Rose***

The Rose on TV lives her own life and is the best version of herself. The Rose in the novel is an exquisite girl who pursues love.

This story is particularly similar to the experience of a friend of mine. She bloomed passionately like a rose in the book, but was hurt by emotions. Now she has become a strong woman, which most people look up to. In fact, I still feel that she needs equal and free understanding, as well as subtle care and care. But she maintains her brightness and pride, and there is still the light of stars in her eyes~ Although I can only read the first story, I am already very satisfied. The writing is smooth. It is recommended that people between 28 and 40 years old will feel more comfortable reading it~

I watched the last chapter and waited for it to end. After it ended, I felt like it shouldn't have ended like this, but it couldn't get better than this. The rose is written from the third person perspective, but there is no first person point of view of the rose. Maybe this is a rose that exists in illusion and in beautiful memories🌹 1. From the brother's perspective in the first part, roses are bohemian, passionate, and youthful roses that wither at the right age🥀 2. The rose in the second part is in a dead state, which is also the rose's own choice, or the gardener's unbearableness is used to set off the withered rose. Ordinary people are not worthy of it, so the gardener was given the rose for 9 years and 3 months, and gave birth to a small rose, but he was trapped for the rest of his life because of the beauty of the rose. The little rose looked too much like the radiant roses that the gardener had seen, so he was afraid of seeing the blue tear mole that was so similar to its mother. He was too ordinary, and he was afraid that the rose would leave him, but he could not avoid it, because he knew that the rose did not belong to him. 3. From the younger brother's perspective to the older brother's perspective, I don't know if I am making up for the "divinity" of the rose. I couldn't fall in love with Zhuang Meigui, so I wrote another perspective with a fiancée, letting "I" abandon my fiancée to express my true love for Rose. It's interesting to see a comment on "Rose's Third Party Story". People always like to use a man's philandering as an excuse for a beautiful woman to be charming. The middle part of the story likes to say that no one is perfect. For us in the new century, we often say: If we grow up to be like xx female celebrities, I will be more arrogant than her... In the early part of the story, Rose will have excuses. Her brother's friend abandoned his pregnant wife for her... This is a very cruel point. Everyone is blaming Rose for not refusing, but is Rose's rejection useful? But the author may want to express that Rose is willful and unrestrained and does not care about other people's eyes (or maybe the era at that time was relatively Western and there is not much discussion here), so she has never refused. It may also be that in Rose's heart, such behaviors are not considered out of bounds, right? 4. I forgot which perspective (I remembered the perspective of Little Rose's husband). The more I looked back, the more exciting point of watching Zhuang's pursuit but being rejected kept lingering with me. Unexpectedly, this is not the kind of episode where the father instructs the mother that the mother is not a good person at the beginning, and then they get to know each other and then reconcile. Nor is it forcibly paired with Little Rose to make up for the regrets of the protagonist from the third perspective. This clip made me feel that no matter how similar the described rose is to the little rose, everyone is a unique individual. Not all luxurious life is suitable for everyone. When they face the luxurious life, they enjoy it but panic, knowing that it is only a short-term fear of losing it. Before the 1990s, Chinese people spent their entire lives pursuing houses and cars. After 2000, those born in the 2000s enjoyed the success of their predecessors and began to live a life with choices. After all, it is different. 5. I would like to call the last one called "Dramatic Life" very exaggerated. After seeing Zhuang's appearance, I thought about how I would regret seeing the sparkling rose. Yes, he deserved it, but when I saw the first step of Rose's first love, I felt very strange. Why didn't I accept the rose because it showed that I was different? Or is he really an exception among the many who love roses? Or out of loyalty to his fiancée? Adults will have adult considerations... Then he gave me the answer. He was afraid that he would not be able to grasp the rose when facing the rose, and he was also afraid of losing everything he had. It took me half a day to read this book. Some details may not be detailed, and some characters may have forgotten their names. The above opinions only represent my personal feelings after reading it. 2023.06.12 03:26 Am

Wow, I have lived to be almost fifty years old, and I have read a book by a popular author in my girlhood. People really do grow with age. I can't give this book full marks because time has dragged me forward and I can no longer accept the true love in those dreamy wealthy families described by Yi Shu. If Liu Yifei hadn't starred in this drama, I wouldn't have read this cliche book. However, older books have always been with me, such as The Besieged City, Dream of Red Mansions, and The Book of Songs.

