The Mulberry Trees Have Not Fallen Yet

Chen Yanzhi really makes people cry. He is in darkness but he is still trying to grow. I watched the author's 1V2, to be honest, I didn't hate it, but when I finished reading the updated part, I found that I still wanted Chen Yiyan and the heroine to have a 1V1, because Chen is worth it. Contrast this with Shen, who had an affair in his previous life and didn't treat the heroine as a human being. Most of the heroine's smooth life was shattered because of him. After finally regaining happiness, he indirectly caused the heroine's death in childbirth. It's hard to be reborn in this life. I hope that the heroine and Chen can stay together for a lifetime. As for Shen, the love he had at the beginning was something he didn't like, so don't give him a chance. A broken mirror cannot be reunited.

It's great to watch, Min and Chen are both good babies, Shen is so bad. While watching it, I couldn't help but feel sorry for the heroine and the hero. In my opinion, the second hero is a big b*tch, controlling everything, raising the heroine like a little pet. He has disliked the heroine his whole life but still controls her life. I hope the author will update it soon. I want to see the male protagonist become more powerful.

I'm very surprised to see such a good romance in Tomato. Shen Yunzheng's character is so three-dimensional. In his previous life, he was an antisocial personality and had an emotional disorder. But Shanshan is really true, kind and beautiful. It's not influence, but education, which leads her ex-husband to be a good person. Sister Bao's growth line is very well done, step by step. The character Xiao Chen seems to have come to save Shanshan. After the plot was completed, it was discovered that good deeds are rewarded. Shanshan, but do good deeds and don't worry about the future. My favorite sentence from the work: Min Shanshan cannot be a lion or a tiger, but she can be the best version of herself. Strong recommendation to give teachers motivation to write,

Xiao Shen returns from evil, but the character design is really interesting, but I stand firmly with Xiao Chen, he needs the warmth and salvation of the heroine who is like a little sun [laughing and crying] [laughing and crying]

I lament that the author has such awesome descriptions and characterizations of the characters. In the early stage, the main character did not like Shen Yunzheng. However, when he saw that in the previous life, Shen Yunzheng saw the heroine willing to die for Chen Yanzhi, he immediately let go and even wanted to end his life. In this life, in order to save the heroine, he knelt down and begged his disgusted grandfather. Shen Yunzheng suddenly went out of his way to criticize the anti-personality pervert. He has turned into a flesh-and-blood paranoid bamboo horse. I guess that in the previous life, Shen Yunzheng was more than just playing with the heroine because of his arrogant and extremely self-centered character. He never saw his own heart clearly. He was too confident in himself and looked down on the heroine. Only when the bird flew away did he see his true heart. He became so crazy and desperate when he saw the love between the heroine and Chen Yanzhi. Shen Yunzheng is so charming. I really look forward to what Shen Yunzheng will do next. I promise I won't be a eunuch [crying] [crying]! ! ! Ending 1v2 [crying] [crying] [crying]

The male protagonist and the second male lead are really two extreme people, one has a healthy personality and the other is an extremely dark and crazy person. Both of them are very charming, and the part about Chen Yanzhi is quite uncomfortable to watch. It is truly beautiful and miserable. I like Shen Yunzheng because I personally like this kind of crazy character design (I like it in novels, but not in reality). The heroine is really soft, cute, silly and sweet. Will the ending be 1v2? I kind of want both.

The plot is very novel and refreshing🍋🍋The lively and smart girl who is like an elf has a pure and silent crush on the action-oriented male protagonist, and the paranoid second male lead is evenly matched. The female protagonist was madly in love with the male protagonist in her previous life, but later discovered that the male protagonist was a selfish and paranoid lunatic. She later divorced and remarried the male protagonist, but died due to dystocia. After being reborn, I wanted to redeem the male protagonist and stay away from the second male lead, but I found that the male protagonist is a very good person himself and can succeed without being redeemed by others. Although it is a bit like a redemption story, it is more of a nurturing one. The second male lead is also very smart. He will subtly feel the coldness of the female protagonist towards him and take revenge on the male protagonist. It describes the female protagonist's helplessness that neither can change and her clear determination to change herself. Therefore, the second male lead and the male lead are almost as likely to appear. The author's description is very natural and not artificial. I believe you will fall in love with the heroine's character after reading it. I highly recommend it.

