Before Goodbye, After Goodbye

I finished the first part overnight, excluding the ending, I liked it overall, it was very sweet. I was blindly searching for it, so I watched the second one first. I found out about the ending after being spoiled by the linkage. I didn't want to watch it at first because it was too uncomfortable. Then I watched it with the feeling that I would get stabbed. It was particularly good at the beginning, and it was very good until the finale. It's so sweet that I need to take insulin. Compared with the middle part of the second part, the middle part of the first part really feels like a breath of fresh air (mainly because of the lack of swords). I really like Jiang Mu's character, his personality is so charming. Such feelings are not very tempting to such a person who lacks love. Love is never fair. But he chooses what he calls "fairness" for the sake of the one he loves. No one can accuse him of taking advantage of his needs, this is the purest form of love. Reminds me of a sentence, "I can accept that you love someone else, how much I love you." Only when you have been caught in the rain do you know how to hold an umbrella for others. Love is complicated, and there are many ways to express it. I like his sobriety very much. Even if there is no green plum falling from the sky to give him he, I don't think he is a cushion when he is depressed. Except for the last 6 chapters, I think the first part is very good. Although it is not smooth sailing, there are hesitations and confusions, but in the end we will meet again in the sea of ​​flowers. The hardships of the process can better set off the joy of the ending. Purely subjective, I'm already dark enough, I can't accept dark be. But for the sake of he in the third part, the be here can be regarded as a stumbling block on the road to reunion, which is considered acceptable. Ps: Actually, I didn't have the courage to watch it originally. I planned to watch the second part and take two injections of insulin before starting a week of depression. I accidentally saw a review of the third part that said it gave the first part a happy ending. I really couldn't bear to watch the finale of the third season and some rebirth episodes, so I dared to relax and come back to the first part to experience their love. I will catch up on the third part tomorrow. Even if I know the ending as a complete plot addict, it will not affect my viewing experience. Instead, I will verify step by step that their love leads to the ending, and say the words that should be taken for granted~ Promise me not to write be

No wonder it feels familiar, it is very similar to Fourth Uncle's writing style. The beginning and direction of the story are very similar to Fourth Uncle's writing style. I just don't know if the ending will be the same (I really hope not). Blade warning⚠️ The author's writing style is very good. I hope he will publish more works.

It hurts, it hurts, it hurts It hurts, it hurts, it hurts, it hurts, it hurts, it hurts, it hurts, it hurts, it hurts, it hurts, it hurts, it hurts, it hurts, it hurts, it hurts, it hurts, it hurts, it hurts, it hurts, it hurts. It hurts, it hurts, it hurts, it hurts, it hurts, it hurts, it hurts, it hurts, it hurts, it hurts, it hurts, it hurts, it hurts, it hurts, it hurts, it hurts, it hurts, it hurts, it hurts, it hurts. It hurts, it hurts, it hurts, it hurts, it hurts, it hurts, it hurts, it hurts, it hurts, it hurts, it hurts, it hurts, it hurts, it hurts, it hurts, it hurts, it hurts, it hurts, it hurts, it hurts. It hurts, it hurts, it hurts, it hurts, it hurts, it hurts, it hurts, it hurts, it hurts, it hurts, it hurts, it hurts, it hurts, it hurts, it hurts, it hurts, it hurts, it hurts, it hurts, it hurts.

What the author writes is really good and great. Xiaoyu and Brother Zhang are so regretful that they really cried to death. The author is really empathetic. I hope the author will get better and better in the future. The novels he writes are getting sweeter and sweeter. Don't cut it anymore [flying kiss] [flying kiss] [flying kiss] [flying kiss]

I think it feels particularly good when paired with "Fractions". I remember that day when the sun pressed down on the plain The wind blows slowly and no one sheds tears Everything is so beautiful, so good that I don't need to speak Golden side face wearing all-white sneakers The wind continues to blow and the world continues to work So sure I know it's you That day you came into my life Thank you for becoming a fraction of me I can see you even if I close my eyes, the sunny south Even if I make a mistake, wait for me as time goes by Even if I stay, there will still be you and the night sky Who am I to let you do it for me unconditionally? That day you came into my life Thank you for becoming a fraction of me If I am more complete, it is also because of you One day you left my life Thank you for being a fraction of me I feel you breathing against my chest In that dawn that I can't go back to What fraction of mine You finally left my life Leave me who is getting older every day Please remember that I once loved

Because I read a relatively mature work by this author and it contained Easter eggs, I read his previous works (this one), and on this basis I would like to talk about my personal feelings and evaluation. Personally, I'm actually a little disappointed. The plot development is quite abrupt and unique. Anyway, my eyes went dark when I read it in the middle. However, the whole growth process is arranged, and the overall view is okay (I'm only talking about the protagonist, not the supporting role). It can be seen that the author is making progress. Considering that this is the author's first work (it seems so), I gave it four points (or three points, it is already good for the first time).

