**

This book is really full of useful information. The author is a big shot in the history department. He used to know that Emperor Xin was hacked, and he also knew some of Emperor Xin's achievements, such as liberating slaves, but he only knew a rough idea. The author wrote it in too much detail, and there are historical records or archaeological documents to support it. Unlike those written by Yun Shuiwen, this book has too much useful information. My heart was racing, especially when I learned some historical facts that I had never understood before, such as the invasion of the Aryans. To be honest, I had never heard of it before. I had often seen reviews or novels advocating about the Qin Dynasty. What would happen if the collision between ancient Rome and the Qin Dynasty happened? There was a theory that what would happen if Western countries invaded historical powers such as the Qin, Han, and Tang Dynasties? But few people know that Western countries actually invaded ancient China in history. The Aryans, a nation that destroyed the world's three major ancient civilizations, invaded the Shang Dynasty, which was ruled by Wu Ding at that time, and were defeated by Fuhao. This incident has a lot of controversy on the Internet, but the author supports this incident from many angles. Regardless of whether it is true or not, at least the author writes in detail and objectively. This novel is really wonderful, and it shouldn't be rated so low. After reading this novel, and looking at other novels with the same theme, I feel that those novels are all written by Yun, and their writing is too ordinary. In comparison, this one can be regarded as a god.

It is very well written👍. The five-star review has made more people read this good article. After reading this article, I realized that the Zhou Dynasty was basically a group of newborn kings, and the Shang Dynasty was basically a group of sage and sage kings. I was not familiar with the history at that time. I guess the Shang Dynasty of the sage and sage kings must have defeated the newborn Zhou Dynasty.

It can be seen that the author has put a lot of effort into it. It is unique in the inventory article. Starting from the Shang Dynasty, it is also a historical blind spot for many people. There are many viewpoints that subvert cognition, some of which I know, and some of which are the first time I have seen it. After reading the comment area, I just want to say that it can be seen from the article that the author is talking about the good things about the Shang Dynasty and a lot about the bad things about the Zhou Dynasty. However, it is undeniable that historical evaluation itself is very subjective. Everyone knows that the Zhou Dynasty is too good, and it is not inferior to the author. He is just talking about things other than the well-known good things. Wouldn't it be interesting to have more different opinions? I feel that it is very well written. Although some of the settings feel a bit awkward and there are some inappropriate wordings, the flaws are not hidden and it is very good among similar articles. A small suggestion to the author is that he can list the reference papers in this chapter and use facts to prove it. There should be fewer negative reviews. You can also give us some popular science and go to CNKI to check it yourself.

It's a good book. I hope the author can keep writing until the Republic of China. He should take his time and don't rush or skip dynasties. I see a lot of people saying that the author is talking nonsense and giving low marks. What I want to say is that you can read the author's book as the Romance of the Three Kingdoms. You can see for yourself how outrageous it is compared to the Romance of the Three Kingdoms and the Romance of the Three Kingdoms. The author's reasoning is much more reasonable [face covering]. According to the official history, the Shang Dynasty, Zhou Dynasty and various forces seemed to be fighting like fools, and there was a sense of fragmentation in various places. I prefer this kind of conspiracy and intrigue, which feels more real. This is originally a novel, and there is a lot of interesting information in it. I hope the book will not enter a dark room, and I wish the author's data will get better and better. [Top post][top post][top post]

Super good-looking, highly recommended, starting with Wu Ding and Women's Hao. From the perspective of slaves, Emperor Xin was more kind than King Wu of Zhou. It talked about what kind of story Sima Qian really wanted to express when he wrote the "Fenghuo Opera". It is said that the descendants of the survivors of the Shang Dynasty established the later Great Qin. The Qin people did not eat a grain of Zhou rice. They were not a vassal state of Zhou, but on the same status. The ancestors of Qin obtained fiefs for the Zhou emperor to herd horses. This is just a misinterpretation. This is not the true history. It really changed my view of history.

Yes, the author's articles are full of useful information, and I learned a lot of knowledge. I originally thought that I had read no less than a hundred historical novels, and there was nothing I didn't know. After reading the author's book, I felt that I was ignorant [face covering] [face covering] [face covering], so I must give it a five-star rating!