I like the heroine very much. She has a wise and foolish feeling. She is not internally conflicted. She is very cute. I feel that she is a very transparent person. I like her frankly and passionately. This is simply because of the living environment she grew up in and the special protection of people around her. In fact, the heroine herself also has her own way of thinking. She has continued to grow after being reborn. She also has her own way of dealing with difficulties. Some people may think that The heroine is pretentious, but I think this is the very cute thing about the heroine. She is a person who gives emotional value to the people around her. She praises her when she is good, and hates her when she is not. Her emotions come and go quickly, and she has a clear distinction between love and hate. It is originally the life of a young lady and a girl who has grown up doting on her. It is not illegal to be squeamish, and it is a harmless squeamishness (and the kind that is not annoying). It is also up to you to help others. To help others as much as possible, I think this is not a derogatory sense of the Virgin, but a kind of kindness that doesn't care. In fact, looking at the back, it should be that the heroine's thoughts are too idealistic, so what she sees in the world or her lifestyle is a bit close to, or subconsciously living the life she wants, so even if she is sad, she will slowly get better. She is a really cute and transparent girl, don't go Care about people who make you sad and hurt yourself, and only care about people who are good and important to you. In fact, many people can't do this. Although the heroine is squeamish and inert at the beginning, she also grows little by little later. Growth is often not achieved overnight, and it also needs to be gradual. I really look at the heroine like a daughter. She is a really cute person [Send my heart] [Send my heart] The author, please write it! ! I hope that the female goose can be happy, and I also look forward to the confrontation and running-in scenes between the male protagonists in the two control groups. In fact, I think the male protagonists have their own advantages and disadvantages, but as long as they can treat the female goose well and accept it, the most important thing is that they really can't bear to let the female goose be sad, so the male protagonist works hard to make them, and the female protagonist dotes on her! !

It's still good. I can see that the author is getting more and more into the mood as he writes. The most important thing is that I can feel the author's love for the heroine... This has surpassed most novels on the market. Both the early and late stages of shaping the heroine are very good. It is a novel that makes me feel good just seeing the heroine appear.

After watching the first half, I thought it was just average, and the writing was not very good, but the second half was interesting. Shen Yunzheng's emotional line was particularly well-shaped. Whether it was the friendship between childhood sweethearts or the story of growing up and liking each other, living abroad or even getting married, it was very full and smooth. As for Chen Yanzhi, I think his setting is too perfect. He is a male character born entirely for the female protagonist. This is more in line with the preferences of public readers. Whether in the past life or in this life, he always admires Min Shanshan, and he is a perfect match. So I quite liked the ending of the threesome, it was sweet and not cliché.

I read the latest one in one go and discovered that it is an unfinished story. It is really good. Some people may think that the heroine is silly and sweet, but personally I think Shanshan's character is very consistent with the environment in which she grew up. She is simple but not stupid, kind but sharp, and has a soft temper but can become brave because of the people she wants to protect. I like this little sun-like girl who is lively, bright and powerful. From her past life experience, Shanshan gradually understood what marriage really means to a woman. Although becoming a man's appendage can get material benefits and not have to work for a living, it will lose the independence of the soul and the thickness of the spirit. Once rejected, the fate of a woman in a subordinate position can be imagined. Life is precious, and I hope all girls can be independent and free in their precious lives. I wish you a bright future, a high-spirited life, and a happy life for us.

This article is beautiful! Chen is suitable as a husband, but Shen is really charming. It depends on how the two men balance their relationship with the heroine in the end. The heroine prefers Chen, but Shen may not give up on the heroine. I hope Shen can recover his past life memories, know how to cherish them, and not end up in a lose-lose relationship with the other male protagonist Chen!

