**

Very nice, very nice. Tang Ma, Tang Tui, can you all go and see us? This is so cool without CP! ! But perhaps because of the lack of CP, this book is not very popular. But the author's writing style is really good! Not a noob at all, the plot and emotional descriptions are also very exciting. I highly recommend it after 8 years of reading. Tang Xiaoyi, you will always be that high-spirited young man in my heart. I hope you will always be free. Don't look back, just keep going.

It's great. Although the word count is not as high as other popular fanfics (34,000), it can be read clearly and you won't be unable to follow the follow-up trend because you forget the previous plot. The psychological description is delicate, the plot is not procrastinating, and it focuses on the theme of "who am I" without any sidetracks. The author is great, super great!

I finished reading it at 23:25 on January 3, 2026, and found that it was too late! ! ! Highly recommended for everyone to watch! [Tang's first perspective + amnesia giant knife + not invincible plot is amazing (ooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooong)] It is really a very high-quality fanfic, that is to say, it is a real story in the book. The amnesia of Tang is very immersive, especially the death of Loki. He knows that this is not Tang, but he still protects him. As a clone of Tang, the sentence "short-term happiness makes him realize..." It kills me! ! ! ! Unlike other characters who are invincible upon first appearance, or fall in love with someone from time travel, which not only makes the original characters collapse, this one is pure black! ! (Of course there are only three or four like this) This is what happened in Tang's world, and it really fits. Tang's amnesia is the biggest highlight of this book. The author wants to find the real Tang, not the one-sided memory we have of him. He is also very short and concise, and the writing is very good. The descriptions in many places are really beautiful to me. How can you write so well! ! This also mentioned Tang's parents, Yu Zhi, Duo Duo Si, George, Yin Ling, I really, the writing here is really diverse [crying] This is the best fan work I have ever seen. I hope the author can write more. I will always pursue you! ! (Good knife, good knife [crying])

I have read it three or four times now (the following is the comment I made when I first read it, which was placed at the end of the chapter in the book. I want to comment again in the whole book) Please forgive me for my poor choice of words🙏🏼When I first read it, I felt that the language was mediocre and I just didn't feel it. What waves. But when I read it carefully, I felt the turbulent flow under the text, which is a bit like the combination of a third perspective and Tang's inner monologue. It is a writing style I have never read before. I feel a three-dimensional Tang Xiaoyi in the teacher's writing and what the teacher expressed is far more than just that. It has an indescribable feeling. Finally, thank you teacher for presenting such a good work.

It's very interesting. I don't know how to say it, but I think it's very well written. Although it's very short compared to other novels, it's very good and I really like it. I can see that the author writes very carefully. I really like this novel. It's really well written. I'm honored to read this novel. "They said that in that Chinatown, there was once a young man who beat horses and paraded through the streets. In that antique shop, there was a boy in a white wolf and Tang suit with a ruffian smile." "That young man always had three or five friends side by side, talking about his arrogant and unruly dream of crossing the ocean and the world. He stood in the fiery red sky. Sora smiled against the light, letting the evening breeze ruffle his broken hair. A glimpse of the young man in his prime..." "Then what? Then what?" "Then... He never came back." "The candlelight flickered, the lights were gray, after all, the wait was in vain." "There is no such young man in the antique shop at No. 42 In Chinatown." Duoduo: Tang Xiaoyi! Didn't you say it was dangerous to withdraw? ... What I said... Why doesn't it count! ! ! Tang Feng flies with the wings The dawn fog is about to disappear, so what's the problem? Wingspan covers the vast sky you are like a ray of sunshine Weave memories into a cloud The tune that lingers in my heart forever The melodious sound of the flute can be heard in the distance live in my heart

It's an excellent novel. It controls the characters very well. I really like the author's story.

Teacher, your writing is so good, you really captured the image of Tang Xiaoyi in my heart🥺🥺🥺🥺 I hope there will be more high-quality articles like this in the future. .