Clear organization and well-founded opinions! The most amazing article in popular science history! ! ! There are a thousand Hamlets in the eyes of a thousand people, and there are countless years of history in history books. Therefore, every time I read a historical article, whether popular science or time travel, there will always be countless people arguing in the comments. It is difficult to distinguish between superior and inferior, and it is difficult to distinguish true from false. The strange thing about this book is that it has been argued by countless people and failed to win. The arguments are clear, consistent with the background, consistent with human nature, the logical chain is complete, the reasoning is smooth, and consistent with social development. The arguments are well-documented and credible. The history books, which used to be strange and full of contradictions, have become smoother and smoother. The ancients no longer make people feel stupid and ignorant, but their true wisdom has a soul. The best article in popular science history! ! ! I saw a lot of low scores, one or two points, but they all just said a few words about this and that, and I couldn't bear to say a few more words to talk about the arguments and the argumentation process. I don't care, I don't care, you are wrong. It's really funny. It's quite a kind of pride that the whole world is drunk and I am alone [laughing][laughing][laughing][laughing]

This book is really good, rich in content, and the evaluation is very objective. The author has a multi-faceted understanding of the real history, rather than simply understanding the surface from textbooks and short videos from marketing accounts. He also writes in more detail, and maintains a better balance of evaluations between men and women. There are many writings of the same type. From the female perspective, it is easy to be too exaggerated and pretentious. From the male perspective, it is easy to stereotype, arrogant and trample female characters. The focused historical content is suspended in the flow of short videos. There are too many errors, too much subjectivity, fragmentation or too short-sightedness. This book is very balanced and very comfortable to read, but the author writes very carefully, so the battle line of this book is probably going to be very long.

The quality is very good, but some characters do not fit his ideas at the time, and as we all know, there are many places in historical texts that are highly subjective to the author. It's a bit of a headache to read, mainly because of the part about Liu Bang and Lu Pheasant, which doesn't fit the situation. The article contains the author's strong subjective ideas.

Dialectical simple historical materialism. In the historical inventory, there are sacred books in tomatoes. And as far as I can see, there are very few written before the Qin Dynasty, and the emperor's achievements are clearly and clearly written. It's awesome👍. I deeply doubt that the author is a student of history. Please protect it. I suggest that it can be double opened at a certain point. I feel that many people should accept it, and it can be regarded as an alternative and lively and interesting way to introduce history to us. Peeling away the cocoon, clearing the clouds and seeing the sun. The writing is excellent. Niu Niu Niu

A rare historical novel, well, it shouldn't be considered a novel. The author uses a large amount of historical materials and archaeology to present us a different history, which is great. Come on, it's best to publish a book when it's finished. I've read it twice. But it's not easy to take notes. It's better to have a physical book, so that you can add your own understanding, so that readers who like history will have a deeper understanding and appreciation.

To be honest, this is the most culturally rich article I have ever read. Other Tianmu texts are written in one step, just like reading a history book. This book introduces the historical background and cultural background. In addition, the social background at that time and historical research allow us ordinary people to understand history. (I used to feel very boring when reading history, and I couldn't understand what it meant.) The author must be a history student or historical researcher. Come on⛽! I rarely read serials, but I will definitely follow this article!

This can only be said as yyds. Let me use the people's view of history to evaluate ancient emperors starting from the Shang Dynasty. You will find that the so-called sage Zhou was cruel to the people, while the cruel Shang was sage to the people. Di Xin is not the so-called faint king, but a holy king. He is well-deserved to be hailed as the last human emperor. The author of this book is not like other authors who either make it up randomly or translate it directly from historical books. His scoring criteria are the priority of historical materials: archaeological relics > official revised history > private revised history > unofficial history! Viewpoints accepted: modern scholars > ancient historians! Use of historical perspective: Civilian historical perspective > Heroic historical perspective! Materialist Dialectical View of History > Single Perspective View of History), believe me, you will not stop reading it. If you are interested in history, as long as this book is not blocked, I will keep reading it.