It's very interesting. How can there be such good people like Min Shanshan and Chen Yanzhi? Especially the part where the author wrote about Shanshan feeding stray cats when she was a child is really cute. Shanshan is like a little angel. She planted the seeds of kindness and love in the heart of little Chen Yanzhi, so that our male protagonist still grows up to be the best even though he has endured so much wind and rain.

Everyone is showing me this! Super pretty! I vouch for this with my 8 years of book experience! The male and female protagonists are both super pure love warriors, and both of them are extremely sincere. I am moved to tears every time! The courage of young people really comes from love! Chen Yanzhi is always ready to die for the Shanshan he loves. He loves Shanshan regardless of anything and gives everything he has. I also watched Shanshan transform from the dodder flower in her previous life (actually it is not quite accurate, because Shanshan in her previous life also had the courage to leave the second male lead. She gave everything she had when she loved her, but after discovering that her lover was a devil, she resolutely gave up her luxurious life, left him to be self-reliant, and took back her love) little by little, she became the person she is now with the courage to protect her love. Both babies are super sincere and brave warriors of pure love! It's just that every time I'm afraid of being beaten up by the second male lead! The characters are all very plump and three-dimensional! Watching them grow up little by little makes me cry. The author's writing style is also very good! I am really moved by the love between them! I will cry when I see them happy! I will always follow you! This is my first time writing a long review, and it seems a bit incoherent. It's really good! (Actually, I came in after reading the book title "Shanshan" at first, hahahaha, because I have also been listening to the song "Shanshan" recently) Shanshan, you deserve all the beautiful love in the world

Super good-looking, and the male and female protagonists are people with sound personalities. They are normal people, not some materialized light. This book is a healthy, reasonable and normal book that is different from other campus youths and makes people's eyes brighter. The heroine is a silly girl in the traditional sense, not the derogatory one now. The male protagonist has a good outlook on life in that environment, and they are two good babies.

This book is so good that I read it all in one day. It seems to have more feeling than all the books I have read before. I can't explain this feeling, but I just want to read it. The characters in it, such as Shen, although he criticizes crazily, he feels a little sorry for everything he has encountered, but he Treating family ties or relationships, it's all... There is a heroine who is not like those books we have read before, such as silly, sweet heroines, or strong female characters. The heroine in this book makes me feel very energetic. They all say she is stupid, but she is not stupid. She is just sincere and kind-hearted. And although Chen is born like an ant, he does not give in. He is very strong and progressive, and he is also very good to the heroine. He is simply the god of pure love. No one in this world will treat you well for no reason, just because of love☞☜

2025.4.17 Min Shanshan: Shanshan is generous, bright, wise and foolish. It took me a lifetime to understand things, and finally I became myself. Shen Yunzheng: A lover without words. She was entangled with Shanshan in her past life and this life. I like this sentence, "After all, we have been entangled for too long and too deeply, and we have melted into each other's flesh and blood." Everything in his previous life was his own fault, but he finally understood how to love others. (I can talk, (happy)) Chen Yanzhi: Yanzhi is hard-working and humble in love with Shanshan. He is upright. Even if he loves Shanshan, he does not destroy Shanshan's family. Instead, he helps Shanshan get divorced when their relationship breaks down (which can be regarded as selfish) Life is entangled, flesh and blood merge into a blur. I prefer the ending together, that's it for the three of us. I think it's all up to Shanshan, whatever Shanshan chooses is the best. Personally, I like the image of Shen created by the author very much♡

Very, very beautiful! I really like the female lead, she is very cute and kind, and the male lead is also great. The scene where the heroine feeds cats and dogs when she was a child is so cute for both the male and female protagonists. The character of the male protagonist is also very good. He has not become mentally defective because of the hardships in life. He is still an upright person. My brother is also very good. I like him very much. He will definitely die from the tonic [I'm about to cry]. In the first few chapters of the second male lead, I thought he was just a childish and arrogant (not a complimentary) character, but later I found out that he was actually a mature pervert at the time, and the names he called the heroine were very annoying. I really hate the second male lead, but looking at it, I still hope that the ending will be 1v2, and the introduction is also 1v2. I still want to say that I particularly like the heroine because her baby is so cute!

