Tianmu: the Unofficial History I Wrote, the Ancients Said It Is the True History

There are many interesting historical references, and the author himself understands them very well. It's just that the ancestors' reaction descriptions are a bit sparse. It feels like one video follows another, with not many reaction descriptions interspersed in between. But overall, it's pretty good and interesting.

It's a beautiful story, and it's not a nonsense. Some of the detailed historical chapters are different from the simple history that most of us know now. It has depth, and it doesn't make people feel like I read it once on Douyin, and another author made it into text for me to read the same thing again. There is no overly stereotyped historical figures, and there will also be profound negative analyzes of history in modern times, as well as comments that I can directly see. Most of the Tianmu texts do not seem to place so much emphasis on evaluating history and historical figures.

I don't understand why the rating is so low. I feel like it would be fine if it was more than eight points. Although there are minor inaccuracies, at least most of the historical facts are correct. You can read it even if you ignore the minor issues, and the writing is pretty good. Let me complain about other things first. For the video-watching category, there are mainly historical and non-historical categories, but both categories have disadvantages. The historical category basically only talks about history, and can only be used to understand history, unless the plot is written appropriately (referring to the proportion of the actions of historical figures after understanding them). Non-historical articles generally belong to the fun genre, but this kind of entertainment is seriously inconsistent with general historical facts, and except for the beginning, the proportion of famous historical figures that everyone wants to read becomes smaller and smaller towards the end (isn't the main purpose of reading this kind of historical article just to see your favorite famous figures? You can write about small characters, but it becomes more general and very boring as you go towards the end). The last thing is the control of the writing style. The proportion of the videos and the reactions of the ancients in this kind of writing is very important. Many of the videos I watched before were all written, and then modern people posted a lot of comments or comments, accounting for at least two-thirds of the whole text. The reactions of the ancients may be more at first, but will become less in the future, and they will not even write about historical figures at all. Instead, they will write general translations, such as the ancients were surprised, the ancients were guilty, the ancients were angry... Boring. I want to watch history, but most of them are purely about history, and the funny points are just hyped up. When I watch entertainment videos, I want to see the reaction of ancient people watching modern second creations and spoofs (such videos can also be funny while telling history, but not many people can write them, and there are very few). However, entertainment generally does not have much history, so naturally there is no such thing as what I want to watch. Okay, finally come to the topic I want to say. This article almost perfectly meets my needs: ① The protagonist of the tool is still there, and she is almost invisible in the back (I actually think this is good, some have to write the reaction of the protagonist of the tool, and the writing is very embarrassing), and reduces a lot of meaningless shaping (not to say that it cannot be shaped, the point is that many of them are written in a very awkward way, it is better not to shape, the writing is quite flat). ②I think the proportion of various arrangements in the article is great. There is no problem of having to finish a long video. It is appropriate to omit it. Secondly, there are comments about modern people, such as barrages. I didn't include a lot of them as is the common problem in many articles of this type. I chose very typical and short ones. The focus of the article is on the reactions of the ancients (it is well written, not embarrassing, but interesting to read), and what the ancients did after extracting details of historical events. There are also some entertainment aspects, but most of them are based on second creations by historical fans (I finally found what I wanted to read, and I am very happy). The historical figures who appear are mainly named and surnamed. Generally speaking, all aspects of this article are to my liking. As for the issue of lobbyists not being objective, I think there is no need to get too entangled. Even those who compile official history may not be completely objective. This article is already very objective. How can we completely abandon subjective consciousness? To say that it is too subjective, I feel that most of them see some negative information about their favorite historical figures in it, coupled with the belittling reaction of the ancients, which makes them feel subjective. However, as I said above, subjectivity cannot be completely discarded. Moreover, individuals have their own stains. It is normal for some people not to like it. This article is well written, and it is not overly direct and insulting. If you don't like it, don't read it.

I really like the canopy type of articles, but many of them are relatively mindless. This article has avoided all my red flags very well. First of all, the protagonist is a pure tool person without knowing it, and he does not live broadcast his daily life. It feels like he is voyeuristic, and he just watches videos. Secondly, 80% of the videos selected are historical, which can bring benefits to the ancients and appeal to readers who like this type of writing. The most disgusting thing is articles that use a lot of modern information. The ancients either can't understand it or are not interested. The word count is just water. In addition, serious and funny videos are interspersed, which avoids the boredom that may be caused by watching a single type of video for a long time. The selection of videos is good, and they are all up owners that I follow. I suggest you also write about Xudu Bar's dynasty chat group series, as well as some famous historical drama clips and their second creations, such as Ming Dynasty 1566, as well as the four famous TV series mentioned, clips and ghost clips.