I recommend this book. Many comments are entangled in the author's rating, the small theater interspersed in the novel, and the definition of historical perspective. Don't you understand that this is important? Shouldn't we struggle with the thinking logic of the author's inventory? The most important thing in reading history is the logic of history. According to the logic of "Romance of the Three Kingdoms" or "A Taste of the Three Kingdoms", there are always a lot of idiots in history. So what does the reader feel after reading it? Isn't this just another form of stupidity? Most people are serious about reading history books, and they can still find useful things in the complicated history books. The author said, "There is a threshold for reading history." This is a good statement. If readers only want to show off their knowledge and brag, just read it as a novel and enjoy it. As for the historical data and logic in this book, does it matter whether the author has added personal information? As long as the historical data are true and the logic is well-organized, isn't it a mature way of thinking to analyze characters who can be included in history books as normal people? Does the truth matter? Most of the time it doesn't matter. Everyone speaks and does things from their own perspective. The most important thing is that thinking and logic are the most important! Whether it's conspiracy theory or facial expression, does it matter? If you don't know the evil of human nature, you don't know the value of good. Abandon the black and white outlook on life, and learn to use stance, interests, and specific issues to analyze concretely. This is the highlight of this book. After all, it can write things that are not known to be true or false, so that people instinctively feel that this thing may be true. Isn't this the successful output of a way of thinking? Whether history is true or false is nothing compared to this thing. The truth is the business of historians. Isn't it enough for individuals to read history to inspire their own way of thinking or to enjoy it? Personal views only represent personal views. Does it matter whether others agree or not? Aren't there people on the Internet who have great preaching ideas? I think so too - "The main theme is a person who does whatever he wants, Ai Xin Xin"! Again, to ordinary people, does the truth matter? ? ?

The common people's view of history is finally no longer mindlessly boasting about Emperor Qin, Emperor Wu of Han, and Emperor Tang Zong and Mingzu! Every battle has a clear logic. The author worked hard to check the information [Love]. I will keep chasing. I hope the author won't be fooled! I have been kicked into the trap by many authors!

It's okay, I can read it, and the comment section is quite entertaining. By the way, if you want to read the Ming and Song conspiracy theories, you can go. The author uses the traditional Mingbao Zong and Wanyan Jiumei, not the conspiracy theories of the traitorous civil servants Zhu Qizhen and Zhao Gou

The best thing about this book is not the reaction of the emperors and ancients when they saw the inventory, but the author's interpretation of history. Unlike other books of the same type, this book interprets history in the most concise terms. It really made my scalp numb when I read it! The author's perspective is really unique. I've read a lot of novels, but this is the first time I've seen this. Explain and analyze history from all angles, find out the true face of history from every corner, and it really has historical basis! The author is really awesome, and the history he wrote really shattered my three views. I used to think that Sima Qian was just making it up, but after reading the author's book, I realized how well-intentioned and powerful Sima Qian is. The explanation is very comprehensive and clear, and the history is really scary to think about! I was really shocked by the wisdom of the ancients. Is this genius? I raise the banner for Di Xin! This is the gold content of the Human Emperor! ! ! In addition, the article uses interests to describe all motivations and causes and effects, and human nature is clearly written, very logical, and feels very real. I just couldn't survive the first round. While reading the book, it really helped me understand history. However, the shortcomings are also obvious. If the inventory is said to be at the god level, then the reaction of the ancient people who looked at the inventory seems to be a little bit worse. It feels like many people have lost their character. Isn't the author not very good at writing this aspect? Of course it's also my own opinion, but I still hope the author can improve it. The author must keep writing! Don't run away! It's really beautiful! I believe this book will become popular one day! You must insist on writing it down! ! ! [Crazy][Crazy][Crazy]

Wonderful, with historical data and not boring. It is objectively analyzed based on the background of the times, rather than just boasting about the benefits. I have always felt that ancient times are not that simple. The ancestors are really awesome. Come on, support.

Niubi, I was a little annoyed by reading Shang Dynasty earlier, so I skipped a bit to read the Bolangsha part. The argument is very rigorous. I need to read this book carefully. Well, while telling the ancients not to be superstitious about divine authority and suppressing divine authority, and at the same time sending merit rewards from heaven, what is this?

I feel that this book tells the true history. The author's writing style is the best, much better than other cycloramas. I look forward to the author updating it soon. I stayed up all night to finish reading the book.

1 This novel is very good, but it cannot be read as history. Many historical materials cannot be found on Baidu and other browsers, or the meanings are different. For example, it is said in the article that Emperor Yi returned to his sister because Emperor Yi took his sister back, but what I found is that Emperor Yi married his sister. In addition, the article said that Shang King Wending killed Ji Li and married his daughter to Ji Chang, and then Emperor Yi returned to his sister. However, there is no record in the existing historical materials that Wen Ding killed Ji Li and married his daughter to Ji Chang at the same time. Another example is "Guisi, Yi Zong, Emperor Wu of the Yi Dynasty." Zhen: Wang Qishao offered sacrifices to the Tang Dynasty, and the tripod blessed his second mother (daughter). His blood was three, and his blood was three, and his blood was three, and he was right. "This text says that two women were used to sacrifice to the gods, but what I found was that two women were sacrificed to the gods. 2 This novel is still readable, such as the application of game theory in the text. If you want to know more about it, you can take a look. It is still useful for studying humanities, history, and humanities. 3The recorded history is still true. The general direction is correct, but the details are wrong. 4 Regarding the common people's view of history and the heroic view of history, I read some comments saying that the author is actually using the heroic view of history. This is a matter of opinion, so I won't go into it. I usually like to read historical videos and novels. I rarely read official history, let alone some professional historical terms. This is the first time I have heard of civilian history and heroic history.