I read this book because of the drama starring Liu Yifei, and wanted to know what kind of person Rose is, but I was disappointed and always felt very depressed. The characters are beautifully created, but it's like seeing flowers in the mist. Maybe it's because I'm old and can't bear to see this so-called love at first sight.

Autobiography of four men. All I heard were their "Rashomon"-like justifications and experiences in life. The beauty of the heroine is the foundation of all stories.

There are still a lot of changes in the drama version. Rose, a woman who is passionate about nature, constantly growing, and always beautiful. Everyone loves roses, but she always follows her heart and insists on herself.

To be honest, this is the first time I read Yi Shu's novel, and I unexpectedly liked it very much. After I finished reading it, I thought that all the comments in the comment section would praise the novel. However, I read a lot of reviews that said the book was not good. Most of those who did not recommend it simply listed the general plot of the book in brief and concise terms, saying that the story of Rose was too old-fashioned and cliche. But I didn't realize it at all. I even felt that when feminism is now popular again, this book can't be said to be a fan, but surprisingly it doesn't stand against it. This book is not just a simple story about she loves him and he loves her and she doesn't love him and he doesn't love him. It explores what love is in the story, including bringing readers to reflect on what is love? Do people actually need love? A novel that only writes about love is not pretentious, and it does not mean that you should be disdainful of this novel because it only writes about love. Love is an unavoidable topic in life. Even if you say you don't need love, you are still talking about love. In addition, in the story, such as the changes in Rose's character and views on marriage and love, Huang Zhenhua's changes in character and views on marriage and love, etc., As the story progresses, everyone has new insights over time. Only after reading carefully can you realize their changes. As for those who have only briefly read the plot and then concluded that "The Story of the Rose" is a lackluster work, I will only think that your emotions are not delicate enough and this book is not suitable for you. There is no need to criticize Yishu to show your inexplicable superiority. I hope you will never be influenced by the TV series or some reviews without reading the novel carefully before reading "The Story of a Rose". This novel is well worth reading.

When I was in high school, I loved reading my teacher's books. But now that I'm middle-aged, my mentality is completely different when I read novels! Perhaps the background of the novel at that time was that Hong Kong was still a capitalist society, and its values ​​were different from ours. Therefore, the protagonists in the book could love as they pleased, just follow their own feelings, love without scruples, and think that they were free, real, and casual. But I actually like Mrs. Huang and Zhou's ex-wife in the novel, because in addition to love, they also have family, responsibility, and morality. Ethics. Not having love means everything, the world will not revolve around you, everyone has their own responsibilities to bear in life, hard work, career, family, love, friendship, etc. Straightforward and true love is beautiful, but don't promote so-called love by stepping on the wounds of those around you.

I give five stars because the author wrote it very well and is very real. Rose is also a beautiful person, but she only loves herself. I can't help feeling her decisiveness, daring to love and hate, and I hate the men in the novel who are attracted by sex. It's no wonder that Rose is beautiful, and girls will fall in love with her. I feel disgusted when a man abandons his girlfriend for her and betrays his wife. Since you have a girlfriend, a wife, and a fiancée, you must keep a distance instead of hanging around Rose all the time. Rose does not reject others and allows others to love her, which is also very selfish. Some people die for roses, but what I'm most afraid of is that some people are very extreme. They want everyone else to get them if they can't get them, or they deceive others. What should they do if they want roses? They have to pay for their own choices. If the rose is an ordinary wild rose, will others still love her as always? No, I see the influence of rich people here. Without money, no family background, no talent, and no flowery appearance, will others fall in love with her? I just want to complain that the world of rich people is such a mess. The yellow rose is a charming and touching rose. Her final tenderness is as gentle as water, which is hard not to like. Ask if the TV series is good [I learned it] [I learned it]

The Rose in the book is more childish in her love and affection. Although she has no career ambitions, her beauty is not aggressive. What I like most is the way she is immersed in love when she loves. When you don't love, you no longer miss or recall

Although Yi Shu's novels are a bit far away from this era, they describe human nature vividly. Several adapted TV series, from the plot to the actors, the acting skills are also just right. I have rarely seen novels and TV series together.