I hate meeting each other because we will eventually have to say goodbye again... I hate parting because we may not be able to meet again after parting... [Cry][cry][cry][cry][cry][cry][cry][cry][cry][cry][cry][cry]

How can I put it this way? It's a very good book and it touched me very much. I really admire it. I read it secretly in my dormitory (a high school student). I originally stayed up late as an exception, but now I can't sleep at all. I read this book in circles for a long time. I put it aside for a while, but I picked it up again now. I can honestly say after seeing the ending. The words are very regretful and painful, but also very true. You don't know which one will come first, tomorrow or the accident. The longing for the future and the contradiction of the unknown and confusion create life. I won't say more, there are classes tomorrow, and the butterflies of fate are making waves. I hope you and I can always find our own sea of flowers after thousands of sails have passed. 2025.12.5 ——Sun Luo Muqiu

Overall, it was pretty good. I enjoyed watching some of the sweet parts. The characterization was okay and there were many details. I still gave it a five-star rating [Love] [KISS] [Blow Kiss] [Like] But, I'd better give some sharp comments [like] (Personal opinion, you are welcome to give me advice, just don't scold me [send your heart]) Although there are many detailed descriptions, several places are quite repetitive, and the character creation is a bit complicated, especially the protagonist Ding Yu. The way he broke up in the later period seemed to suddenly change his personality, which was a bit extreme. Zhang Jingxuan's attitude of quarreling with Ding Yu was a bit excessive, but that was not the point. [Note] The tail knife part is a bit far-fetched. I think it's okay. I don't have the feeling of having multiple swords. Maybe it's because I read the comments and prepared myself mentally in advance. [Cover face] I watched this first in autumn and winter, so I felt that some of the plots were a bit too similar, such as injuries due to unexpected events, thorny family backgrounds, illness, injury, and amnesia. And it can be seen that Shushu is not very good at writing about daily life, and his love affairs are almost the same [Chigua] I think it is obviously borrowed from "The Road" and "This Separation", the writing style and character stories are somewhat similar. [Thinking] The reasons for the outbreak of those conflicts are somewhat far-fetched. Of course, it is not impossible to explain the direction of the plot based on the inner conflicts of the characters. The characters can also be shaped, but there are several aspects of the image that are not reasonable. Not much to say, overall it's pretty good. I watched it over the past few days during my break. When I saw the beginning of the episode where Jiang Mu gave Jingxuan a chance, and when Jingxuan and Xiaoyu got back together and then quarreled and broke up, I felt that it was very confusing. But it's not bad. The forced knife at the back still adds some interesting points to the novel. Keep up the good work, Shushu (I just saw that Shushu has released a new book, so I decided to read it)

After reading all three parts, I still feel that this one has more to offer. Although the third part gave this one a slightly better ending, I still long for the author to publish a rebirth novel [crying], featuring the best Zhang Jingxuan in the world [crying] [crying] [crying]

The content is very real, just like the author's personal experience (made up randomly), and it touches people's hearts. It is the best book to read so far. I already shed tears. Although I am now Be, we are still together in the end.

The writing is very good and the emotional lines are very rich. The situation of Brother Zhang when Jiang Mu and Xiaoyu were together really reminded me of Fang Datong's song "Quietly, far away, maybe reluctant to let go, silently, quietly, maybe it's worth it, I'm still waiting somewhere." Later, they quarreled again, broke up, and got back together, which also gave high emotional value. Although the ending is a bit unsatisfactory, the overall story is still very good! But it will be uncomfortable for a few weeks [almost crying]