Very good! The beginning looks very good, and there is a basis for many things. I like to read it. It has more feeling than those imagined historical novels

The author is great. I have read several novels about emperors before, and I have also been poisoned by some novels. Now I no longer read this type of novels, but when I read this one by chance, I seemed to have returned to the excitement and shock of the first time that year when my three views were shattered. I can only offer "nb" and ask the author to keep updating. I will always support you.

A very in-depth book. The profound analysis of various historical figures is refreshing. [Like][Like][Like]

It's a very good book. It clearly distinguishes between public and private matters and personal emotions are not so important.

The writing is good, unlike other people who brag for the sake of bragging and black for the sake of blackness, who all one-sidedly say whether an emperor is good or bad [like] [like] [like] [like] [like] [like] Just like the historical records of Zhu Qizhen are rubbish, but judging from the general environment of the Ming Dynasty and other records, it is not the case [laughing and crying] [laughing and crying] [laughing and crying] [laughing and crying] [laughing and crying] Judging from the dark conspiracy theory, the emperors of the Ming Dynasty were all pitiful people, and they were all killed by Confucianism. From a historical point of view, from the Shang Dynasty to the Qing Dynasty, they were all destroyed by Confucianism. I have obviously been reading and listening to books for almost 20 hours, why only nine hours [Thinking][Thinking][Thinking]

It's quite good. From the description of watching the movie, it feels quite fair. The reasons are given, historical records are written, and detailed analysis is made. When watching it, it feels reasonable. It can also be seen that the author really understood the information when writing. The main reason is actually that the author did a rational analysis instead of blindly criticizing right and wrong. This is really rare. I have read many articles of the same type. The writing in those articles is really outrageous, and they are fair comments. In fact, they contain countless personal emotions. It can be said to be a work of catharsis of their personal emotions. No one knows what the true situation of the characters in history is. After all, the results are based on the records of later generations and the analysis of current historians. So I feel that this book is good, at least it looks at the problem rationally, rather than just talking about right and wrong, who has made great achievements and who has brought disaster to the country and the people. But in the final analysis, this is a novel after all. If you have to take it seriously and find faults, it's really not necessary. It feels good to be able to achieve this level. I hope it will be better in the future. Stay impartial, analyze rationally, and be well-founded. Don't be like other movie-watching articles where your personal emotions take the lead.

The writing is very good, although some characters feel wrong, for example, Li Shimin, who so-called loves the people like a son, loves landlords and scholars, not common people! [Laughing and crying] Maybe it was deliberately made up to arouse everyone's emotions! Overall, it's really good. The author has a very rich reserve of knowledge. There are many historical events that I didn't know about. It's very informative! I would like to ask you, I have written almost 1,000 chapters now. I thought I could select some of them and publish them. If it is not expensive, I can buy them for my children!

Some of the interpretations are interesting. Many controversial and doubtful contents were indeed found using AI, and the logic is basically self-consistent. In addition, deductive reasoning can be roughly 70% true, 40% mainstream historians' opinions, and 30% only recognized by some scholars. It is already more professional than many historical celestial texts. As long as the author does not purge the Qing Dynasty later, we will be good friends forever. The updates are too slow, and I am getting anxious and impatient while waiting for the inventory of the First Emperor. There are a few trolls in the comment area, and the author sometimes writes chapters to refute them. It would be better to block them and read them again for a better experience.

[Like] [Like] [Like] [Like] [Like] [Like] [Like] It's very beautiful, very perfect. I personally have an opinion about this book. Some people say that the author is making it up. I want to ask you why you think that if you know it, it must be true. Besides, this is a (online novel) similar to Fengshen Bang, Lotus Lantern, and Seven Fairies Descend to Earth. I think it is because it is logically logical, has a clear theme, and is full of interest. It is written on the label. It is a historical brainstorming article. Can you understand it?