You will understand only after you have seen it. The beauty of a rose is due to her sincerity, authenticity, and purity. Although this does not conform to the mainstream aesthetics, so what? Who cares whether a rose needs to cater to something? She should be a flower blooming in spring. She is beautiful without knowing it, and she comes and goes as she pleases.

I was shocked that this was a work from the 1980s. The awakening of Hong Kong women and the awakening of women in big cities in mainland China will take a long time to reach small cities...

I watched the TV series and the original novel at the same time. The Yellow Rose in the TV series is more real and does not make people look uncomfortable. In addition to her beauty, she also has many qualities, such as being studious, persistent and motivated, and being extremely affectionate. The yellow rose in the original novel. Apart from her beauty, she is the most loving and holy person, but from a female perspective, she would think that she is too beautiful to be true. In my view of values, she is purely destined to have good fortune and does not have much agency. At the same time, it's a bit contradictory. Could it be that a person with the most love would choose someone he doesn't love to marry for ten years because of a broken love? Of course, the reason why I love TV series more than the original works is because the scripts are adapted to cater to current mainstream values. For example, Huang Mei Mei's father and mother in the TV series made people feel so warm~ But the mother in the original book did not make Huang Mei Mei feel maternal love. For example, the ex-husband is such a decadent and ordinary person in the original book (from Huang Zhenhua's perspective); and the ex-husband in the TV series graduated from a prestigious school and started his own business in the IT industry, but declined because of his controlling personality. In the era when anti-PUA was prevalent, Huang Meigui left him, and the plot and character were tenable~ I can't understand Fu Jiaming's part in the TV series. Maybe it's because the lead actor is too old and his looks are too good for his hips. I can't understand why he didn't choose his first love at this time? Maybe this is intentional by the screenwriter. Although first love is good, it will eventually pass away, and you can't go back even if you want to [cover face][cover face][cover face]

After watching the TV series, I didn't feel like I could relate to the original work. I personally feel that the TV series version is more in line with Rose's character, especially Liu Yifei's performance, which perfectly interprets Rose's growth process. However, the story of Rose in the original book is a bit hollow. Maybe the storyteller left out many details, or maybe the rose in the book is just a rose in the eyes of others.

I finished reading "The Story of Rose" by the author [Yishu] at 05:43 on June 22, 2024. The book currently has a score of 9.1.

Roses seem to be the embodiment of love in this world. Pure love attracts everyone. Some people are stuck in love, living in the past and unable to move forward. Some people choose others at different times, give up love, and then live in the love they lost. Some people have seen love, felt it, and continue to move forward, just because in this world, besides love, there are other very important emotions.

A book that makes people think is a good book. Although the era and life this book tells may be far away from ours, everyone today has the shadow of these characters. Rose is a very passionate person, but she is more like a character in a dream. In my eyes, she is not a beauty, she is smart but not arrogant, she does not care about the outside world, she does not seduce anyone, she only cares about her own feelings. Although many men fell in love with her, she sometimes did not explicitly refuse (but she also did not agree), which was just due to her temperament (a book is written from a male perspective, so it is inevitable that some people will not understand or even hate roses). Secondly, there is the beauty of roses. I personally think that the beauty of roses is not just about appearance. Her unique temperament is one of the reasons that cannot be ignored. Her beauty is not artificial or pretentious, and her understanding of aesthetics is transformed into her clothes (Yishu rarely uses facial features to describe her beauty, but more often uses metaphors and what she is doing and what she may be thinking to describe). This kind of free and unrestrained beauty is what the world pursues. We cannot be Rose, but her personal charm and her stories are rare spiritual wealth. There is also the fact that this book is written about Rose from the perspective of others, which makes Rose's personality more ambiguous (it may be written from Rose's perspective. After all, most novels are unfolded from the protagonist's perspective, and we will prefer to understand Rose. I think this is one of the reasons why this novel is by no means a superficial love novel). There may be a layer of filter added, and it is a filter in the eyes of men. At this time, Rose is more Like a pure land that men pursue, the embodiment of their beautiful fantasies, and this kind of beauty has fascinated so many men. Is this more like a dilemma of Hong Kong capitalism at that time, people were exhausted in interests and favors. It is difficult for such a woman who is not disturbed by worldly dust not to become the white moonlight in the hearts of people at that time (not just men, but especially men).