The biggest feeling this book gives me is that it is really funny. Some of the unofficial histories I know, some I don't know, but they are all interesting [face covering] Who knows how to laugh until your courage aches while reading this book? The laughter is really dense, and sometimes you can learn some historical trivia. [Working on manuscript][Working on manuscript][Working on manuscript]

This thing in the old collection of the Confucius Mansion was dug up suddenly. Trivia: there are almost more than 8,000 pieces in the old collection of the Confucius Mansion, including all kinds of clothing and jewelry. In fact, there are no more than a hundred pieces of clothing and jewelry from the Ming Dynasty, two pieces of clothing from the Yuan Dynasty, and the rest are from the Qing Dynasty and the Republic of China. Also, this thing is from the Jinzhu Mami after the liberation of Qufu. , They were copied and registered after being found and registered by the Confucius Mansion. They were finally restored and put on display. It was not a voluntary donation at all. The old collection of the Confucius Mansion had been ruined by Hanfu merchants. There were many exhibits in 2012. I don't know why it was dug out by a group of marketing accounts last year to promote the Kong family. Was it intentional or what?

It's really good to watch. The videos are not all about entertainment, but are interspersed with historical content, and the descriptions of the ancients are very appropriate. It's not like other novels that are becoming more and more perfunctory and just write "the ancestors couldn't help but be speechless/laughing when they looked at

Can you write about Kangxi being the son of Hong Chengchou?

After watching it, I think it's okay. It's pretty good in this category. You can watch it. The overall quality is okay. The characters of the Ancients are pretty good, the dialogues are pretty good, and the video arrangement is OK. Overall, it's not too good-looking, but it's watchable. I won't continue reading.

I really like talking about cp, guessing characters with beanbags, and who is the undercover agent. Please do more🤲🏻 He also took out Emperor Wu and trampled him. The impression and view of Liu Ju's benevolence, gentleness and recuperation basically came from Sima Guang. Sima Qian did not praise Liu Ju, but he said that Liu Ju doted on Li Gan's son Li Yu (and doted on Li Gan's daughter). What kind of person is Li Yu? [The brave man Yu favored the prince, but he was interested in profit, and the Li family mausoleum declined slowly.] In Sima Qian's eyes, he was an unworthy descendant of the Li family. Ban Gu also did not describe Liu Ju's character and achievements. But one thing is written, that is, "As soon as I get to the palace, I will set up Bowang Garden above, so that I can communicate with the guests and follow their preferences, so most of them come in as heretics." That is to say, Liu Che gave him Libo Wangyuan and asked him to form a party in private. However, many of these guests are heretical scholars and are not very comfortable. Even if Emperor Wu is in his late stage, the people will not be willing to rebel against the prince when they hear that Emperor Wu is still alive. Think about it for yourself, if Emperor Wu is really that stupid and if the prince is really that good, why are the people unwilling to follow Liu Zhi? Regardless of the reason for Liu Ju's rebellion, it is a fact that tens of thousands of people died. If it is not dealt with, it cannot be justified. Otherwise, all future princes will be able to use this excuse to rebel? Look at how Liu Bing has dealt with the Huo family's rebellion and implicated the execution of thousands of families. What does the thousands of families mean? A conservative estimate would be tens of thousands of people.

This book is generally very good, but it has two major advantages and disadvantages. 1: Because it is all written in videos, you need to search for the original video on other software and watch the video once to better understand the novel. If you do not find the original video, you will not understand a lot of the content and will not have a sense of immersion. But precisely for this reason, reading the novel is more like reading the comment section of the original video. It's never enough to watch. 2: Because it comes from short videos, some of the content is not historical, but because it comes from short videos, you can learn some historical knowledge and content that you thought was unofficial history but turned out to be official history, and some that you thought was official history turned out to be unofficial history. Summary recommended viewing.

It's both rigorous and serious but also relaxed and silly. It's neither too serious and boring nor too silly and mindless. The combination of meat and vegetables looks very boring, and there are also explanations for inaccurate videos. Generally speaking, it's not bad. Watch it for fun when you're bored [please update]

It's okay, but it's best not to write too much about one character in this kind of historical video, because I was a little tired after seeing Li Er in several consecutive chapters. I understand that the author may like Er Feng, but for readers, watching multiple chapters of the same person in a row will not be good, so it is recommended to write them separately.

A more realistic Tianmuwen. Who would watch videos related to history? The author mostly wrote about some funny videos of the heroine watching other people's daily life, and some scenes of appreciating beautiful videos. He also wrote about the ancient people's recognition and understanding of modern life and "applying what they learned" hahaha, which fully embodies the sentence "the ancients are just ancient, but they do not represent feudalism" [heartfelt]

Please teacher, please update more and watch the videos of up fuck masters. I really want to see everyone's reaction. Combined with the barrage, it makes me laugh so hard 😂😂😂

Why is the rating so low? I think it's okay. There is no continuous live broadcast of the sky like other novels. There is no constant interaction like other novels. This novel is interactive with both the sky and the sky, not too much, not too little, just right. Anyway, I support it.