I really like the heroine [Love], and the relationship between her and Chen Yanzhi is my ideal love. Although abnormal love is exciting, this kind of positive and healthy love will not make people lose themselves. The two people get along quietly and comfortably, and the process of mutual growth and improvement is even more touching, ahhhh! ! ! Confession to the author, I really like everyone in the book! ! ! [Love][love][love]

I should have given five stars to a latecomer [I almost cried] I watched 1/3 of it and thought it was a cliché about the second male lead chasing his wife in the crematorium and gave up on it. I came back today and finished watching it [crying] It is not a sugar-watered campus nor an American city, it is an ethical drama that entangles two lives [crying] My ex-husband cannot be simply defined as a scumbag. This is a character that makes it difficult not to The emotional character, the monster spawned by the family tragedy, once stole Xiao Chen's limelight [face covering] Sister Bao is a very good heroine, the two male protagonists love her sister very much, and they are normal people only when they are around her sister [smile] The whole story has a high-dimensional overlooking cold intelligence and fatalistic tragic tone, but it is diluted by the 1v2 ending. Highly recommended ~

Good-looking, good-looking, good-looking! The writing is good, the transitions are natural, the concept is very good, and the three characters are all three-dimensional. The love-hate entanglement between them makes me so happy. I like the feeling of my heart twitching. Shanshan is really good, gentle, strong and kind. She has grown a lot in the future. No one will not love Shanshan! The author portrayed the heroine very well. The character traits of the two male protagonists are also very obvious and memorable. I felt sorry for Xiao Chen in the front, and I felt sorry for Xiao Shen in the back. (Hey! Just like the author said, Xiao Shen did it himself. There was a misunderstanding but his lover missed it.) Shanshan and the two male protagonists have completely different emotional experiences. I like this feeling of hating the sea and loving the sky. It's so refreshing! The extra episode can be regarded as making up for the regret. It makes me sad but I feel happy at the same time. You three must always be happy.

The author's writing is great. The tension between the three people is really well written. In the end, the character is pushing the author away. The unreality of the paper man is very real. Shen made me feel like the characters in the novel are awakening. The author wanted to write an ordinary scumbag from the beginning. Man, in the end, the later part becomes more exciting, but I don't think 1v2 is a good ending for Shen. In fact, when I watched the beginning, I thought about 1v1, and when I saw the second half, I kind of thought about 1v2. But after actually watching the whole thing (including the extra), I subjectively think that the extra is just a piece of information given by the author to everyone. "Perfect", because the biggest difference between Shen, Chen and Shanshan is that Shen has really killed innocent people. This cause and effect can never be reversed. Human lives need to be repaid with human lives. He feels guilty not only for Shanshan but also for the lives of others. Just because he has never done anything in this life does not mean that he has not committed any sins in his previous life. Because he is reborn and his essence is still the same person, so I think Shen needs to atone for his sins. The 1v1 death ending is his real redemption. Shanshan will always leave him a place in her heart. Chen will always be with Shanshan. This is the perfect and incomplete true ending in my heart.

The writing is so beautiful. The student days occupies a larger space. I would have found it too slow and disliked it before, but now I understand that as long as it is well written, no matter how young it is, I will never get tired of it. I especially like the story of Shanshan and Yanzhi in the early stage. I feel like they are two little bitter gourds who go in both directions, and their love for each other has always been firm. I see that some people in the comment area think that the second male lead is more attractive, but the author's love for the first male is particularly good. People who can love others and are good themselves are also shining. Fortunately, they have never missed it in their lives! 1V2 is excellent. What you can't get is always turbulent. The heroine finally won two, and it was a matter of course! Boss, you write so well. It's so popular to follow you and drink spicy food. It's delicious! I saw the introduction, will the next book also be 1v2? So looking forward to it!