I came here to read this novel because the drama has become very popular recently. I saw a review of a novel written more than 40 years ago. You can't use any three-dimensional view to evaluate it, and you can't be too serious about it. People who are serious about everything are not suitable for reading novels. From the perspective of the novel alone, it is very well written...

Yi Shu is a Hong Kong writer who is good at writing about the love, struggles and dilemmas of urban men and women. However, the era is different and the views are different. I don't like the men in this novel. They always marry their current wives despite not loving each other.

When Master Shitai publishes a book, it is always extraordinary. Every word is precious and every word is touching. This book is written in a self-narrative tone from a man's perspective, so it is easy for people to think that Rose has many faults. Just like Rashomon. In fact, each of these men (except for the eldest brother) is worse than the last! And they attributed all their mistakes to Rose.

People love some people and marry and have children with other people. I think the whole article highlights this point. Many times I confirm this statement and start mentioning it many times. But Rose is different. She pursues love and marriage. She is the same person. She pursues love purely and truly. It is also said that roses are color-blind butterflies in the flowers. They cannot see love at all but are wrapped in love. Others, she understands love. I think the love she pursues cannot be given by ordinary people.

I think it is wonderful. No one is perfect. The whole life of Rose is full of passion. Seeing from multiple angles, Rose is not only beautiful, but also gentle and affectionate. She has her own charm. Modern beauties are dragged down by family livelihood and can no longer maintain serious love and enjoy life seriously. Those who have the conditions are also very corrupt and casual. In middle age, who can still love purely?

I read this book many years ago, and recently read it again because of the TV series. It still has the flavor of the original book, pure people, sincere love in the heart, and the weaknesses of human nature. It is completely relieved and it reads very smoothly.

This book reflects various people's views on love, and makes a more detailed analysis of the attitudes of various characters in real society towards love. The author supports the value of love in marriage, and can serve as a better reference for modern people's views on love.

After watching 11 episodes of the TV series and finishing the novel, I thought the TV series was better at first, but I personally felt that smashing the house was a bit exaggerated. I continued to talk about the feeling after reading the novel. I personally think it is wonderful, pure and beautiful, and there are no roses in reality. More people's lives are the second choice, so I personally think it is well written.

After reading this book, I couldn't calm down for a long time. The concept of love collapsed and then was re-established. It is a book worth pondering. This book portrays the protagonist very well. From being disappointed in love in the early stage to being unswerving in love until death in the later stage, the brave Huang Meigui and Huang Zhenhua who know how to weigh the pros and cons (the early love marriage is happier) are smart and transparent. Su Gengsheng, who can read people's hearts, Rose's pursuer, soul mate Fu Jiaming, first love Zhuang Guodong, Fang Xiewen who walks through the marriage hall side by side, and Mr. Luo and others. The novel describes Rose's love experience with different partners, telling each story while also revealing the other side of human nature. Mr. Huang and Mrs. Huang are recognized as a couple, but the reality is that the husband does not understand his wife and becomes her husband's shadow, and then Mrs. Huang resists. "No one is perfect" "People love one group of people and marry another group of people" "A blessing in disguise is a blessing in disguise" and so on. I think this book has benefited me a lot. Sunk costs do not participate in major decisions. No matter how much you pay, there is no limit to turning back from the sea of ​​suffering.

Why do many people like roses? Probably because he likes her free and easy attitude. She has had several relationships, whether it was her first love, getting married and having children, meeting someone she loved, and finally marrying someone who raised her as a child. She is always so free and easy. She has been sad, sad, and confused, but she has never been entangled. Dare to love, dare to hate, pick it up and put it down. The sun is shining, dare to be yourself, wear the clothes you like, do the things you like, and don't care about other people's eyes. She knows where she is strong and where she is lacking, and she understands herself very well. This is probably why she married Sir Rodham. It is the dream of many people to live their life according to their own ideas, and she did it.

It's bloody and crazy, so what is true love? Is it the moment of falling in love with each other when we meet, or is it a choice made after being bound by morality? Weighing the pros and cons can be a person's reason, and liking can be said to be a feeling, but love is not. Love is an impulse that is unreasonable and inexplicable. If you say you will never understand love if you have never loved before, then will it be a disaster if you suddenly fall in love with someone you shouldn't love? (The flower language of yellow roses: pure friendship, fading love, waiting love).