drag on, and the AI-modified human-like speech [face covering] [laughing and crying]

It's very well written. The protagonist is a capable and conscientious person.

If you have a lot of food and a lot of food, you still need a bicycle.

Although it is an AI article, the volume is large and the management is full.

Did the previous paragraph about Stalin's children combine Yakov and Vasily? The writing is okay, but some details could be paid attention to.

See Chapter 95. It's Chinese New Year again, eating dumplings again, and warming up the house. So lively. This couldn't have been written by AI. Beautifully done. After a hundred pictures, it will all be AI.

Although it is AI, it does not review manuscripts. But🍅there are very few articles like this that are about contemporary dining. Five-star reviews are given for feelings, not books.

I came across this book by chance, and it felt refreshing. The writing is concise and clear, and the writing is good. It gives me a sense of superiority through time travel, but I slowly intervene in a measured way. It's pretty good so far. Keep reading.

Suddenly I remembered my favorite movies, The Battle of Leningrad, The Quiet Don River, I love watching them

The structure is rigorous, the logic is clear, the plot is ups and downs, deep and meaningful. It is a rare time travel novel. It is not stupid or unpleasant. It is highly recommended to read it.