Is it a new book? It's so beautiful, why doesn't anyone see it? Don't be fooled by ratings I read it last year. I came across it by chance today, and I am still amazed when I read it again. Really brought Tang to life "Finally, thank you Tang Xiaoyi for spending my childhood with me, those happy times that flew by. You are one-half of me, and I will always like you." -Wing-

The writing style is very good, the description is very vivid, and I finally found a CP-free article! [Love] The whole book is about "I" asking "who am I", and the subsequent discussions about "life" and "memory" are also very in-depth. I feel that the author really thinks about these propositions seriously. There are also a lot of references to Nordic mythology, which suddenly seems to be very cultural. Many details are connected with the original work, as if the story really happened in the world of Chajiu, but Leo's illusion did not write it out. In addition, spoilers, although the ending is not he, it is really terrible [cry] [cry] [cry] (Author, you really stabbed me to death) This is my first time writing a book review, so I'll stop here. I saw that the data in this book was not good, so I wanted to write something to make up for it. I hope this book can be read by more people [laughs]

OK, this is my first time writing a book review! First! Author, do you understand the value of this~ I haven't read a few Cha Jiu Er Chuang, but I have read a lot of Harry Potter. I must say that this is the only one that makes me feel exactly the same as the original setting. There is even a feeling of "this is Tang Xiaoyi's future story". The characters are very full, and I feel that Tang Xiaoyi has been brought to life. The treasures of the Nine Circles - especially Tang Tui, Tang Ma, and even Tang Meng can be watched. When watching, be careful to keep your mind on it. There are some plots that you may not be able to turn around. You can ask the author in the comment area. The author is also a very enthusiastic little kid. Then I have to say, please prepare tissues when reading this article. I read it while I was doing my homework, because there was someone in the living room, so I left it there so as not to cry. I am almost exhausted, but the ending is he~ but there are sacrifices and sorrows. Finally, a little spoiler, if you don't want to see Baozi, run away! Yuzhi was not resurrected, but was killed with memories. Loki is dead. Windsor nearly died. In the end, can this barely be considered a long review? The author please come out and praise me! (Knife threat jpg.◉‿◉)

😭😭😭😭Tang Xiaoyi, the forever great adventurer——

The writing is good and the plot line is okay. Tang's first perspective + continuation after falling into the water + amnesia Bai Yueguang's return is really delicious! ! ! There is a touch of sadness throughout the whole story, without OOC, but the ending of the story is as impressive as when I first watched Charles IX. In the end, regret is still regret.

I like it very much, very beautiful. I haven't finished reading Charlie IX, I've only read a few books, but I don't know much about Tang Xiaoyi. When I was a kid, I wanted to look for it online, but I gave up when I couldn't find it. Now that I have grown up, I sometimes see him. I remember that a teacher played by him during a dance. My friend asked me who the teacher played by. I don't know but it looks familiar. I suddenly realized it when I saw him at home. That was the first novel I read in my childhood. I plan to make up for my childhood with O(∩_∩)O~~ This book is very immersive, and I feel like I am also searching and exploring. Want to have adventures and laughs with them. I would like to meet you in my dream(｡>∀<｡) When I saw Tang Xiaoyi when I grew up, I felt very happy and liked it very much. There is an indescribable feeling.

The writing is really great and the ideas are clear. Because there is no CP, the popularity is low, but it is a rare and awesome article that makes people admire it.

I really like the author's writing style, and Tang also writes very well! ! ! It's my Bai Yueguang Yi Di Nan Xian Wen! ! ! Highly recommended! ! !

This book itself is consistent with the original work in terms of plot development, writing style, characters, etc. From the plot logic, character description and other aspects, it is a very high-quality fan fiction work. In particular, Tang Xiaoyi's description is very exciting, with strong skills, smart mind, interesting soul and great spirit. Here I also put forward some of my own ideas from my own perspective: First of all, I personally think that the members of the DODO adventure team, especially the captain Mo Duoduo, may be able to reflect the inheritance of some excellent qualities, such as Mo Duoduo's wonderful reasoning in the 30th volume; secondly, I really hope that the Wolf King can survive to accompany Tang Xiaoyi, and I can try to reflect some of the interaction and mutual support between the Wolf King and Tang Xiaoyi.

Love the teacher storyline!