The writing is really, really beautiful! 🥳🥳🥳 I really like it! 🍀🍀🍀 🌸The thing that impressed me the most about this book was actually Shanshan. I think the portrayal was very successful. Every time I read about her, it was like encountering a warm spring sun, because she is very contagious.ヽ(✿ﾟ▽ﾟ)ノ 🌸It is not difficult to think that if you get along with her as a good friend, you will never have to worry about any twists and turns. Her thoughts are like a crystal clear stream, pure and clean. Such a girl will always lend a helping hand when others ask for help, even if she has to put in more effort. ╰(*°▽°*)╯ 🌸But, her kindness is not a compromise without a bottom line, but comes from the love and compassion for the world deep in her heart. When encountering issues of principle, she becomes extra determined, with undoubted strength in her eyes, which makes people understand that beneath her soft appearance, she hides an extremely tough heart❤️. For example, when she rejected Shen Yunzheng, she had her own opinion. Of course, it was just an example. 🍀🍀🍀 🌸She makes me feel like a happy, energetic and cute puppy. She warms the people around her in her own way, making people want to get close to her. O(*≧▽≦)ツ 🌸Also, Chen Yanzhi may look cold on the outside, but he is gentle and delicate on the inside. His hesitation and determination when facing relationships, and his struggle and growth in the face of life's setbacks are all deeply portrayed. Shanshan is a representative of enthusiasm and bravery. Her optimism not only infects Chen Yanzhi, but also infects us. Their personalities are somewhat complementary, making their interactions full of fun and tension, and they often smile knowingly at their sweet interactions. 🥰🥰🥰 🌸It's really super pretty! ! !

The heroine has a full three-dimensional design, and the description is delicate and unfolds slowly. When you see the title, you know that the author is narrating from a female perspective. The logic currently sees no problems and is coherent. And it's the first time I've seen two extreme male protagonists written together. It's very novel and unconventional. Regarding whether it is 1 or 2, I feel that I can accept it. After all, just looking at the writing and logic, the characters are quite good. It feels like it is slowly telling the story of a little girl. Let me mention it again, the most outstanding thing about this article is the delicate writing style and the character of the heroine, which make people feel the light breeze and the smell of spring flowers. I haven't seen such fresh writing style on tomatoes for a long time.

T^T I'm very satisfied. After reading the beautiful and sweet article, our cute heroine just wants to be happy. T^T The main text 1v1 and the extra 1v2 are very satisfying. I'm waiting to eat. T^T The rice is so delicious.

It's very beautiful, plain and simple. It's just the rebirth of an ordinary little girl who doesn't seek wealth and wealth. She just wants to live the present moment and be safe with her favorite people and family. This is the crematorium of the second male character chasing his wife, an unsuccessful series. The writing is particularly delicate, which makes the characters in the book plump and lively.

I can't do it anymore, it's so beautiful, the writing style is delicate, the feelings are sincere, the passionate love of youth makes my body warm when I read it, I rarely come across such good writing, author, I want to follow you [crying] [crying]

First! The heroine is really excellent! ! ! The heroine is very good! Second, hello Xiao Chen! ! Main text Xiao Chen is the male protagonist. Although I have finished reading the side story 1v2, I still feel a little empty. The female protagonist and Xiao Chen are both so pitiful. They have finally come to the end of their hardships. And Xiao Shen, how can I put it, if it is a normal novel, the novel will definitely be a male protagonist. And I personally feel that Xiao Shen's character is really not suitable for the female protagonist. I still like Xiao Chen, but as long as the female protagonist is happy! ! Shanshan, you and Xiao Chen and Xiao Shen will be happy forever! !

This book is really super good-looking. I haven't found the romance to be adulterated so far. You can eat it with peace of mind. To be honest, this book is really super good-looking. Although the heroine is a bit clumsy and dull, she is really cute and will not make people bored. The writing style is also very good. Okay, but it's not the finished article. Oh my god, I have to gain weight before I come back to read it. I don't want to live a life of hunger and satiety, waiting for updates day by day. I don't want to be passive. I want to finish it. [Blow kiss] [Blow kiss] [Blow kiss] [Blow kiss]