Okay, I rarely write reviews, especially for Chang Hong, but this one is really good. I think the rating of this book can be about 8 points or above. It is very interesting and interesting. I have read many similar novels. I think the author's writing is considered to be very good in this subject. As for Shi Tong, you need to have a certain amount of historical reserve, otherwise it will be OOC if you don't grasp it well. Some other articles make me feel The author seems to have put his thoughts on behalf of the characters. For example, some words such as "Laozi" and "Nudema" often appear, which makes people very uncomfortable and disgusting, and also makes the characters OOC. This book does not have it. Other articles will also disrespect women, such as Wu Zetian, who will use words such as "this girl's family" to describe her with a hint of contempt, but the author does not, and instead writes very well! Although there is not much description, it describes her domineering ambition as an emperor and her deep thoughts. Emm I don't know how to describe it, but it's very good❤ I won't go into the rest. Come on author, this book is very interesting and I look forward to its update! ❤

It's really beautiful! When the Tianmu talks about them, ancient people from different dynasties will have their own vivid reactions. The characters stand instantly and there is no sense of paper at all. Koke CP has also become better because of personal interactions and discussions among Koke friends from various dynasties.

The rhythm is quite good. It's not just a quick introduction to the Qin, Han, Sui, Tang, Song, Yuan, Ming and Qing dynasties.

Beautifully written However, I think it's a bit embarrassing for the author to write about ancient times and look at some situations in modern times (either it's unpatriotic or it's a bit embarrassing, that's my problem) It was probably about Qin Shihuang and Han Wu Emperor when they were scolding foreign countries. It made me dig my toes into the ground a little bit, but skipping it doesn't affect the plot. I really like the author's writing about unofficial history. Lu Bu's uterus is his hidden weapon (singing) There are also very serious ones: such as what is needed for rebellion in ancient times, the clan structure of the Song Dynasty, analysis of the Xuanwu Sect, why the order of favor is a conspiracy, etc. Netizens won't go too far when they complain about CP. The reaction of the ancients is also reasonable. Later, there is a video about them watching Shi Tong's popular CP analysis. The author successfully led me into Bangxin's trap. (I didn't finish the video originally, but now I've gone back to finish it.) Also, Wei Gu is awesome I don't know if the author is interested in Wangchuan Fenghua Lu. I would like to see them watch the video of Feng Menglong being chased by everyone in Wangchuan. I particularly recommend the song "Ancient Echoes". I hope the author can consider Wangchuan Fenghualu🌹

This book is very interesting. What I like the most is that the author used a lot of videos of my favorite up masters! ! ! ! Some are funny and some are popular science. They are very relatable. Many of them are videos that I have watched, so they are very interesting to read. I love them, and I will love to watch more! ! !

This is a book that I particularly like. The protagonist is basically a tool. There is not much plot, and there is no incoherence when skipping chapters. The character's personality is also well controlled. Although there are some minor flaws during the viewing process, the flaws are not concealed, and it is straight forward!

It's nice to read. The writing is a bit childish and exaggerated in the first few chapters, but becomes more and more sophisticated in the later chapters. The ancient people's reactions and video content are well combined, and each part is of moderate length. As a tool, the heroine does not jump up and down like other novels. There is nothing wrong with this subject matter. However, the sense of connection between the content of each video and the reactions of the ancients could be stronger. I would also like to see how the previous dynasties that were inspired by the video to reform developed in the future... Of course, it is okay to maintain the status quo, and I have no intention of giving guidance.

The writing is very interesting and the description of ancient people's reactions does not feel awkward. Tied! The author didn't play much with Ming Chao throughout the whole article, so why did Cheng Ming blow it [what]

It's just fun to watch. Many of the video chapters have beginnings and endings and end abruptly. Some of the jokes are not funny if you don't understand them. What the author writes about modern entertainment is better than official history (very few), and what he writes about official history is better than unofficial history (more), and unofficial history is very wild and only history is left (quite a lot). It is quite enjoyable once or twice, but after reading it more times, I feel a little tired, and the author writes it to the point where the ancients took it for granted and didn't care [face covering]

It's okay, the video selection is quite interesting. The writing and rhythm are just average

The book is a good book. Don't look at the paragraphs and commentaries. It is comparable to the wisdom of nudity. That is to think that you are omniscient and omnipotent just by reading some marketing accounts. I have not seen any real historical data. After all this, you can also search for explanations from officially certified historians or professors from the history department.

It's actually okay, but the review is a bit too positive, so I'll deduct one point.

I studied history just to understand this! Hahaha, it made me laugh so hard. Some of the plots also referenced Master Hunfan and Emperor Gao Zuwen of the Wei Dynasty, my two favorite bosses! This book is awesome!

It's beautiful. It's beautiful. I love watching this kind of ancient sky screen. Oh yeah