I finished watching the first part in two nights. Overall, I feel that the writing is very good, and it touches my heart. Whether it is Ding Yu's emotional line (such as the separation and reunion with Brother Zhang, or Jiang Mu's company during the trough period, I rate it very highly). It is also about the emotional shaping of the supporting characters. In my eyes, the author did not neglect the supporting characters and allowed all the supporting characters who have appeared to have their due roles. I just feel that Jiang Mu and Ding Yu's separation and Jiang Mu's new relationship are too hasty. I think you shouldn't let go easily when you love someone, but this also reflects Jiang Mu's character and shows the depth of his love for Ding Yu (I don't know if that's right). The plot of Brother Zhang's transformation from cowardice to courage in love is also very good. Author, you are really great (I am sorry for Brother Zhang, my Xiaoyu [cry][cry]) I forgot one more thing, I think the relationship between Jiang, Zhang and Ding is a bit messy Now I have to complain about the author. I first read Dong Pang. After a few chapters, he gave me a slap in the face. My Lin Hao, I was so frustrated. I felt really unhappy. I stopped reading Dong Pang later, so I went to the author's homepage and saw the first part. I originally thought it was a sweet story but it turned out to be, don't kill me [crying][crying][crying], so I didn't dare to read the next two parts, so I only watched the extras in the second part, and cried again [almost crying], but I was hesitant in my heart, because I read the review of the third part, which said that Ding Yu was resurrected, and I was doing my best to mentally build up. Finally, I hope that the author's writing style will get better and better, and he will publish more works in the future (I want to eat sweets) (please please) Some advice for those who haven't read it: If you don't want to read it, just go to chapter 102. It's okay to be a bit jaded at the beginning, but at least the result is good, but chapter 102 stabbed me to death (I can't take it with me when I read other novels, all I can think about is Xiaoyu and Brother Zhang). Also, if you don't want to be stabbed, don't read the second extra chapter about Xiaoyu and Brother Zhang. Come on, author.

It's beautiful, I love reading it, who doesn't like this sweet little article [Blow a kiss]

It's very beautiful, and the story is well written from start to finish. Finally, a big one came to me and killed me with a knife. Knife Chapter 66 is a good choice if you don't want to chop.

The sweet story in the early stage was so sweet to me, but I was killed in the last few chapters, so I just pretended that Chapter 102 was the finale. The writing style is exactly the same as that of the fourth uncle. Sure enough, the author has also tasted the knives of the fourth uncle, and he learned it badly /ᐠ ｡‸ ｡ᐟ\ Can't you write sweet stories obediently? Overall, it's pretty good, and the characters' emotions are delicate. Especially the second reunion of Ding Yu and Zhang Jingxuan is very well written. "It's not forgiveness, it's carrying Not to erase, but to remember Not exile, but eternal bondage."

Beginning: It's a wise choice to be together. Breaking up, joining up, and stumbling are all things you need to go through on the road. If the result is good, it's OK. Ending: I wrote it to death. I cried while watching it while I was fishing at work. My colleagues asked me what was wrong QAQ [crying]

I unconsciously brought myself into the characters in the book. Looking at the lives of these people and thinking about my own previous experiences, I was always very touched. I hope the author can publish more novels like this. I like it very much.

Like is a heartbeat in a moment, admiration for someone when love first blooms in youth, a confession with courage, endless secret love, ever-present jealousy, and regretful miss.

It's very interesting. This article gave me a deep feeling. Love is really a beautiful thing. It can connect two hearts. In the process, there will be setbacks, quarrels, family pressure, or self-decision, but love can overcome everything. Two sincere hearts will be together! (Uuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuu

Pure be, don't enter if you don't like it (the protagonist dies in the end)

Very interesting gay article, the author will release a new work soon Why are you more dangerous than my fourth uncle? [Crying][Crying][Crying][Crying][Crying]

I really like watching it. Like this, what should Zhang Jingxuan do next? [Cry][Cry][Cry][Cry][Cry][Cry]

- Bana flower: The flowers and leaves never meet each other when they bloom, which means that they miss each other but can never meet each other. It represents despair and regretful love, and symbolizes the relationship that cannot reach the end.

In the end, the big sword broke my defense [I almost cried] Can the author write some endings in the future?

It's beautiful, but it hurts when the big be eats the knife at the end

Weiwei talked about some trends in the industry. Those who are new to the industry can read it. Those with experience can read it.

It's very sweetly written, but my own problem: I think it's a little weird. Overall it's very good and quite delicate. The previous writing is very sweet, and it could have ended with a happy ending or a beautiful imagination. But the author decided to cut the knife and end it in the most painful way. Not only is it uncomfortable for the readers to watch, but it is even more uncomfortable for those who are immersed in the scene.

The emotional description is delicate, and the author's writing style is also good. I haven't read a novel in a long time, but this one made me want to read more. It's so good.

It's good, the process is good, but what happened to the last chapter 107? Let me ask you.