Beautiful... Brought tears to my eyes. I originally came here with the intention of watching the ending of BE (I don't know which book review I read about BE from), but I'm happy with HE! [Spoiler alert! ! ! As usual, I would like to praise the author first. His writing skills are quite good (at least in my current opinion), the character design is very good, and the decryption is not difficult or complicated. The story line can be sorted out with a little use of my brain. This can be considered very thoughtfully written. At least several of the more popular ones I saw on 🍅 felt OOC. At the end of the story, he is still the brazen, strong and brave boy in Tang suit. I didn't expect that the clone was real. For a moment, I really doubted whether "I" was Tang Xiaoyi? Is "Tang Xiaoyi" the real Tang Xiaoyi? (It seems that the book review I saw when I was looking for the book said it was from someone else or something) It's just too short and not enough to eat (still unfinished) (It seems like it would be better to write it longer? Then write it again) Dada really transitioned Tang Xiaoyi's process from "amnesia" to "recovering memory" very well. At the beginning, "I" was humble and polite, at least to the outside world, and then slowly transitioned to becoming venomous. Only when I finally "find myself" did everyone suddenly realize: He is really back! (I was still influenced by the book review I saw when I was looking for a book. When I saw it, I was still thinking: Is this Tang Xiaoyi truly finding himself, or is "I" imitating him so vividly? I didn't feel relieved until I read the postscript.) Finally, I wish you to continue your writing and your creations! (Mainly because I want to eat it()) 🍅Stop swallowing my book reviews orz Also, Thank you very much orz

Recommended by Tang Tui Qiang Split [I also strongly recommend] [I also strongly recommend] [I also strongly recommend] Very good, good, good, good, good, good, good, good, good, good, good, good, good, good, good, good, good, good, good, good, good, good, good, good, good, good, good, good, good, good, good, good, good, good, good, good, good, good, good, good, good, good, good, good, good, and it's a pity that I read it a little late [crying]. The author's writing is very good, and it even feels like he is reading the original work. Among many fans, it can be regarded as the best among the best. The plot is smooth, the setting is OOC-free, and it is very comfortable to read. It makes up for some regrets of the original work to a certain extent, but if you think about it, regret is also an indispensable existence in life. Among them are the spiritual inheritance of the Feather Team, Loki's farewell, Windsor's return, and the interpretation of life. In addition, Tang Xiaoyi's monologue under amnesia is very consistent. The setting of Shuangtang is really cool... There are many particularly good things, but I don't know what to say [crying] Anyway, take a look for yourself, you won't be disappointed.

It can be regarded as the first Cha Jiu humanistic book that I have read in its entirety. It is very interesting. I haven't read many first-person novels, but with the amnesia buff, the reading turned out to be very smooth and immersive. At the same time, it really made me think about "what kind of person Tang Xiaoyi is." That boy amazed me during my youth. It was short and gorgeous, and my memories were beautified to earth-shattering proportions. But there is no doubt that he was a very good person, so no matter how much he was beautified, I always felt that he was such a person. The author writes really well, so well that every time "I" in the book raises doubts about being Tang Xiaoyi, I will silently say in my heart, "It's you, you are Tang Xiaoyi." This is my first time posting a comment. It is dedicated to the first fanfic I have read. I particularly like Xiaoyi in the article, but I can't describe the feeling in words. I can only loudly appeal to everyone, "It's great! Read it!"

How to say it? My assessment is. If Leo Phantom is not well written, then I will recommend him as the new author (only my personal opinion, my parents are safe and healthy, everything goes well, life is smooth sailing, resist all bad comments)

Damn it, I cried when I saw it. I'm not good at writing, so I won't talk big words. The author's writing is really good, and the plot must be dramatic and exciting.

Such a good book, why isn't it popular? ! It's really beautiful. I kind of want to cry [cry][cry][cry]

The teacher's writing is so beautiful and true! ! !

There is no inexplicable whitewashing, and there are no uncomfortable views. I can feel throughout the whole process that this person is Tang Xiaoyi, and he has no CP orientation. The most comfortable fanfic I have ever read, and I see that it is not inexplicably sensational yet.

Tang Xiaoyi is not left behind

Super, super good-looking, makes the character of Tang Xiaoyi more three-dimensional

Here, Don seems to be really continuing his adventure in a place we can't see. It's really well written and great! Come on, author! Ahhhhhhhh why is it so well written but not popular!

Except for the knife, everything else is good

It's very good-looking. As Tang Tui, I feel so good watching it.